A significant Ontario Court of Appeal decision has reshaped the legal landscape for employee equity compensation. In Wigdor v Facebook Canada Ltd., the court held that a provision in a restricted stock unit (RSU) agreement seeking to prevent vesting during the statutory notice period set out in the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) violated the ESA and rendered the provision unenforceable.

As a result, the employee was entitled to damages on account of continued vesting during the much lengthier common law notice period. The decision has significant implications for employers that offer RSUs and other forms of equity compensation and underscores the need for a careful review of existing plan documents, award agreements, and termination provisions.

Background

In 2020, Meta Platforms Inc. acquired Chatham Inc. and hired its founder, Dr. Daniel Wigdor, as Facebook Canada’s director, research science. As part of his compensation package, he received 43,380 RSUs with an estimated value of approximately US$7.5 million, scheduled to vest over a four-year period. Facebook Canada terminated Dr. Wigdor’s employment in December 2023, providing eight weeks’ pay in lieu of notice and 12.5 weeks’ statutory severance pay per the ESA. Dr. Wigdor declined to sign a release that would have prevented him from challenging the forfeiture of his unvested RSUs.

The underlying RSU Agreements contained termination-related forfeiture provisions. The 2020 RSU Agreement provided that all unvested RSUs would be forfeited upon termination and no vesting would continue during any notice period, including the minimum statutory notice period prescribed by the ESA. The 2021–2023 RSU Agreements contained similar language, subject to a saving provision preserving rights “explicitly” imposed by legislation.

At first instance, the lower court held that the employment agreement’s termination clause was unenforceable for failing to recognize Dr. Wigdor’s prior service with Chatham Inc. The court awarded 10 months’ common law reasonable notice but dismissed the RSU claim, reasoning the RSUs were not “wages” or a benefit plan contribution and therefore did not need to be provided where the employer provided pay in lieu of notice under section 61 of the ESA, as opposed to working notice under section 60 of the ESA. Dr. Wigdor appealed the RSU determination.

Sections 60 and 61 of the ESA must be read together

The central issue on appeal was whether the lower court erred by treating sections 60 and 61 of the ESA as separate and unrelated provisions.

Section 60 applies where an employer provides working notice and requires (among other things) that the employer not “alter any other term or condition of employment” during the notice period.

Section 61(1)(a) applies where an employer provides pay in lieu of notice, requiring payment of a lump sum equal to the amount the employee would have been entitled to receive under section 60 had working notice been given.

The Court of Appeal held that these provisions must be read together. Section 61(1)(a)’s reference to the amount the employee “would have been entitled to receive” under section 60 requires assessing the employee's full compensation package during the statutory notice period. The provisions are intended to place employees in the same financial position whether they receive working notice or pay in lieu of notice.

RSUs are a term or condition of employment under the ESA

The Court of Appeal found there was “no real doubt” that Dr. Wigdor’s RSU entitlements were a “term or condition of employment”: the RSU grants were incorporated into the employment agreement, described as employee compensation, vested quarterly and were treated as taxable benefits.

Treating the RSUs as a “term or condition of employment” was dispositive of the appeal on the question of the application of the ESA. As a result, the court declined to determine whether RSUs are “wages” under the ESA, noting the answer may be fact dependent. Whether RSUs are treated as “wages” under the ESA remains a live issue.

Forfeiture provisions contravene the ESA and are unenforceable

Having concluded that RSU vesting was a term or condition of employment, the court held that the forfeiture provisions were void under section 5 of the ESA.

The 2020 RSU Agreement expressly prevented vesting during any notice period, directly conflicting with the required continuation of “terms and conditions of employment” under section 60. The saving language contained in the subsequent agreements did not cure the defect. Because the ESA does not explicitly address RSU vesting, a clause preserving only rights "explicitly" required by legislation was insufficient. Any contractual ambiguity, the court held, must be interpreted in favour of the employee.

In the absence of the forfeiture provisions, Dr. Wigdor was entitled to damages of US$4.7 million representing the value of the 9,405 RSUs that would have vested during the 10-month common law notice period. The court's award therefore extended well beyond the employee's statutory ESA entitlements and captured vesting that would have occurred throughout the substantially longer common law notice period.

Takeaways for employers

For employers offering RSUs or similar equity compensation, Wigdor means:

  • Statutory-notice vesting continues. Sections 60 and 61 operate together, so pay in lieu must reflect what the employee would have received during working notice —meaning terms and conditions of employment, including RSU vesting, cannot be altered.
  • Forfeiture clauses require review. Contractual provisions that purport to extinguish RSU vesting immediately upon termination—even during the statutory notice period—may now be unenforceable as contracting out of the ESA. Employers should review their existing equity compensation agreements in light of this decision.
  • Saving language may not suffice. Generic language preserving statutory minimum standards may not be sufficient. Employers should carefully review whether plan language effectively preserves ESA entitlements in all potential termination scenarios.
  • Compliance is tested at contracting. A gratuitous payment offered after dismissal will not rescue a contractual provision that could operate contrary to the ESA. Drafting must be compliant from the outset. This is distinct from a payment offered further to the execution of a release, which may be enforceable.
  • Legal advice is no defence to an unlawful employment agreement provision. An employee’s sophistication or representation by counsel in negotiating the employment agreement does not affect the enforceability analysis. Employers cannot rely on an employee’s legal sophistication to sustain provisions that contravene the ESA.
  • The “wages” issue remains open. The court left open whether RSUs are wages under the ESA, but this issue did not affect the notice-period analysis because the court had already found that RSUs were a “term or condition of employment.” It may, however, affect other entitlements under the ESA, such as calculating vacation pay.

The Court of Appeal's decision is a significant development in Ontario employment law and reflects an increasingly expansive view of statutory termination entitlements. Employers that offer RSUs or other equity-based awards should review their employment agreements, incentive plans, and award documentation to assess whether existing forfeiture provisions remain enforceable.

Contact