In Advanced Multi‑Technology v Uniserve Limited [2025] EWCA Civ 1212, the Court of Appeal considered the test for proving reliance in misrepresentation cases, the limits on trial judges to decide cases on issues which have not been pleaded, and how commercial parties should respond to repudiatory breaches and protect their rights under supply contracts.
Background
The case concerned a dispute arising from a supply contract for face masks which was agreed during the Covid‑19 pandemic.
Advanced Multi‑Technology for Medical Industry (trading as Hitex), a Jordanian manufacturer of medical supplies, contracted with Uniserve on 21 April 2020 to supply £80 million worth of face masks. The contract contained an agreed delivery schedule which required Hitex to supply a scheduled number of masks by certain dates. Uniserve was to collect the masks from Hitex’s factory.
Uniserve had carried out investigations into Hitex’s production capabilities before signing the contract to seek to verify its proposed delivery schedule.
Certain deliveries were produced on time by Hitex but were collected by Uniserve ten days after each delivery date. On 14 June 2020, Hitex asserted that it had available two million masks at their factory in compliance with the delivery schedule (which had been revised after the contract was signed). However, Hitex did not notify Uniserve that the product was ready for collection (and, as emerged in the evidence, a portion of the stock was reserved for the Jordanian government irrespective of any obligations to Uniserve). A few days later, Uniserve communicated to Hitex that the contract had been terminated due to Hitex’s failure to supply the agreed quantities in time. Hitex continued to produce masks, and on 11 July 2020 informed Uniserve that it had multiple deliveries waiting for collection. In response, Uniserve reiterated that the contract had been terminated.
Hitex brought a claim for breach of contract alleging Uniserve had failed to receive and pay for the masks. Uniserve brought a counterclaim alleging it had validly terminated the contract or, in the alternative, it was entitled to rescind the supply contract as it had been induced to enter into the contract on the basis of misrepresentation.
At first instance, the High Court dismissed the misrepresentation claim and held that Hitex was entitled to damages based on the repudiatory breach of non-payment by Uniserve in July 2020. The trial judge found that Hitex had two million masks available for collection on 14 June 2020, meaning that Uniserve did not have the right to terminate at that point, and further held that Hitex had a right to terminate for non‑payment.
Court of Appeal’s decision
Uniserve successfully appealed and the Court of Appeal dismissed Hitex’s claims.
The “third man theory”
The first issue addressed by the Court of Appeal was the fact that the trial judgment was, in part, premised upon grounds that had not actually been argued or asserted by the parties themselves (Hitex’s case was that it kept the contract alive for performance). The Judge had concluded that Hitex had accepted Uniserve’s renunciation of the contract, a point not argued by the parties. The Court of Appeal highlighted the “basic principle of our adversarial system of civil justice that the parties identify in their pleadings the case which they seek to advance so that the issues for decision are clear, that evidence and submissions are directed to those issues and need not be concerned with other matters, and that the judge decides the issues thus identified and gives judgment accordingly”.
A case must be decided on a basis which had been argued, not on the basis of the “third man theory”, where the judge posits a case theory unidentified (and not argued) by the parties, as this approach leads to uncertainty and potential unfairness. The Court of Appeal indicated that where a judgment is based on grounds not asserted by the parties, it is a mistake reviewable by an appellate court.
Misrepresentation
Hitex had accepted that the third party which provided delivery assurances by email to Uniserve had authority to make representations on Hitex’s behalf, but the Court concluded that the email did not play a real and substantial part in inducing Uniserve to contract.
The Court of Appeal considered the application of the evidential presumption, which is “very difficult to rebut”, that a representee will have been induced when a fraudulent misrepresentation is made which is intended to cause the representee to enter into the contract. However, the Court of Appeal held that, on the evidence, the judge was entitled to find as a matter of fact that Uniserve was not induced by the misrepresentation to enter into the contract. The evidence showed that Uniserve entered the contracts on the basis of its own diligence, knowing full well that Hitex was unlikely to be able to meet the production targets communicated by the alleged misrepresentation; this had rebutted the evidential presumption.
Termination
The supply contract did not expressly state whether Hitex had to notify Uniserve when masks were ready for collection, nor whether Uniserve had to collect the finished product by any particular time. The Court of Appeal determined that at the time of the June 2020 communication from Uniserve, Hitex had made available the required number of masks for collection by the agreed date. Therefore, Uniserve did not have a right to terminate the contract, and its communication in June 2020 purporting to do so amounted to repudiatory breach. However, Hitex did not communicate its acceptance of this repudiation, and therefore the contract remained alive.
Absent Hitex serving a notice making the time for collection of the essence, which it never did, it remained under an obligation to have each new mask shipment available for delivery together with any previous uncollected shipments in accordance with the delivery schedule. The Court found that Hitex was required to keep 15% of its stock in reserve for the Jordanian government at any given time; therefore, the available number of masks had to be reduced accordingly to reflect this requirement. On the basis of the revised figures, by the time of the July 2020 communication from Uniserve, Hitex was in breach of its delivery obligations in the contract and Uniserve was entitled to terminate the contract in its July 2020 communication.
Key takeaways
The Court of Appeal’s decision demonstrates the importance of clear drafting in supply contracts and that parties should precisely set out their respective expectations as to performance. If timely collection from a supplier is considered essential, then the contract should say so.
The decision also underscores the critical importance of clearly communicating acceptance of repudiation. Without such communication, the contract is kept alive and the innocent party remains bound by its contractual obligations.
Courts cannot make arguments for one side or another nor make decisions on grounds that have not been pleaded; the judgment shows that appellate courts will not hesitate to intervene should this occur. It was also suggested that parties should not be too reticent about challenging substantive errors when a judgment is provided in draft to the parties.
On misrepresentation, the judgment provides a further example in a long list of decisions where contracting parties were found, as a matter of fact, to have relied on their independent due diligence rather than representations made by the other party when deciding whether to proceed.
With thanks to Zeynep Tavsanli for their assistance in preparing this post.