In the last quarter of 2025, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) released two judgments of interest to creditors and Canadian securities issuers. These judgments address the prescription1 (limitation period) to enforce a judgment for payment under Quebec civil law and public companies’ disclosure obligations under securities law.
This update summarizes takeaways from each decision and previews what lies ahead in 2026 at the SCC.
Key takeaways
- Mohawk Council of Kanesatake v Sylvestre:2 Under the Civil Code of Québec, a party has 10 years to enforce a judgment for payment. Issuing a notice to seize property will interrupt and reset the 10-year deadline regardless of whether the property is ultimately seized.
- Lundin Mining Corp. v Markowich:3 Under securities legislation, the term “change” is to be interpreted broadly when determining whether a “material change” has occurred for the purpose of securities disclosure obligations. As the SCC endorsed an “investor-friendly” approach to disclosure, public companies are encouraged to err on the side of disclosing new developments sooner rather than later.
Mohawk Council of Kanesatake v Sylvestre
The issue was whether an unsuccessful attempt to seize property, where a bailiff served a notice of execution but did not seize assets deemed to be exempt under section 89 of the Indian Act, interrupted the 10-year prescription for enforcing judgments for payment in Quebec.
Under the Civil Code of Québec, the right to enforce judgment for payment ends, or prescribes, after 10 years unless this period is interrupted by a qualifying judicial application. In this case, the creditors argued the judgment for unpaid fees was interrupted by the service of a notice for execution, even though the bailiff did not take steps for seizure under the notice because it considered the property to be exempt from seizure.
In its judgment, the SCC dismissed the appeal and held that the creditors’ 2016 filing and service of the notice of execution was sufficient to interrupt the prescription, even though no property was seized. As the proceeding was not dismissed by a court, the interruption stood, and the bailiff’s lack of action did not negate the interruption. The SCC’s decision clarifies how judgment debts can be enforced and the types of events that can interrupt prescription.
Lundin Mining Corp. v Markowich
The issue before the SCC was whether Lundin’s detection of pit wall instability and a subsequent rockslide at its Candelaria mine were “material changes” that had to be disclosed under Canadian securities legislation, as opposed to mere “material facts” suitable for periodic disclosure. The company disclosed the developments about a month later in a routine update, after which its share price fell 16% in a day, prompting an investor’s motion for leave to bring a secondary market claim and seek class certification.
Canadian securities law requires public companies to promptly disclose any “material change” defined under the legislation as a change in business, operations, or capital that could significantly impact the market price or value of their securities.4 Such changes must be reported immediately, with a material change report filed within 10 days.5 In contrast, “material facts,” which also affect market value, are disclosed periodically.6 Notably, while “change” triggers immediate disclosure, its meaning is not specifically defined by legislation or previous SCC rulings.
The SCC held that “change” should be construed broadly. The SCC majority found that the pit wall instability and the rockslide could reasonably be characterized as having resulted in a “material change” to Lundin’s “business, operations or capital.”
Notably, Justice Jamal, writing for the majority, rejected the “manager-friendly” standard, which provides that a change does not need to be disclosed immediately unless it involves significant disruption to the company. Companies should, instead, follow the “investor-friendly” disclosure standard, under which any event that is a “change in the business, operations or capital” is a change that ought to be disclosed promptly. The definition of “change” remains open-ended and context-specific, leaving room for further interpretation by lower courts.
For a fuller discussion see Supreme Court of Canada rejects narrow interpretation of disclosure standard for “material changes.”
What’s on the docket?
In January of 2026, the SCC heard Democracy Watch v Attorney General of Canada.7 The SCC will decide whether a partial privative clause in the Conflict of Interest Act bars Democracy Watch from challenging the Commissioner’s report on former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s involvement with WE Charity. This highly anticipated appeal is likely to clarify the important question of whether and how legislatures can restrict the right to challenge public decisions by way of judicial review.
The SCC will hear Aphria Inc. v Canada Life Assurance Company, et al. in February of 2026.8 The issue is whether commercial landlords must mitigate their losses when they refuse to accept a tenant’s decision to break a lease. This may be of interest to businesses who are party to a commercial lease.
Businesses with a unionized workforce will be interested in the decision in Attorney General of Québec v SGS Canada inc. The SCC will decide whether labour relations for SGS Canada Inc., a service provider of grain inspection and certification, fall under provincial or federal jurisdiction given that Parliament has invoked its power under section 92(10)(c) of the Constitution to declare grain elevators to be excepted from provincial jurisdiction and subject to federal authority. The matter has been heard, but the decision is under reserve.
The SCC has recently granted leave in significant matters relating to private international law, the use of the notwithstanding clause, and alleged defamatory online consumer expression.
- In Ontario Place Protectors v His Majesty the King in Right of Ontario and Attorney General of Ontario, the SCC will address the constitutionality of the Rebuilding Ontario Place Act, which extinguishes all causes of action against the Crown, except for applications for judicial review, to facilitate redevelopment of Ontario Place.9
- In Cold Ocean Salmon Inc. v Nova Fish Farms Inc., the SCC will consider the interpretation and application of a “time is of the essence clause” in a purchase and sale contract.10
- In NHK Spring Co., Ltd., et al. v Tony Cheung, et al. the SCC will determine whether Canadian courts can assume jurisdiction over a foreign price-fixing class action on the basis that the price-fixing conspiracy had effects within Canada.11
- In Government of Saskatchewan as represented by the Minister of Education v UR Pride Centre for Sexuality and Gender Diversity the SCC will address the use of the notwithstanding clause, which allows legislatures to override certain Charter rights.12
- In Cynthia Prescott, et al. v Benchwood Builders Inc., et al. the SCC will consider how defamation defences and the Canadian principles against strategic lawsuits against public participation (anti-SLAPP) are to be applied in the context of online consumer expression.13
Follow the firm’s insights on appellate law to stay informed of the SCC’s latest activity.
The authors would like to thank Manreet Brar, articling student, for her contribution to preparing this legal update.
Footnotes
-
Under Quebec’s civil law regime, the term “prescription” refers to limitation periods, which set deadlines to bring a legal claim.
-
Mohawk Council of Kanesatake v. Sylvestre, 2025 SCC 30.
-
Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39.
-
Securities Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. S.5 at s. 1(1).
-
Securities Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. S.5 at s. 75(1).
-
Securities Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. S.5 at s. 1(1).
-
See the SCC’s Summary here.
-
See the SCC’s Summary here.
-
See the SCC’s Summary here.
-
See the SCC’s Summary here.
-
See the SCC’s Summary here.
-
See Summary here.
-
See Summary here.