We have collated a brief round-up of important recent cases, procedural developments and hot topics for businesses to help in-house counsel stay up to date, particularly those who are involved in managing disputes. You can access more detailed briefings using the links. Please contact us if you would like further information on a topic.

Part 1 – Contract law and directors’ duties

Part 2 – Procedural updates (privilege and disclosure, jurisdiction, ADR, court structure)

Part 3 – Hot topics for businesses (Generative AI and disputes)

1. Contract law and directors’ duties

Our pick of the recent cases for commercial lawyers:

Saxon Woods Investments Ltd & Ors v Costa [2026] UKSC 21

This decision provides important guidance on the standard of conduct required of a company director when they genuinely disagree with their fellow directors as to the best route for achieving success for the company. The Supreme Court confirmed that a director who intentionally delayed the sale of a company and deliberately concealed that from the board was in breach of his duty under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 to act in good faith to promote the success of the company.

The company and its investors had agreed to work towards an exit by the end of 2019. It was not sufficient that the director sincerely and subjectively believed he was acting in the company’s best interests by delaying the sale. A director’s duty under section 172 applies to their conduct as well as to their subjective belief, i.e. they are required to act, not merely to think, in good faith. Accordingly, the director was not permitted to act single-handedly in driving the company towards his preferred objective, if necessary concealing what he was doing from his colleagues. The duty to promote the success of the company requires directors to act collectively.

Courts will continue to respect the business judgement of directors and will not substitute their own view on what would best promote the company’s success, so to that extent, the test in section 172 is subjective. However, a director’s conduct will be judged by objective standards. See further details: Supreme Court: Directors must act, not merely think, in good faith | Inside Disputes

Veranova Bidco LP v Johnson Matthey PLC & Ors (Rev2) [2026] EWHC 1021 (Comm)

The Commercial Court rejected a claim for fraudulent breach of warranty arising from the sale of a pharmaceutical business. The decision underlines the high threshold required to prove fraudulent breach of warranty; while the buyer/claimant established breach of warranty, it did not clear the high bar of proving fraud.

The Judge held that the threshold to establish fraudulent knowledge required: (1) knowledge of the facts that made the warranty (as qualified by disclosure) false; (2) sufficient knowledge of the terms of the warranty to reasonably appreciate that their knowledge was relevant to that warranty; and (3) knowledge that the warranty was false (or was reckless as to this). As to recklessness specifically, the Judge noted that this is a frequently misunderstood concept and often confused with negligence. Recklessness means simply not caring at all whether something is true or false. As the Judge commented, “[t]his is a high hurdle since it is inherently unlikely that the senior executives of a company would be reckless in this sense.”

This case also illustrates that where it is necessary to attribute the state of mind of executives to a corporate entity, a court will not combine the states of mind of different executives within the company to produce a finding of dishonesty; for example, combining one person's knowledge of the facts with another person's knowledge of the warranty terms. A buyer must establish fraudulent knowledge in at least one specific individual whose state of mind is attributable to the company. See further details: Commercial Court considers threshold required to prove fraudulent breach of warranty claims | Inside Disputes

Great Asia Maritime Ltd v Orion Shipping and Trading LLC [2026] UKSC 23

The Supreme Court held that on a proper construction of the relevant clause in the contract, the buyers of a ship were entitled to loss of bargain damages for loss of profit, despite the lack of a repudiatory breach of contract by the seller. The clause provided for the seller to compensate the buyer for, among other things, ‘loss’. The Supreme Court held that the natural meaning of the clause included loss of bargain damages. This also matched other termination clauses in the contract, the natural measure of loss and prior cases on the same industry terms. The Court held that there was no ‘clear words’ principle regarding the grant of a contractual damages right above what the common law would otherwise provide. A party wishing to contract out of its common law rights or remedies arising by operation of law must use clear words, but the converse situation of the grant of a new right was not analogous. See further details: Great Asia Maritime Limited v Orion Shipping and Trading LLC (the “Lila Lisbon”)

Logix Aero v Siam Aero [2026] EWCA Civ 510

The Court of Appeal held that damage caused by an email interception fraud was not caused by the breach of confidentiality constituted by the unintentional sending of information to the fraudsters. The parties entered into a confidentiality agreement as part of an arrangement to buy and sell aircraft engines. Due to an email interception fraud, the payment price was sent to fraudsters and dissipated. The payer claimed that the payee was in breach of the confidentiality obligation by sending information to the fraudsters and this caused the loss. The Court of Appeal held that the breach was not an effective cause of the loss. The confidentiality obligation was intended to cover commercial breaches, not to protect against hackers.

Although there was no liability in this case on causation grounds, it is a useful reminder of the potential for civil liability following a cyber breach. In particular, the decision suggests that where a duty is owed to maintain confidentiality or otherwise protect information from hackers, loss caused by hacking might be recoverable for breach of that duty. From a practical perspective, simple verification procedures — such as confirming payment details by telephone — remain an effective defence against this type of fraud. See further details: Fraud breaks the chain: Court of Appeal on causation in email interception cases | Inside Disputes

2. Procedural updates

Case law – privilege

Uber London Ltd & Ors v White & Ors (Re Disclosure) [2026] EWHC 1610 (Comm)

The Commercial Court held that litigation privilege will not apply where documents were created for the dominant purpose of enabling a litigation funder to assess the commercial viability of a claim and decide whether to fund it, even if those documents included an assessment of the merits of the case. Litigation privilege protects communications made for the dominant purpose of conducting litigation. While the decision whether or not to litigate is part of the conduct of litigation, the Court distinguished a litigation funder's position from that of a claimant. The funder was deciding whether to fund someone else's litigation, not whether to conduct it themselves, and therefore the test for litigation privilege was not met.

Careful thought should be given to communications with funders, particularly where a funder is seeking to originate a claim and is communicating with third parties to gather information. While legal advice privilege may be available for some communications, it will not protect all, and such communications may become disclosable. Similarly, parties defending funded claims should carefully assess claims to privilege by the other side. See further details: Litigation funders and the limits of litigation privilege | Inside Disputes

Case law – disclosure

Lloyds Developments Ltd v Accor HotelServices UK Ltd & Ors [2026] EWHC 1522 (TCC)

The High Court ordered two former directors to hand over their personal mobiles to an independent reviewer during a disclosure exercise so that instant messages on the devices could be reviewed in a fraud case. The directors argued that requiring delivery of their personal devices would be disproportionate and an unjustifiable interference with their right to privacy under section 8 of the Human Rights Act 1998 as the devices contained personal and confidential information. The Court held that the claimant had a common law right to inspect and copy company-related communications held by its former directors as agents of the company. The company also had a contractual right to access the phones, in accordance with its funding agreement with the directors. The decision confirms that an individual’s right to privacy is not absolute and must be balanced against the need for the fair administration of justice. The proposed safeguard of providing the device to an independent reviewer would reduce any intrusion into privacy.

Case law – asymmetric jurisdiction clauses

Spec 1 v Export-Import Bank of China [2026] EWHC 1162 (Comm)

This decision of the High Court demonstrates that where parties agree to an asymmetric jurisdiction clause (which is commonly used in finance transactions), they accept the risk that proceedings may run in parallel in more than one country. This carries real commercial consequences – including the cost of defending or pursuing litigation simultaneously in multiple jurisdictions and the risk of inconsistent judgments. In this case, the borrower brought proceedings in England and the lender with the benefit of the asymmetric clause started proceedings in Singapore. The High Court refused to grant an anti-suit injunction in respect of the Singapore proceedings; the Court disagreed that once the borrower started proceedings in England, the lender was no longer free to start proceedings in a different jurisdiction. The Court also refused to stay the borrower’s English proceedings on grounds of forum non conveniens – as the parties had agreed a clause that permitted parallel proceedings, the fact that there would be two sets of proceedings did not provide a strong reason for the Court to refuse jurisdiction. If parties wish to restrict the flexibility of an asymmetric clause, this must be set out expressly in the drafting. See further details: When asymmetric jurisdiction clauses permit parallel proceedings | Inside Disputes

Case law – ADR and costs sanctions

MJS Projects (March) Ltd v RPS Consulting Services Ltd [2026] EWHC 884 (TCC)

The Technology and Construction Court refused to depart from the usual costs order that the successful party should receive its costs, despite the claimant's arguments that the defendant had unreasonably failed to mediate and that the defendant's expert had made a late change in evidence. There has been increased focus on Alternative Dispute Resolution (“ADR”) in recent years, and it is well established that a party could face costs sanctions if it unreasonably refused to engage in ADR. However, this decision demonstrates that a refusal to mediate will not automatically result in a costs sanction, particularly where the refusing party engaged constructively in other forms of ADR or settlement discussions, made settlement offers, and had reasonable grounds for requiring further information before agreeing to mediate. See further details: High Court: Does a refusal to mediate always result in a costs sanction? | Inside Disputes

Procedural rules

New court structure

In June 2026, the judiciary announced the establishment of a new Business and Property Division of the High Court. This new division will replace the Chancery Division and sit alongside the King’s Bench and Family Divisions. At present, the Business and Property Courts (which are a collection of specialist civil courts including the Commercial Court, the Technology & Construction Court and the Business List) are spread across both the King’s Bench and Chancery Divisions. The change will bring all of the Business and Property Courts under a single coherent division. The reasons for reform include strengthening the international reputation of the Business and Property Courts and making it easier for court users to understand where to bring their case. The courts and lists within this new Division will continue to operate as they do now and will keep their existing jurisdictions and areas of expertise. The restructure is due to take effect on 1 October 2026, and the Chancery Court Guide and other court guides will be updated to reflect the change in structure and terminology.

3. Hot topics for businesses

Generative artificial intelligence and disputes

In recent months we have seen a number of interesting issues relating to AI and disputes. In relation to witness evidence, in June, the Court of Appeal heard a case concerning the use of AI by a witness before giving evidence in a criminal trial. The witness had used an AI tool to prepare cross-examination style questions of their account to help them prepare for court. The Court of Appeal emphasised that the coaching of witnesses in their evidence is not permitted, which includes using AI. The Court stated that, “All witnesses should be firmly discouraged from resorting to the use of AI to prepare for giving evidence.” Although this was a criminal case, the principles on witness coaching apply equally to civil proceedings.

In previous editions of this round-up we have highlighted some of the risks of using AI in legal work, including the loss of confidentiality and privilege over client documents, and the risk of hallucinations in documents submitted to court. On 17 August 2026, the SRA published the Misuse of AI - Warning notice which highlights these concerns and emphasises that AI must be used by solicitors in ways that are compliant with SRA rules and their professional obligations. This includes ensuring appropriate supervision of junior colleagues who are using such tools.

The Civil Justice Council (“CJC”) has also been consulting on whether specific rules are needed to govern the use of AI by legal representatives for the preparation of court documents in civil proceedings. In June it provided an update on the consultation findings and reported that there was a strong consensus that for lawyers preparing statements of case, skeleton arguments and similar documents, there was no requirement for additional rules relating specifically to AI. However, there were differing views on whether additional safeguards or disclosure requirements are needed for the use of AI in preparing witness statements; concerns were raised over the potential for AI tools to reshape or influence evidence. The CJC is exploring whether a proportionate and workable approach can be developed for witness statements. In addition, the CJC is considering introducing proportionate transparency requirements regarding the use of AI in expert evidence. For further discussion of the issues that can arise when experts use AI in the preparation of their evidence see: Considering rules for expert witness use of generative AI | Inside Disputes

Finally, in July, the UK Jurisdiction Taskforce published its Legal Statement on Liability for AI Harms. The Statement analyses how existing English law principles, including contractual principles and the law of negligence, may apply to non-deliberate harms caused by AI. The Statement’s overall conclusion is that the flexibility of English common law means it is already well equipped to answer many questions regarding liability for AI-related harms and rejects the premise that the absence of an AI-specific liability regime leaves a vacuum. The Statement emphasises that AI is not a legal person and so an AI tool cannot be held directly accountable for harms caused by it. The Statement considers various scenarios in which professionals (including lawyers) may be held liable for harm caused by their use of AI. See further discussion of some of the issues highlighted in the Statement in our separate article: AI and tort liability: The UKJT’s Legal Statement on Liability for AI Harms

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes Blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post