Navigating Canada’s income tax system has grown increasingly complex and invasive, and recent developments suggest this trend will only intensify. While Canadians have the obligation to self-assess as opposed to self-audit, over the past years the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has steadily sought to expand its audit powers, resulting in a more intrusive and demanding audit environment for taxpayers.

Audit activity has increased significantly in both frequency and scope. Taxpayers are now routinely faced with broad and burdensome information requests, often extending well beyond what appears reasonably necessary to address the issues under review.

It is not uncommon to see more than 40 document queries in a single audit, often without the taxpayer or its advisors having any clear visibility into the underlying issues or specific concerns driving the CRA’s review. In many cases, what starts as a bona fide audit gradually turns into a fishing expedition where virtually any existing document or piece of information is treated as compellable.

This shift is reflected across multiple fronts: from the CRA’s Related Party Initiative to a more permissive and simplistic approach to reopening the normal reassessment period, to audits that can remain ongoing for years without resolution. The overall direction is clear: the CRA is demanding more from taxpayers while offering less in terms of predictability, transparency, and accountability. It has become increasingly common for audits to extend over several years, for objections to remain unresolved well beyond expected timeframes, and for access to information requests to produce limited or delayed results.

The most recent step in this evolution came on May 4, 2026, when the Department of Finance released updated draft legislation (now introduced as Bill C-31) that would significantly expand the CRA’s powers to compel information, documents, and oral testimony from both taxpayers and third parties. These amendments would materially expand audit and enforcement powers, without introducing meaningful safeguards such as clear limits on scope or reasonable timelines for completing audits.

Taxpayers should be prepared for a more assertive audit environment and proactively seek guidance from tax dispute professionals in anticipation of potential issues.

The proposed amendments in Bill C-31 were preceded by initial draft legislation in August 2025, that was widely viewed as controversial and prompted significant concern and criticism within the tax community. We summarize below the most significant and recent developments relating to these proposed legislative changes.

No more affidavit or testimony under oath

In its current form, the draft legislation no longer includes the earlier proposal that would have authorized the minister to compel taxpayers to provide sworn testimonies, whether in person or by affidavit. Specifically, proposed section 231.41 of the Income Tax Act (the ITA) has been removed from the legislative package.

This measure had been one of the most contentious elements of the original proposal and attracted significant criticism from the tax community. Its removal represents a meaningful and welcome response to those concerns.

There remain significant concerns with CRA interviews, particularly the agency’s reluctance to permit recordings or transcripts prepared by an independent third party. That said, this still represents a meaningful improvement over the previous draft legislation.

Revised threshold of the 10% compliance order penalty

Where the CRA successfully applies to the Federal Court for a compliance order to obtain information or/and documents from a taxpayer, the draft legislation proposes a penalty equal to 10% of the total tax payable for each taxation year covered by the order. This represents a significant shift from the earlier proposal, which contemplated a penalty of “up to” that amount. The revised wording removes discretion at the assessment stage and effectively establishes a fixed, non-discretionary penalty.

This penalty will not apply where the taxpayer had a reasonable basis to believe the requested information was protected by solicitor client privilege, or where the tax payable for the relevant taxation year is less than C$50,000.

This is unfortunately largely insufficient as there are other reasonable bases to refuse the production of documents and information requested by CRA, such has litigation privilege, settlement privilege, confidentiality and the fact taxpayers cannot be completed to reveal their “soft spots.”

That said, the legislation preserves the CRA’s ability to waive or reduce the penalty, as well as any related accrued interest, where its application would be disproportionate or unfair. While this relief mechanism provides some flexibility, it remains discretionary and will require taxpayers to actively seek such relief.

New formal notice with daily penalties is maintained

The proposed rules maintain the CRA’s authority to issue a formal “notice of non-compliance” where a taxpayer fails to fully answer an information request, triggering daily penalties for non-compliance with audit-related obligations.

The legislation introduces an important procedural safeguard for third parties. Where the CRA seeks information from a third party regarding an unrelated taxpayer, the minister must first obtain a compliance order from the Federal Court before issuing a notice of non-compliance. This requirement is meant to impose a meaningful check on the CRA’s powers in these circumstances.

Broad access to offshore records continues

The CRA’s audit powers remain vast, including its ability to compel the disclosure of information and documents located outside Canada in specific circumstances. The proposed rules introduce a minimum 90-day response period for such requests and limit the bases on which the federal court may refuse to authorize a demand.

However, as initially contemplated, these powers are reinforced as they are now expressly integrated into the notice of non-compliance regime and may be enforced through compliance orders.

Importantly, the consequences of non-compliance are significant. Where a taxpayer fails to produce foreign-based information, a court may prohibit the taxpayer from relying on that information in any subsequent legal proceedings.

Suspension of limitation periods in specified contexts

The draft legislation introduces rules that suspend the normal reassessment period for both taxpayers and related parties in certain circumstances. In practical terms, the reassessment period is paused for the duration of any dispute, whether it involves a judicial review, a contested compliance order, or an outstanding notice of non-compliance. These measures are clearly intended to prevent taxpayers from reaching the limitation period by prolonging information requests and disputes.

While these changes will likely extend audit timelines and heighten the stakes associated with tax disputes, they should not deter taxpayers from appropriately challenging overbroad, illegal or unreasonable audit requests. Strategic and well-founded challenges remain a critical safeguard in an increasingly assertive audit environment.

Key takeaways

The expansion of CRA audit powers does not — and cannot — mean the absence of limits. Government authority, no matter how broadly legislated, must always be exercised within a framework that is legal, proportionate, and reasonable. From the initial demand letter to compliance order proceedings to reassessment, our role is to ensure that at every stage of an audit the CRA cannot simply do as it pleases. Taxpayers have rights. We work with them to ensure those rights are actively asserted and fully enforced when the stakes are highest.

Contact