On September 14, 2026, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decided In re Kia Hyundai Vehicle Theft Mktg., Sales Pracs., & Prods. Liab. Litig.: Ins. Subrogation Appeal, No. 24-5219 (9th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026), a decision that will increase litigation filings in California against foreign manufactures when their goods move through the state’s ports.

Key takeaways

  • Port routing is a forum contact. A foreign manufacturer listed as shipper of record on bills of lading for shipments to and through California ports purposefully avails itself of the forum, even if title and risk of loss pass FOB origin overseas and a United States subsidiary handles importation, inspection and inland logistics.
  • Designing a product for the US market need not target California specifically. While US-specific design alone is not sufficient to establish jurisdiction in California, high volume shipments through California ports supplies the “plus” under the circuit’s stream-of-commerce-plus framework.
  • Shipping volume can support a pleading-stage inference that a defendant’s conduct arises out of its forum contacts. Where shipping records showed that more than 70 percent of the Korean entities’ US-bound vehicles moved through California ports, the court concluded it was reasonable to infer that many of the allegedly defective vehicles at issue were shipped to California.
  • Reasonableness and out-of-state claims remain a live issue. The panel left the seven-factor reasonableness inquiry to the district court on remand. It also declined to decide whether specific jurisdiction differs for state-law claims of insureds injured outside California, because the manufacturers forfeited that Bristol-Myers Squibb argument on appeal.

Background

The appeal in In re Kia Hyundai Vehicle Theft Mktg., Sales Pracs., & Prods. Liab. Litig.: Ins. Subrogation Appeal, No. 24-5219 (9th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026) arises from subrogation claims filed by approximately 200 insurers, suing as subrogees of policyholders whose vehicles were stolen or damaged due to the lack of an engine immobilizer in certain Hyundai and Kia vehicles. The insurers asserted warranty, consumer-protection, fraud, unjust-enrichment and failure-to-warn claims against Hyundai Motor Company and Kia Corporation (the Korean entities) and their US distributors.

Plaintiffs alleged that the Korean entities had two California contacts: (1) thousands of shipments of vehicles and parts to and through California ports for sale by the US subsidiaries—more than 70 percent of Hyundai Motor Company’s US shipments and approximately 77 percent of Kia Corporation’s; and (2) a US-specific design that omitted immobilizers from standard-trim vehicles sold in the US.

The Korean entities moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, submitting declarations that the US subsidiaries imported the vehicles FOB origin from Korea, took title and risk at the Korean shipment point and handled port inspections, processing, unloading and inland transportation. The US District Court dismissed the Korean entities from the subrogation track, finding shipping records as insufficient to show intentional aiming at California and held that the claims did not arise from or relate to any California conduct.

The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding that, at the pleading stage, the complaint adequately alleged purposeful availment or direction and that the claims arose out of the Korean entities’ California contacts.

Ninth Circuit analysis

Pleading-stage record: Contradicted allegations disregarded

The panel first addressed the plaintiffs’ argument that the district court improperly weighed competing evidence. Uncontroverted complaint allegations are taken as true at the pleading stage. Yamashita v. LG Chem, Ltd., 62 F.4th 496, 502 (9th Cir. 2023). But a court “cannot assume the truth of allegations in a pleading which are contradicted by affidavit.” LNS Enters. LLC v. Continental Motors, Inc., 22 F.4th 852, 858 (9th Cir. 2022). If both sides submit affidavits, conflicts are resolved in the plaintiff’s favor. Here, however, plaintiffs did not file competing declarations—they merely pointed back to the complaint. The district court therefore correctly ignored the allegations that the Korean entities advertised vehicles in the US or controlled aspects of US distribution.

Purposeful availment and direction: Ports plus US design

Because the complaint mixed contract and tort theories, the court analyzed both purposeful availment and purposeful direction and emphasized that Ninth Circuit law does not draw a rigid line between them. Briskin v. Shopify, Inc., 135 F.4th 739, 751 n.10 (9th Cir. 2025) (en banc). On availment, a defendant must take affirmative steps that allow or promote business in the forum—deliberately reaching beyond its home by exploiting a market there. On direction, the defendant must commit an intentional act expressly aimed at the forum state that causes harm the defendant knows will be felt there. Placement of a product into the stream of commerce, without more, is not enough, even if the manufacturer knows the stream may carry the product into the forum. The circuit applies a stream-of-commerce-plus test: the defendant must indicate an intent or purpose to serve the market in the forum state. Asahi Metal Indus. Co. v. Superior Ct., 480 U.S. 102, 112 (1987) (plurality).

Two allegations, taken together, satisfied that standard.

First, shipments to and through California ports. Even though the Korean entities did not themselves retail vehicles in California, they “expressly aimed their intentional, and allegedly tortious, actions” at California by sending thousands of shipments to and through its ports. The panel relied on Yamashita, 62 F.4th at 504, which treated shipments to and through a forum port as a “sufficiently deliberate contact” because both shipper and consignee rely on forum law to protect property while it is in the jurisdiction.

The Korean entities characterized the theory as pure stream of commerce. Title and risk passed FOB origin in Korea; US entities imported the vehicles. The panel was unpersuaded. The Korean entities were the shippers of record on the bills of lading, and their declarations “conspicuously do not deny that, as shippers, they controlled where the vehicles were shipped.” This was not a case in which an independent distributor later chose the destination, and plaintiffs were not asking the court to impute the subsidiaries’ contacts to the parents. “By placing vehicles on ships bound for California ports, the Korean entities purposefully availed themselves of the forum and purposefully aimed their goods at California.”

Second, US-specific design. The Korean entities argued that targeting the US is not targeting California. Plaintiffs did not contend that the immobilizer omission was designed to appeal to California customers as distinct from customers in other states. The panel answered by extending Briskin v. Shopify, Inc., 135 F.4th 739 (9th Cir. 2025) (en banc)—a case dealing with internet platforms—applying that decision’s holding that “differential targeting” or a “forum-specific focus” is not required. 135 F.4th at 757–58. A defendant “expressly aims” its conduct toward a forum state when its contacts are “sufficiently deliberate,” even if it cultivates a “nationwide audience.” Id. at 758. Requiring California-only targeting would produce the “perverse effect” of allowing a company to aim at all 50 states and escape specific jurisdiction in each. That reading, the court observed, accords with Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, 592 US 351 (2021): if a manufacturer serves the market in several or all states, it is not unreasonable to subject it to suit in one of those states when the product injures someone there.

The panel was careful to note the limits of its holding: “We do not suggest that the U.S.-specific design would by itself be sufficient to establish personal jurisdiction in California.” It was the combination of the Korean entities’ shipments to California ports and US-specific design that demonstrated defendants “purposefully ‘reach[ed] out beyond’ their” home to “‘deliberately exploi[t]’ a market in the forum State.”

Relatedness: The products that caused the injuries were the products shipped to California

The second prong requires that the claim arise out of or relate to the defendant’s forum contacts. Ford Motor Co., 592 U.S. at 362. The “arises out of” test requires a but-for causal connection between the defendant’s contacts and the plaintiff’s claims. The “relates to” test does not require causation but nevertheless demands a “close connection between contacts and injury.” Yamashita, 62 F.4th at 506. Because the court found but-for causation satisfied here, it did not need to consider the “relates to” test.

Plaintiffs’ injuries, the court held, were caused by the products the Korean entities shipped to California. The complaint alleged more than 7,500 Hyundai shipments and more than 5,000 Kia Corporation shipments of vehicles and parts through California ports for delivery and sale to California facilities. Defendants themselves recognized the inference: they sold vehicles in Korea knowing some could end up in California, and some insureds were allegedly injured in California by the claimed defect.

The panel flagged, but did not decide, a Bristol-Myers Squibb issue. Defendants did not argue that the relatedness analysis differs for a nationwide class or for state-law claims premised on losses of insureds injured outside California. That challenge was forfeited. Foreign manufacturers facing mixed in-state and out-of-state class claims in a California MDL should preserve the point in the district court and on appeal.

Reasonableness reserved for remand

Once the first two prongs are met at the pleading stage, the burden shifts to the defendant to make a compelling case that jurisdiction would be unreasonable. The Ninth Circuit weighs seven factors: purposeful interjection; burden on the defendant; conflict with the sovereignty of the defendant’s home state; the forum’s interest; efficient resolution; the plaintiff’s interest in convenient relief; and the existence of an alternative forum. Freestream Aircraft (Bermuda) Ltd. v. Aero L. Grp., 905 F.3d 597, 607–09 (9th Cir. 2018).

The district court never reached reasonableness, and the parties did not brief it on appeal. The panel left the issue for the district court on remand.

Implications for foreign product manufacturers

The decision is a pleading-stage ruling in a high-volume automotive MDL, but its reasoning is not confined to automobiles or to California ports. Counsel advising overseas manufacturers that sell into the US through affiliates should treat it as a practical guide to Ninth Circuit specific-jurisdiction exposure.

A well-supported affidavit can knock out a complaint’s most ambitious jurisdiction allegations. The practical lesson is significant in MDL practice: a foreign manufacturer that submits specific declarations addressing who contracts for carriage, who is named as shipper and consignee, where title and risk pass and who directs port-of-discharge decisions can neutralize a complaint’s most expansive agency and control theories before the court ever reaches the three-part specific-jurisdiction test.

Shipping terms do not erase shipper-of-record contacts. FOB origin, CIF and similar allocations of title and risk remain relevant to the commercial relationship between parent and subsidiary. They are not a jurisdictional safe harbor when the foreign entity is named as shipper on bills of lading bound for a US port and does not deny control over destination. If the foreign manufacturer wants the US affiliate’s import activity to be treated as the affiliate’s own contact rather than the parent’s, the declaration should affirmatively state who selects the port of discharge and who contracts for ocean carriage. A declaration  that is silent on those points—as it was here—will be treated as a failure to rebut the shipper-of-record allegation, leaving that allegation susceptible to being taken as true.

US-specific product configurations create an additional “plus” factor. Under the panel’s analysis, designing a product specifically for the US market—by adding or omitting features relative to international versions—can combine with shipping contacts to satisfy the stream-of-commerce-plus standard. The holding does not require that the product configuration target any single state. Manufacturers that maintain distinct US-market specifications should account for this factor in their jurisdictional risk assessment.

Volume-based inferences can bridge the relatedness gap. When a majority—or otherwise very high percentage—of US-bound product moves through a single forum’s ports, the court may infer that the products at issue in the litigation were among those shipments, even without evidence linking any particular unit to the forum. The court relied on the fact that more than 70 percent of the combined shipments passed through California, making the inference probabilistically reasonable. Manufacturers with lower forum-port concentrations should not assume this inference will be equally available to plaintiffs.

Preserve the Bristol-Myers Squibb argument. The panel expressly declined to address whether the relatedness analysis differs for a nationwide class or for state-law claims of insureds injured outside the forum state, noting that defendants forfeited that argument. Foreign manufacturers facing mixed in-state and out-of-state class claims should raise that challenge in the district court and on appeal to avoid forfeiture.

Conclusion

In re Kia Hyundai Vehicle Theft reinforces that the Ninth Circuit will treat shipping records and US-specific product design as purposeful forum contacts sufficient to confer specific personal jurisdiction at the pleading stage. Foreign manufacturers that ship goods through California ports as shippers of record—even under FOB origin terms—face meaningful jurisdictional exposure in California when their declarations fail to affirmatively disclaim control over the destination of the goods. The reasonableness inquiry and the unresolved Bristol-Myers Squibb question remain open issues that may further shape the scope of jurisdiction on remand.

Contact