Introduction

Construction claim priority issues are a source of ongoing tension in Canadian insolvency proceedings. The contest between construction lien claimants and mortgage lenders is now the subject of an important decision of the Ontario court in Clarkson Road Developments GP Inc., with leave to appeal dismissed on March 11, 2025.

The decision has significant implications for the treatment of lien and mortgage priorities under Ontario’s Construction Act and the structuring of secured real estate lending transactions in Ontario.

Background

The property at the centre of the dispute was a partially built, multi-unit residential townhouse development. The property was owned through a nominee and limited partnership structure, which was ultimately controlled by CS Capital Limited.

The key timeline was as follows:

  • Between 2013 and 2016, the owner hired an architectural firm to assist with various zoning and design matters in respect of the project.
  • In September 2020, the owner’s objectives shifted to finding a buyer for the project.
  • On July 30, 2021, a sale and purchase completed.  Pursuant to a Unit and Share Purchase Agreement, the purchaser acquired the shares and limited partnership units of the entities that owned the property and the project. Of the $25 million purchase price, $5 million was paid in cash, and the balance satisfied by way of a vendor take back loan.
  • The direct ownership of the property and the project did not change through this transaction; only the equity holdings of the property owners changed.
  • The vendor-take-back loan (owing by the purchaser to the selling equity holders) was guaranteed by the underlying property owner and secured by a mortgage on the property and the project.
  • Following completion of the transaction, construction resumed on the townhouse development.
  • Eventually, the project became insolvent.  In late 2023, several substantial liens totalling more than $20 million were registered on the property. The mortgage on the property, securing the property owner’s guarantee of the vendor-take-back loan, also exceeded $20 million.
  • The Ontario court had to determine the priority of the lien claimants’ direct rights against the property, relative to the rights of the mortgage holder by way of its guarantee from the property owner.

Issue one: Was the mortgage a prior mortgage, with priority over subsequent liens?

The first question before the Ontario court was whether the first lien on the project had arisen in relation to an improvement on the property before the mortgage was registered.

The court found that the first lien arose through the architectural work completed from 2013 to 2016, before the mortgage was entered into and registered. While no lien was registered on title at that time, work (including planning work that could be the subject of a lien) occurred with respect to the overall improvement to the townhouse property.  The relevant question to determine when a lien arises is when the “lienable” work is undertaken, not the timing of registration of any actual lien. Therefore, the lien arose before the mortgage was registered in 2021, and the absence of a contemporaneous registration did not prevent this.

From a practical perspective, this analysis expands the scope of priority arguments available to lien claimants.

Issue two: Did the transaction give rise to a vendor take back mortgage or a collateral mortgage?

Following this conclusion, the next issue was whether the guarantee by the property owner of the vendor-take-back loan, and the mortgage securing that guarantee, resulted in a mortgage for which an advance had actually been made.

This was a critical question because the Ontario Construction Act provides that a mortgage registered after the first lien arose still has priority over any liens not perfected at the time of the mortgage, or for which the mortgage holder did not have notice at the time of the mortgage. Such mortgage priority is only available to the extent of any advance made in respect of that mortgage.

The court held that the mortgage was structured as a collateral charge, securing the obligations of the guarantor property owner. The court followed prior case law to conclude that no advance was made to the guarantor who had provided the mortgage in this case. The advance, if any, was made by the selling equity holder to the purchaser of the equity. As no “advance” was made to the guarantor in respect of the mortgage, the mortgage did not have priority over the construction liens.

This is a significant judgment as the same issue could arise on any Ontario construction project that uses this common structure, where a parent company is the borrower and the subsidiary property owner acts as guarantor and mortgagor for the parent’s debt.

Key Takeaways

This decision highlights several important factors parties should consider in relation to security priority between construction liens and mortgages:

  • Broad Interpretation of an “Improvement”:

The court affirmed that the definition of “improvement” under the Construction Act should be interpreted broadly. The fact that there may be several contracts in respect of a project does not necessarily mean that the supply of services or materials under separate contracts (including construction contracts) will be regarded as separate improvements. Services and materials provided at different stages or under different contracts may all relate to a single improvement. Lenders will need to fully understand the scope of work conducted on a project prior to their arrival and consider whether any such work was a “lienable” improvement, even if no lien was registered in relation to that work.

  • Avoiding Collateral Mortgage Issues in Structuring:

A collateral mortgage securing a guarantee, without an actual advance to the guarantor, will leave the mortgage holder susceptible to priming by lien claimants. The choice to structure the sale as a transfer of securities - rather than a direct conveyance of land - was key to the resolution of the priority dispute in the Clarkson Road case.  The court noted that CS Capital, a sophisticated commercial entity, chose to participate in a transaction that was structured as a sale of securities rather than a sale of land. It agreed to take a guarantee from the landowner, among other things. This structuring influenced how the mortgage was characterised and ultimately affected its priority status.

These issues would have been avoided had the seller sold the underlying property directly pursuant to a proper vendor-take-back mortgage, or possibly even if a co-borrower structure had been used. This particular issue will be of importance to lenders who either: (i) currently have projects secured by collateral mortgages through this type of guarantor structure; or (ii) are negotiating transactions in which a counterparty is pushing for the borrower to be a parent entity, with a guarantee from the property-owning subsidiary.

  • Defining the Mortgage:

The court placed weight on the express wording of the mortgage documents, which described the mortgage as a collateral security for the guarantee. Parties should ensure that their documentation accurately reflects the intended nature of their security interest, as courts will look to both the substance and form of the agreements.

  • Loan Monitoring:

Lenders must diligently monitor the number and size of any new liens, or any arrears that are accruing, on their borrowers’ projects.  A lender likely will not have reserved for the possibility of substantial priming liens.

Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP was counsel to the primary lien claimants pursuing priority claims in the Clarkson Road GP Inc. case.

Contact