The Commercial Court’s judgment in IPJSC United Company Rusal v Whiteleave Holdings Limited and Others [2026] EWHC 154 (Comm) is the latest decision which illustrates how a party to litigation in the English courts can be required to disclose documents held by a third party if such documents can be shown to be in the litigant’s practical control. The test for control is contained in Civil Procedure Rule (CPR) 31.6 and Practice Direction (PD) 57AD. In addition to documents in a party’s physical possession, control extends to documents it has a right to possess, copy or inspect. The right to possession does not need to be a legal right; this decision adds to the line of case law which establishes that it is enough to show that there is an existing arrangement or understanding that a third party will comply with the requests of the disclosing party to provide documents, i.e. there is practical control.
In this case, the party, a CEO of a group of Russian companies, was ordered to search for relevant documents held by the parent company and 11 subsidiary companies. The decision demonstrates how practical control over documents can extend across corporate structures. Parties to disputes should be mindful of this issue as they start to gather documents from various sources to investigate or defend a claim. They should consider if they are establishing an arrangement that could amount to practical control over documents held by a third party for disclosure purposes, which later could require them to carry out wider searches for relevant documents.
The decision also shows how both English law and foreign law can be relevant to the question of control where documents are held in a foreign jurisdiction. The existence of control for disclosure purposes in English proceedings is a question of English law; the English law test applies, including English case law on what amounts to practical control. However, where the right to access documents exists under foreign law, regard has to be had to the foreign law to determine the nature and extent of the right of access. Parties will likely need expert evidence on these questions of foreign law.
Background
The underlying claim relates to the management of a Russian nickel company, PJSC MMC Norilsk Nickel (NN) and its subsidiaries. The major shareholders in NN were the Claimant, Rusal, a Russian producer of aluminium, and Whiteleave Holdings Ltd (the First Defendant). Whiteleave is owned and controlled by Mr Potanin (the Second Defendant).
Rusal, Whiteleave, Mr Potanin and two other parties entered into a Framework Agreement as part of a settlement of long-running disputes between Rusal and Whiteleave as to the management of NN. As part of the Framework Agreement, Mr Potanin was made the President and General Director of NN and became subject to various duties under it.
The Framework Agreement was subject to the jurisdiction of the English courts, and the Claimant brought English proceedings against the other parties to the Framework Agreement for alleged breaches of the Agreement. The Defendants denied any liability and advanced three counterclaims, with a trial scheduled for Spring 2027.
In this application, the Commercial Court was asked to decide whether a disclosure order should be made against Mr Potanin pursuant to Practice Direction 57AD in respect of relevant documents held by NN and certain of its subsidiaries. Mr Potanin’s position, as in previous litigation before the English courts, was that he does not retain any hard copy or electronic documents or files. As all his work is carried out via oral instructions, of which there is no written record, he had no documents to disclose. The Claimant disputed this, but the primary focus of the hearing was therefore on documents held by third parties which Mr Potanin potentially had control over due to his role as President and General Director of NN, a role that is similar to a CEO.
Decision
The Commercial Court ordered Mr Potanin to search for relevant documents held by NN and 11 named subsidiaries.
The Judge held that such searches would not be unreasonable or disproportionate. Given that the case focuses on serious allegations of fraud, misconduct and negligence, coupled with a 14-week trial, the Judge noted that the trial judge should be provided with sufficient evidence to determine the allegations rather than having to draw inference from the absence of documents.
Legal or practical control over documents?
After considering expert evidence on Russian law, the Judge found that in his role as CEO of NN, Mr Potanin had legal control over substantial NN documentation. Russian law gave him the right to access documents belonging to NN provided he was acting in the interests of the company and in good faith. The Judge found that, looking at the broader picture, it was clearly in NN’s interest for Mr Potanin to have access to the documents for the purposes of defending the claims; determining whether Mr Potanin had been negligent in his duties or whether he had misused NN’s assets for his own personal gain was no doubt of interest to NN.
The Judge acknowledged that any documents subject to Russian Confidentiality Rules would not be within Mr Potanin’s control. These Rules restrict the dissemination of documents containing, for example, insider information and commercial secrets, although there are exceptions, such as for disclosure in court proceedings. The Judge doubted whether many relevant documents fell within the Russian Confidentiality Rules but the possibility of them doing so did not preclude the making of a disclosure order requiring Mr Potanin to search for relevant documents and then identify any which he claimed were not in his control.
In relation to documents held by NN subsidiaries, it was common ground between the parties that Mr Potanin’s position as CEO of NN did not give him a legal right to access documents held by NN subsidiaries. However, the Judge was satisfied on the evidence that Mr Potanin had practical control over documents held by them. Whether there is a sufficient arrangement or understanding to establish practical control is a question of fact. The Judge identified several factors which supported his decision, including:
- NN group is an integrated business in which the subsidiaries operate to support the profitable business of NN
- NN and its subsidiaries use a shared document management system and have access to each other’s documents
- the Defendants had already provided documents from the NN subsidiaries to the Claimant
- Mr Potanin had sufficient control over the group of companies to request documents from the subsidiaries, none of which have ever refused such a request.
The risk that disclosure of documents could result in liability
Mr Potanin also sought to resist the application by arguing that under the Russian Confidentiality Rules, disclosure of documents could create a real risk of criminal or civil liability for Mr Potanin in Russia.
This point illustrates a further way foreign law can be relevant to disclosure in English court proceedings. The fact that disclosure of documents to comply with an English court order might breach foreign law is not automatically a basis on which a party can avoid disclosure. The party resisting disclosure must establish that there is a real risk, in practice, of sanctions under the foreign law. In this case, the Judge found that there was no real risk of prosecution of Mr Potanin, NN or any of its subsidiaries. Whilst both experts in the case agreed that there are circumstances where disclosure could create such a risk, neither identified any specific reasons to believe that Mr Potanin’s compliance with the disclosure order would result in such liability.
Key takeaways
Practical control can extend across corporate structures
Parties to a dispute should not assume that, because other companies in their group have a separate legal personality, documents held by those companies cannot be in the party’s control for disclosure purposes. There have been other decisions where a parent company was held to have practical control of documents held by subsidiaries and vice versa. Practical control is a question of fact and will depend on whether there is an existing arrangement or understanding that the company will comply with the requests of the disclosing party.
Importance of considering procedural implications when agreeing to a jurisdiction
The Judge indicated that one of the factors influencing whether such a disclosure order was just and proportionate was the parties' decision to submit to the jurisdiction of the English courts. Their advisers would have been aware that if a dispute arose which led to court proceedings, disclosure obligations, as prescribed by the CPR and PD 57AD, would form part of those proceedings. Accordingly, it is important to consider the procedural implications of submitting to a particular jurisdiction before agreeing to do so.
With thanks to Sam Matravers for his assistance in preparing this post.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes Blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.