The High Court’s decision in Lux Films Ltd v Fowler & Another [2026] EWHC 963 (KB) is a useful reminder that directors’ duties continue to bite even where relations between shareholders have broken down and a director is planning an exit. It also underlines the practical importance of documenting director, employee and shareholder relationships, particularly in small owner-managed businesses where roles often overlap.

The most notable feature of the judgment is the Court’s treatment of unlawful means conspiracy. The Court held that, in appropriate circumstances, a sole director and the company he controls may be capable of forming the necessary combination for the civil tort of unlawful means conspiracy. The Court rejected a direct analogy with criminal conspiracy and focused instead on the practical reality of concerted action by separate legal persons causing harm.

On the facts, the Court found that Andrew Fowler had acted both personally and through Andrew Fowler Media Ltd (AFML), the company he controlled. That distinction mattered; AFML was not merely a passive recipient, but the corporate vehicle through which competing work was undertaken and profits were received.

Background

The Claimant, Lux Films Ltd (Lux), is a small UK media production company which specialises in video content. Although Lux was incorporated as a company, the relationship between its three equal shareholders was not governed by a shareholders’ agreement, and the directors did not have written employment contracts.

In the case, the Defendants were Mr Fowler and his company Andrew Fowler Media Ltd. Mr Fowler was also a director, shareholder and employee of Lux.

In 2023, relations between the three shareholders began to deteriorate. Mr Fowler indicated that he wished to leave the business and whilst talks took place, ultimately he remained an employee, director and shareholder in Lux, continuing to work at the Claimant’s offices and use their resources.

While continuing in his role at Lux, Mr Fowler began to undertake work through his company AFML, of which he is the sole shareholder and director. While carrying out this dual role, it was alleged by Lux Films that Mr Fowler started to work for clients of Lux, began advertising for work which could have been carried out by Lux and used resources belonging to the Claimant, including staff, software and systems, to drive work to AFML, which was in direct competition with Lux.

In June 2024, Mr Fowler was suspended from Lux, pending an investigation, with Lux later issuing proceedings and applying for injunctive relief.

Decision

The High Court found that Mr Fowler had breached his fiduciary and statutory duties. The Court found that Mr Fowler’s conduct breached both his equitable obligations and the statutory duties codified in the Companies Act 2006, including the duties to promote Lux’s success, exercise independent judgment and avoid conflicts of interest.

AFML was found to be liable for the following:

  1. knowing receipt of property and benefits derived from Mr Fowler’s breaches of his fiduciary duties;
  2. unlawful means conspiracy; and
  3. liability to account as the corporate vehicle through which Mr Fowler carried out and profited from his breaches.

Mr Fowler was also found to have breached his contractual obligations of good faith. He did so by continuing to work for Lux whilst using their confidential information and resources, as well as working for AFML whilst he should have been working for Lux. He also misused his position to divert opportunities and value from Lux to AFML.

Mr Fowler put forward a range of defences to the claims made by Lux, all of which were rejected by the Court. These included arguments that his conduct amounted only to permissible preparatory steps, that he had been excluded from Lux’s management, and that he had used only his own expertise and business know-how rather than Lux’s confidential information.

Key takeaways

A sole director and their company may be capable of civil conspiracy

The Court held that, in the case of a civil conspiracy, the focus is on concerted action by separate legal persons causing harm. The fact that Mr Fowler controlled AFML did not prevent a finding of unlawful means conspiracy where AFML was used as the vehicle through which the unlawful conduct was implemented and profits were realised.

Directors’ duties continue during a breakdown in relations

The deterioration of the relationship between Lux’s shareholders did not release Mr Fowler from his duties. He remained a director and employee, continued to receive salary and benefits, and was still required to act in Lux’s interests rather than divert opportunities to his own company for his own personal gain at the expense of Lux.

Written contracts and shareholders’ agreements matter

The absence of written employment contracts and a shareholders’ agreement left important issues unresolved, including notice periods, exit arrangements, ownership of client relationships, confidentiality obligations and restrictions on competing activity. The Court ultimately held that a reasonable notice period for Mr Fowler was six months, despite his resignation on seven days’ notice.

Intent to injure in unlawful means conspiracy

Sweeting J set out the requirement for an intent to injure in an unlawful means conspiracy, stating:

“In an unlawful means conspiracy, an intention to injure is established where the defendants knew that injury to the claimant was the inevitable consequence of the course of conduct pursued for their own benefit. It is not necessary that harm to the claimant be the predominant purpose.”

The decision confirms that, for unlawful means conspiracy, it may be sufficient that the defendants knew injury to the claimant was an inevitable consequence of the course of conduct pursued for their own benefit, even if causing that injury was not their predominant purpose.

Preparation to compete is different from active competition

The Court rejected the suggestion that Mr Fowler was merely preparing to compete. He had actively solicited clients, performed work through AFML, used Lux’s confidential information, resources and staff, and received payment for competing work while still both a director and employee of Lux. The law permits preparatory steps but not where they involve conflicts of interest, competition or the misuse of confidential information.

With thanks to Sam Matravers for his assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post