On October 9, the Quebec Court of Appeal allowed the appeal brought by the companies operating Tim Hortons restaurants and dismissed an application for authorization to institute a class action filed on behalf of approximately 500,000 participants in the “Roll Up to Win” contest who had mistakenly received an email informing them they had won a boat valued at C$68,7511.

The Court of Appeal thereby overturned the Superior Court’s decision authorizing the proposed class action and holding that the defendants’ arguments should be determined by the trial judge on the merits.

Background

The Roll Up to Win contest ran from March 4 to March 31, 2024. Under the contest rules, all rolls had to be revealed no later than April 12, 2024. The proposed class representative had rolled 24 entries in the Roll Up to Win contest and won six instant prizes. He therefore knew he had not won the boat, which was the only prize of its kind among the more than 16 million prizes available in the contest. On April 17, 2024, after the contest had ended, he received an email erroneously stating he had won the boat. A subsequent email was then sent to correct the error.

Dissatisfied with the response provided by Tim Hortons’ customer service department, the proposed class representative filed an application for authorization to institute a class action, alleging the defendants had contravened sections 41 and 42 of the Consumer Protection Act (CPA), which provide that a representation or advertisement concerning goods or services is binding on a merchant. The plaintiff sought an order requiring the defendants to deliver the boat or, alternatively, its monetary value, as well as compensatory damages for the stress and inconvenience allegedly suffered by class members and C$10,000 in punitive damages for each class member.

Court of Appeal’s decision

The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for authorization on the basis that the criterion of an arguable case under section 575(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure was not met. According to the court, sections 41 and 42 of the CPA apply to representations made before or contemporaneously with the formation of a contract. They do not apply to post-contractual representations.

These provisions are intended to protect consumers’ reasonable expectations created by merchants’ representations that influenced their decisions to enter into a contract. Since the email received by the proposed class members was sent after the contest had ended, it could not constitute a pre-contractual representation capable of influencing their decisions to enter into a consumer contract.

The Court of Appeal further emphasized that the proposed class representative had no legitimate expectation of receiving the boat, since he had already revealed all of his rolls and knew which prizes he had actually won. Put differently, the plaintiff had never won the boat despite the email he received. The court concluded that the proposed action was based on an “indisputable logical flaw”: how could the fact of never having won a prize lead to a conclusion requiring the merchant to award it?

Lastly, the court held that the motion judge erred in finding that the issue of whether the email constituted a pre contractual representation should be left to the trial judge. The court reiterated that the threshold for authorization remains low and appellate courts should generally show deference to decisions rendered at this stage. However, where, as in this case, the alleged facts and the documentary evidence are unequivocal, and existing jurisprudence already definitively answers the legal issue raised, there is no need to defer the matter to a trial on the merits. In other words, no evidence adduced at trial could alter the fact that the email was sent after the contest had ended.

Key takeaways

  • Sections 41 and 42 of the CPA do not apply to post-contractual representations. They protect consumers’ reasonable expectations created by representations made before or at the time of contracting.
  • Although the threshold for authorization of a class action is low, an application based on an incorrect legal theory or on reasoning tainted by an indisputable logical flaw will be dismissed.
  • Where a legal issue has already been definitively resolved by the courts and the alleged facts and documentary evidence are unequivocal, the issue may be decided at the authorization stage.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Restaurant Brands International Inc. c. Deschâtelets, 2026 QCCA 1354.

Contact

secondary

true

bynder-sourced