In R v Lakeman[2026] EWCA Crim 4, the Court of Appeal held that ‘gold pieces’ in an online computer game constituted property for the purposes of s4 Theft Act 1968.

Background

The gold pieces were recorded as entries in a ledger kept by Jagex, the developer and publisher of the game. The terms and conditions stated that they could only be redeemed in game and that Jagex could delete the gold pieces or anything in game bought with them. Sale or gifting in the real world was forbidden. An employee of Jagex hacked into user accounts and transferred a large number of gold pieces to accounts within his control which he then sold in the real world for fiat currency.

Decision

The Court of Appeal stressed that the definition of property for the purposes of theft in the criminal law was not the same as the definition for the purposes of private law.  However, they did consider the Law Commission’s consultations and reports on digital assets and previous cases dealing with digital asset property issues, coming to conclusions that will be relevant in general, and it is this discussion which we consider here.

First, the Court supported the Law Commission’s conclusion that digital assets are real functional things distinct from the code that instantiates them. The ecosystem of software, players and code allows the gold pieces to appear visually, to be traded in the game and to have other functional attributes. It is these manifestations together that constitutes the gold piece, not simply the underlying data. Copying the data underlying a gold piece would not copy the gold piece. It followed that what must be evaluated to determine whether it constitutes property is not the underlying data but the ideational object constituted by the combination of people and software and manifested visually or otherwise by the system.

The Court concluded that gold pieces could exhibit the attribute of ‘rivalrousness’ – that is, use and consumption of a gold piece was inconsistent with somebody else using and consuming it. Jagex had the ability to delete any gold piece at any time. The Court pointed out that this was relevant to permanence, but not rivalrousness. An object might only exist for a short time but be rivalrous during the term of its existence. The Court adopted the Law Commission’s example of the melting ice lolly which can only be consumed before its impending ‘runny end’ (as the Law Commission rather poetically puts it in its Consultation Paper, para. 10.110).

The critical quality that the Court considered was permanence. To be considered property, an object must have a sufficient degree of permanence or stability. This is the quality that the Law Commission assumes that in game objects will often be lacking. Here, the Court held that it was sufficient that the gold pieces had “a small degree” of permanence, even if Jagex could unilaterally delete them at any time. They drew the analogy with coins, which could be withdrawn as legal tender at any time and would then cease to exist as currency (although the physical object would remain).

Key takeaways

The approach of the Court to permanence is highly significant in placing more weight on real world practice than it does on the design and implementation of the system.  Whether a digital asset is permanent usually starts from an analysis of the system that constitutes that asset: whether it is distributed, cryptographically secure and independent of persons or legal systems, so that no individual person or group has the power unilaterally to destroy it. Here, Jagex could destroy the gold pieces at any time.  The system itself exhibited little permanence. But the Court focused instead on the practical aspect: that the game had persisted over time with users prepared to import a high degree of value on the objects contained within it.

This approach is likely to lead to an expansive view of which digital assets constitute property. In particular, closed, permissioned systems may well satisfy the requirement for permanence, even where a single person within a permissioned system could unilaterally create or destroy assets. Many uses of blockchain technology within financial markets involve permissioned blockchain ledgers.  Designers of these systems must now upgrade the likelihood that objects created within these systems attract property rights.  This will affect the web of contracts that underlie these systems and the process for transfer of and creation of security over the digital assets within them.

The Court of Appeal’s wide definition of in game digital assets as property in the criminal context is of distinct interest. We look forward, for instance, to the first prosecution for theft of a player who beheads another player with his longsword or incinerates them with a magic fireball and then steals all their gold. But looking purely at the implications for civil law, this shows the progressive approach of the English Courts to dealing with digital assets. Treating digital assets as ideational objects constituted by the entire ecosystem of data, software and users is a powerful concept that allows principled and consistent development of the law. Further cases are likely to explore the minimum degree of permanence needed to constitute a digital asset as property in private law.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post