In its March 20 decision in ProSlide Technology Inc. v. WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd., 2026 FCA 59, the Federal Court of Appeal (FCA) found that product design and development in Canada, without physical making of the product, will not infringe Canadian patents.

The court rejected the argument that Canadian patent law needed to evolve, given that modern design software allows products to be fully designed in Canada and then manufactured abroad. In doing so, the court maintained the status quo and kept Canadian patent law from plunging down a slippery slope where product design can ground infringement. As concluded by the court, “it would be for Parliament (not the courts) to move the threshold for patent infringement.”

Background

ProSlide Technology Inc. and WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd. are Canadian corporations and the two largest competitors in the global market for water slides. ProSlide sued WhiteWater for allegedly infringing a number of its Canadian patents. At trial, the Federal Court found in favour of WhiteWater, concluding that numerous claims of ProSlide’s patents were invalid and not infringed.

On infringement, the focus of this update, the key facts were that the relevant patent claims are to physical objects (e.g. water slide components), but WhiteWater never had such objects in Canada. All of the relevant manufacture happened abroad. Nevertheless, ProSlide contended its Canadian patents were infringed because virtually all of WhiteWater’s design and development activities, short of physical manufacture, took place in Canada.

Federal Court relies on Steelhead to find non-infringement

In rejecting ProSlide’s case for infringement, the Federal Court relied on the FCA’s earlier decision in Steelhead LNG (ASLNG) Ltd. v. Arc Resources Ltd, 2024 FCA 67. In Steelhead, the FCA determined that a patent to a natural gas (LNG) facility was not infringed when the defendants shared an engineering study for an LNG facility that, if it had been built, would have fallen within the patent’s claims. The FCA found that, even if the defendants benefited from sharing the engineering study, doing so was not “using the invention” under the Patent Act, as the invention was to an LNG facility (not engineering designs) and an infringing facility was never built.

The Federal Court found that the legal principles from Steelhead were a “complete answer” to ProSlide’s assertion that WhiteWater had infringed its patents without actually having any infringing objects in Canada. The Federal Court held: “Where a patent claims a physical object, the patentee’s exclusive rights under section 42 of the Patent Act to ‘use’ the invention extend only to that object. They do not also include the use of conceptual designs or drawings of that object.”

FCA affirms on non-infringement

ProSlide appealed the Federal Court’s finding of non-infringement. ProSlide urged the FCA to expand the interpretation of “making… the invention” under the Patent Act in light of advances in design software and global communications. Specifically, ProSlide argued a real and substantial connection existed between WhiteWater’s design activities in Canada and the manufacture of physical components abroad, such that WhiteWater was, in essence, “making… the invention” in Canada.

The FCA rejected ProSlide’s arguments. Writing for a unanimous panel, Justice Locke held that the principles in Steelhead applied, agreeing with the Federal Court that “there is no basis in law to find that generating detailed computer-aided designs and mechanical drawings in Canada is ‘making' the claimed invention, where the invention as claimed is for a physical object.” Just as the engineering study in Steelhead did not “use” the claimed invention (an LNG facility), WhiteWater’s product design in Canada did not “make” the claimed invention (water slide components).

Moreover, the court pointed to a slippery slope: treating design as “making” the invention would inject significant uncertainty into what product development would, or would not, be patent infringement.

ProSlide has 60 days from the date of the FCA’s judgment to apply for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Takeaways

The practical implications of the ProSlide and Steelhead decisions are significant. Even advanced design work in Canada will not suffice to infringe a Canadian patent to a physical object or system (e.g. an LNG facility, a water slide component), even if that design work is shared with others, benefits the designer, or is used to direct manufacture of the object abroad. The territorial limits of Canadian patents highlight the importance of obtaining corresponding foreign patents in jurisdictions where products are likely to be manufactured and/or sold.

Contact