Litigation strategy for trademark expungement and opposition proceedings in Canada is changing. In the past, when faced with such proceedings, many trademark owners filed only limited evidence with the administrative decision maker—the Trademarks Opposition Board (Board)—knowing if an appeal to the Federal Court (Court) was necessary, additional evidence could be adduced as of right. No longer. In 2025, amendments to subsection 56(5) of the Trademarks Act (Act) came into force requiring leave from the Court before adducing additional evidence on appeal.
How strictly the Court will apply the new leave requirement remains to be seen. In a significant development, the first decision to consider amended subsection 56(5) was released in January 2026. In Products Unlimited, Inc v Five Seasons Comfort Limited,1 the Court developed and applied, for the first time, a test for leave to adduce additional evidence on appeal from a Board decision.
The Board’s decision
Products Unlimited applied to register its FILTER DESIGN trademark (the Mark). The Mark is non-traditional, consisting of diamond-shaped openings arranged in a specific pattern on an air filter. The application was opposed, with the opponent alleging, among other things, that the Mark was primarily functional in nature and thus not registrable under subsection 12(2) of the Act. After examining the evidence before it, the Board found that Products Unlimited had not met its onus to disprove the opponent’s allegation. As a result, the Board refused the application for the Mark.
A new test to adduce additional evidence on appeal
Products Unlimited appealed the Board’s decision to the Federal Court and requested leave to adduce additional evidence. The request was necessary because the appeal was commenced on April 2, 2025, the day after the amendments to subsection 56(5) came into force.
Amended subsection 56(5) had not been previously considered by the Court. The Court developed a test for allowing additional evidence on appeal, namely whether doing so was in “the interests of justice,” taking into account all relevant factors, including:
- The relevance, credibility, and admissibility of the additional evidence
- The materiality of the additional evidence, including whether it could have affected the Board’s decision
- Whether granting leave would cause prejudice to the opposing party
- The circumstances surrounding the delay in filing the additional evidence
Notably, the Court found that the language of subsection 56(5) “signals an intention for greater flexibility in the admission of new evidence than is generally afforded in appeals.”
Application of the new test
Applying its new test, the Court found it was in the interests of justice to grant leave to Products Unlimited to adduce additional affidavit evidence (the Affidavit):
- The Affidavit was relevant, credible, admissible and material to the central issue of whether the Mark is primarily functional.
- Admitting the Affidavit into evidence would not cause prejudice, particularly as the opponent did not participate in the appeal.
- The Court accepted Products Unlimited’s explanation for why it did not file the Affidavit with the Board. Although the evidence was not new and could have been filed with the Board, the Court accepted that Products Unlimited was not required to put its “best foot forward” before the Board, as the amendments to subsection 56(5) were not in force at that time.
In light of the additional evidence, the Court overturned the Board’s decision, finding that the Mark was not primarily functional and should be registered.
Takeaways for trademark owners
Although the Court granted leave to adduce additional evidence in Products Unlimited, it may be less inclined to do so in the future. The Court appeared swayed by the injustice of expecting Products Unlimited to put its “best foot forward” before the Board when, at that time, it could expect to adduce evidence on appeal as of right. This rationale will not be available for parties to Board proceedings started after April 2025.
Therefore, parties should start strong by, whenever possible, leading a full evidentiary record before the Board. In doing so, parties can now seek a confidentiality order to protect sensitive evidence before the Board, under section 45.1 of the Act.
The authors would like to thank Sulayman Syed, articling student, for his contribution to preparing this IP Monitor.
Footnotes
-
Products Unlimited, Inc. v Five Seasons Comfort Limited, 2026 FC 48, rev’ing 2025 TMOB 21.