A requirement in a company’s by-laws for shareholders to resolve disputes through private arbitration is known as a “mandatory arbitration” clause. While recent developments by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission make it more likely for these clauses to be used in the US, the situation is less clear in Canada.
Mandatory arbitration by-laws in the US’s new IPO era
On December 1, 2025, Zion Oil and Gas, a Dallas-based and biblically inspired oil and gas exploration company, amended its by-laws to include a mandatory arbitration clause. This disclosure came ten weeks after the SEC’s September 17 announcement clarifying it would not block from the public market companies that banned shareholders from accessing courts to resolve disputes. According to a Bloomberg Law review of SEC records, Zion Oil and Gas is the first company to mandate arbitration since the September announcement.
The new SEC policy emphasized the role of disclosure in protecting shareholder interests: “We believe that any relevant issues concerning an issuer-investor mandatory arbitration provision are best addressed through complete and adequate disclosure of material information.” SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins described this reform as part of the SEC’s plan to “Make IPOs Great Again” in an October 9 keynote address. Mr. Atkins encouraged states to follow suit in this approach.1
The Canadian perspective
Canadian courts and securities regulators have not been similarly clear on this issue.
In Canada, there has been a rise in adoption of “forum selection” or “exclusive forum” clauses in public company by-laws. These clauses specify the jurisdiction in which legal proceedings against the company must be brought. If properly drafted, forum selection by-laws specifying a jurisdiction for disputes are likely enforceable. However, the status of “mandatory arbitration” by-laws—being one type of forum selection clause—is much more uncertain. While mandatory arbitration by-laws may help protect companies by reducing securities litigation and shareholder activism, it is not obvious how these by-laws would be treated under Canadian law.
Are by-laws “contracts” in Canada?
Canadian arbitration legislation requires the existence of an arbitration agreement to provide a basis for arbitrator jurisdiction. Any mandatory arbitration clause must therefore be found in a contract between two or more parties.
While contracts are necessarily on consent of the parties, a by-law may be in place prior to a shareholder assenting to the by-law, or even where a shareholder has voted against it. Some corporate law statutes, including in British Columbia and Nova Scotia, treat a company’s articles or by-laws as contractual in nature, expressly stating they are binding on shareholders as if they had been signed and sealed by each shareholder.
In contrast, however, the Canada Business Corporations Act and the business corporations statutes in Ontario and Alberta have no such express provisions. While the Quebec Business Corporations Act does not expressly treat a company’s articles or by-laws as contractual in nature, the Civil Code of Quebec provides that the by-laws of a legal person establish contractual relations between the legal person and its members. The enforceability of a mandatory arbitration by-law is therefore less certain for companies incorporated outside of British Columbia, Quebec and Nova Scotia.
However, Ontario courts have enforced forum selection clauses in similar contexts, including a forum clause in the by-laws of a baseball league2 and an arbitration clause in the by-laws of a non-profit organization.3
Public policy considerations
It is possible for a court to strike down a by-law for being unreasonable or contrary to public policy. Public policy considerations cut both ways on this issue. Arbitration clauses often pose a financial barrier to litigation and may effectively preclude class action lawsuits. However, public policy may also favour enforcing a valid agreement between two parties, including enforcement of a valid arbitration clause—the Supreme Court of Canada strongly endorses the enforcement of arbitration clauses.
The SCC has declined to enforce forum selection and arbitration provisions in the context of consumer contracts where inequality of bargaining power and cost barriers exist, as in Facebook and Uber. The subject matter of the proposed litigation informs the analysis—while Facebook dealt with the “quasi-constitutional” privacy rights of consumers, courts may not find that shareholders’ rights vis-à-vis a corporation warrant the same protection.
Other legislation does not squarely address this issue
Other relevant legislation does not clearly answer the questions of whether and how a shareholders’ ability to pursue litigation would be affected by mandatory arbitration by-laws in Ontario, including securities, class action, and consumer protection legislation:
1. Securities: Ontario’s Securities Act provides for shareholder remedies but does not contain any clear language that would invalidate an arbitration agreement either directly, as is the case of Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, or indirectly, such as through the presence of a non-waiver provision that voids any waiver or release of rights under the Act.
2. Class actions: Ontario’s Class Proceedings Act, 1992 also does not explicitly answer this question. Ontario courts, however, have considered whether proposed class actions must be stayed in the face of a mandatory arbitration clause and have determined that such clauses are simply a consideration as to the “preferable procedure” analysis for class action certification.4
3. Consumer protection: Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act states clearly that arbitration clauses in consumer agreements are invalid insofar as they prevent recourse to the Superior Court. However, regardless of whether by-laws could constitute a consumer agreement, the CPA does not apply to transactions regulated under the Securities Act.
Takeaways
The law on mandatory arbitration by-laws has yet to be settled in Canada. While the SEC has signalled it will not take issue with such provisions, Canadian courts and securities regulators have yet to take a definitive position.
Beyond the legal analysis, companies considering mandatory arbitration by-laws should be mindful of how such provisions will be received by institutional investors and proxy advisors, who have generally recommended voting against broad forum selection by-laws absent a compelling justification and a strong governance track record.
Footnotes
-
The SEC chairman encouraged states to follow suit, commenting on a change in Delaware earlier last year: In August 2025, Delaware amended its corporate laws to expressly permit corporate by-laws to mandate that internal corporate claims be brought in Delaware and prohibit by-laws from mandating arbitration with respect to these claims.
-
2010 ONCA 722 (aff’d 2012 SCC 9).
-
2005 CanLII 36153 (ON CA) at para 14.