In Hughes v Bellamy [2026] EWHC 237 (Ch), the High Court granted urgent interim relief under s.25 of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 (CJJA) to prevent the dissipation of assets in support of foreign unfair prejudice proceedings.

The decision raises important questions about the interplay between the American Cyanamid test for injunctive relief and the freezing injunction threshold, and demonstrates that s.25 CJJA can be a useful tool to deploy to urgently preserve English assets whilst parties await the determination of foreign proceedings.

Background

Mr Hughes (the Claimant), and Mr Bellamy (the First Defendant), were equal shareholders in and directors of an Isle of Man company, Mulberry Limited (Mulberry). In 2025, they established a joint venture to create a sovereign AI business, with Mulberry as the sole owner of two English subsidiaries, Pathfinder 1 Limited (the Second Defendant) and AI Pathfinder Inc Limited (the Third Defendant).

Disputes arose between the two shareholders concerning: (i) the funding of Mulberry; and (ii) governance of the two subsidiaries.

The Claimant made an urgent application for interim relief under s.25 CJJA in support of unfair prejudice proceedings in the Isle of Man, prompted by the Claimant’s discovery of the sale by the Third Defendant of most of its assets. The Claimant considered this sale to be suspicious, potentially at an undervalue, and to parties possibly connected to the First Defendant.

The Claimant sought an order from the Court to prevent the Second and Third Defendants from disposing of their assets. The Claimant submitted that the American Cyanamid test for injunctive relief should be applied, which required the Claimant to demonstrate that: (i) there was a serious issue to be tried; (ii) the balance of convenience favoured the injunction; and (iii) that it was just and convenient to make the order sought.

The Third Defendant resisted the application, arguing that it was in substance, a freezing order application without the usual safeguards and without the Claimant producing solid evidence of the risk of dissipation of assets. It submitted that the sale was not disclosed because it was subject to non-disclosure and confidentiality agreements.

Decision

The High Court granted short-term injunctive relief preventing the Second and Third Defendants from disposing of, or dealing with, their assets without the Claimant's prior written consent, and held the following:

  • Legal test and risk of dissipation: The Judge appeared to agree that the American Cyanamid test governed the application, given the importance of preserving the status quo of the subsidiaries' assets, pending resolution of the unfair prejudice petition.

    The Judge noted that even if the freezing injunction test was applied, the undisclosed sale of the Third Defendant's assets would satisfy the requirement of showing a real risk of dissipation, regardless of whether this was attributable to valid confidentiality agreements. In particular, the Judge considered there to be a “fairly strong possibility” that the sale might have been at an undervalue and to parties associated with the First Defendant.

  • Purpose of the injunction: there was “good reason” to make the injunction, as the Claimant proposed to seek, by way of counterclaim in the Isle of Man proceedings, an order permitting him to buy out the First Defendant’s shares in Mulberry, which were only valuable if the subsidiaries retained their assets.

  • Cross-undertaking in damages: The Judge determined that fortification of the cross-undertaking in damages was not required at this stage, given the Claimant's apparent wealth. The issue was deferred to the return date.

Key takeaways

The decision is a useful reminder of how interim relief can successfully be obtained in shareholder disputes. By accepting the Claimant’s submission that s.25 applications in support of unfair prejudice proceedings may attract the American Cyanamid test, the High Court has opened a route to claimants - at least on an urgent, short-term basis - to asset-preservation relief without all the usual freezing order safeguards, such as fortified cross-undertakings.

Finally, the cross-border dimension is also noteworthy. The court granted relief over English subsidiaries notwithstanding that the substantive proceedings and the parent company were situated in the Isle of Man, showing the Court’s willingness to exercise its powers under s.25 CJJA in support of foreign shareholder proceedings.

With thanks to Alfred Holder for his assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post