Download report

Introduction

Private credit has advanced from a niche of alternative finance to a primary source of capital for midmarket borrowers, reshaping the Canadian lending landscape. Globally, this asset class surpassed US $2 trillion, representing ten times its 2009 size. Once dominated by specialist lenders, private credit is now firmly embedded in the private equity playbook. Most major private equity sponsors operate dedicated direct lending or opportunistic credit arms, making it one of the fastest‑growing strategies within the broader private equity ecosystem.

Private lenders frequently offer financing solutions tailored to the needs of small and medium-sized enterprises, with some financings reaching into a few hundreds of millions of dollars, especially in sectors where traditional banks are less flexible. Investors can take part in this scheme through private credit funds, which raise capital from institutional investors, high-net-worth individuals and increasingly, retail investors.

This article frames the role of private credit funds through the lens of managers and investors, and then highlights two issues that increasingly shape outcomes: the yield–risk trade‑off in origination and the structural tension between investor liquidity and asset illiquidity.

What private credit does for managers

For managers, private credit is an investment strategy that seeks to generate income with relatively lower risk than equity-based strategies and attracts investment for the specific reasons outlined below.

Generally, the asset class offers several advantages:

  • First, private credit lenders tend to have more flexibility in terms than traditional bank lenders. The ability to negotiate bilateral deals allows managers to tailor covenants, security packages and amortization profiles to specific risks. Private lenders may also seek equity consideration (such as warrants) to increase returns.
  • Second, private credit lenders may be in a better position to realize the value of collateral than traditional bank lenders. For example, a private lender (especially as an investment arm of a private equity sponsor) may have the ability to manage a borrower’s business as a going concern and position the asset for sale later, which could lead to improved recovery in a default situation.
  • Third, as the private credit market grows, so does the breadth of strategies available. Private credit now encompasses a wide range of strategies, including senior secured direct lending, unitranche, mezzanine, special situations, factoring, securitization, asset‑based finance and real estate or infrastructure debt. Additionally, some strategies focus on participating in private loans through syndication or on a secondary basis, all of which support scalability and diversification.

Private credit fund managers may need to be registered as investment fund managers and portfolio managers under securities laws. Furthermore, some lending activities also trigger licensing and conduct requirements. For example, a strategy that originates commercial or residential mortgages may require mortgage broker licensing and adherence to business-conduct standards. Whether registration is required is a fact-specific analysis for which fund managers should seek legal advice.

What private credit does for investors

Private credit is attractive to investors as it supports portfolio diversification and risk-adjusted returns. This is particularly true of retail investors who have limited access to income-producing investments, while their institutional counterparts may have private credit arms of their own. Relative to equity investments, private credit’s low correlation to traditional assets, seniority in the capital stack, and covenant frameworks can support more stable return profiles through varied market conditions (subject to manager quality and sector mix), a particularly important quality in the current economic landscape.

Structuring considerations

Managers must carefully consider fund design, governance and controls when structuring a private credit fund to meet their own objectives and those of investors. The following issues should be top of mind when structuring and managing private credit funds.

Issue 1: Yield–risk trade-off

The first issue is the inexorable link between target returns, performance fees and risk. The tension between these factors leads to conflicts of interest between managers and investors such as the following:

  • First, higher target returns pull managers down the capital structure or toward weaker borrowers with increased risk. Seeking higher returns may also erode protections – managers may ease financial maintenance covenants, reporting obligations, cash reserves, etc. This is particularly relevant in a lowering interest rate environment where managers may be incentivized to increase risk in the portfolio to earn performance fees.
  • Second, managers need to strike the right balance between enforcing on a loan versus an “amend‑and‑extend” approach. When interest rates rise or when a borrower’s business suffers an unexpected downturn, interest coverage compresses and borrowers may struggle with loan payments and/or compliance with financial covenants. When such struggles are expected to be temporary, forbearance or payment-in-kind (PIK) mechanisms can preserve the loan asset, but will lead to additional portfolio risk and delay resolution of non-performing assets.

Fund level mechanics can be used to mitigate such conflicts and reward prudent risk management. Floating hurdle rates that reset with benchmark rates ensure a private credit fund has performance metrics that respond to current market conditions. They can also incentivize portfolio managers to seek investments with appropriate risk profiles and discourage searching for “home runs.”

Further, performance fees calculated on cash distributions rather than accrued or PIK amounts, anchor incentives to timely servicing and credit quality instead of asset value. In practice, this discourages excessive PIK or amend and extend tactics that defer stress recognition and favour underwriting that sustains cash coverage and default adjusted returns.

Issue 2: Investor liquidity and asset illiquidity

The second issue is the tension between investor appetite for liquidity and the illiquidity of private loans. If not properly aligned, there is risk of forced asset sales at sub-optimal values. Fund managers must manage the structural vulnerabilities tied to the illiquid nature of private credit assets.

Canadian experience has shown why disciplined liquidity design matters in practice: recently, managers across private real estate and private credit have exercised limited or temporary redemption gates due to significant redemption requests. This has had significant impact on investor confidence in funds and the industry as a whole, resulting in redemptions even in funds with strong track records and performance.

While some investors may be accustomed to daily liquidity in publicly traded securities and public mutual funds, redemption limits, notice periods, fund‑level and investor‑level gates and in‑kind distribution rights are common in funds with less liquid assets and are legitimate tools to mitigate against forced sales and value destruction. Such tools also provide the manager with time to liquidate assets in an orderly manner and in some cases, outlast market hysteria.

Redemption restrictions seek to balance the need for investor liquidity with the inherent illiquidity of underlying assets. Thoughtfully constructed redemption mechanics allow time for managers to either raise funds or liquidate assets to satisfy redemption requests, while providing certainty to investors on redemption timing. Managers can consider utilizing the following strategies to manage liquidity in their funds and avoid outright redemption suspensions.

  • First, retain some liquidity in the portfolio. Semi‑liquid structures should be backed by portfolios with meaningful scheduled amortization, diversified maturities and, if possible, secondary sale options. Managers may also consider dedicating a portion of their portfolios to more liquid assets, which can be sold if unexpected redemption demand arises.
  • Second, make liquidity policy a feature, not fine print. Define ordinary‑course redemption capacity, queue mechanics and gate triggers clearly; report utilization and queue length regularly; and explain how the manager finances redemptions without impairing the remaining portfolio.
  • Third, maintain a robust valuation policy. Sometimes, redemption requests arise not from a need for investor liquidity, but rather skepticism about portfolio valuation. Maintaining a robust valuation policy helps avoid a disconnect between net asset value from the points of view of the manager and the investor, increasing investor confidence in the fund and reducing redemption requests.

Handled this way, redemption limits become an investor protection mechanism rather than a perceived punishment, and managers preserve the ability to invest patient capital through cycles.

Conclusion

Private credit funds now play a central role in Canada, matching borrower needs with investors’ and managers’ demand for durable, income oriented diversification. The strategy’s advantages for managers and investors are maximized when economics, governance and liquidity are engineered to reflect the underlying assets. As private credit funds continue to grow, managing the above issues will be essential to providing investors and managers with successful outcomes.

Fund design, conflict policies and valuation policies are paramount to mitigate inherent conflicts between investors and managers, and funds that can manage such conflicts while maintaining strong track records will emerge as leaders in a dynamic and growing segment of the alternative investment sector.

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Financial services in focus
Volume 1: Looking back on key insights from 2025
/content/nrf-eds/en-ca/topics/financial-services-in-focus

Contact