As most Canadian employers know too well, employment agreement termination provisions drafted to comply with employment standards legislation have been successfully challenged on often the most pedantic and trivial of grounds.
In particular, Ontario employers have seen termination provisions invalidated on account of highly technical and overly literal word-by-word analysis. The use of the phrases “at any time” and/or “for any reason” have been enough to put otherwise valid contractual language at risk of being nullified.
Termination provisions have also been at risk for failing to distinguish between a more onerous legislated wilful misconduct standard and a less onerous common law standard, even if the minimum legislated requirements were accounted for. Where a termination provision was determined to be unenforceable, employers became liable to pay terminated employees indeterminate, and often much more onerous, common law notice damages.
Yesterday, the Ontario Court of Appeal brought welcome clarification to the enforceability of termination provisions with a common-sense approach.
Specifically, Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc. confirmed what our employment lawyers have maintained: “at any time” and “for any reason” are not magic words that automatically void an otherwise valid termination clause where the intention to comply with the ESA is otherwise clear on the language. Also, a properly drafted “with cause” termination provision can preserve statutory minimum entitlements by reference, without elaborating on common law just cause and the more onerous wilful misconduct standard.
Background: The lower court
This March, the Court of Appeal heard two separate matters together with nearly identical termination clauses. The first, an appeal of the February 2025 decision Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc. (2025 ONSC 952) (Baker). The second, an appeal of the April 2025 decision Li v. Wayfair Canada Inc. (2025 ONSC 2959) (Li).
In Baker, the use of the words “at any time” in the termination provision was held to be inconsistent with Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (the ESA), rendering the termination clause unenforceable. In Li, a provision permitting without cause termination “at any time and for any reason,” however, was held to be valid and enforceable. The inconsistent findings stem from differing views at the lower court on whether the employer was effectively granting itself blanket discretion to terminate without regard for the ESA by terminating “at any time,” such as during a job-protected leave.
Baker also found that all termination provisions were invalid because the just cause provision failed to differentiate between just cause at common law and wilful misconduct under the ESA, despite that the requisite statutory minimum entitlements were accounted for.
We wrote in detail about Baker, Li and other inconsistent lower court decisions in February 2025 and July 2025, noting that the contradictions at the lower court were ripe for appellate resolution and we would continue to advocate on behalf of employers for a common-sense approach to contractual interpretation.
Court of Appeal decision
Writing for a unanimous panel, Justice Monahan articulated a principled framework and emphasised that interpretation, even in the employment context, remains a contractual exercise focused on the objective intentions of the parties and the wording of the contract as a whole.
In this vein, courts should avoid a legalistic “magic words” approach and should not find ambiguity where none reasonably exists, nor should words within employment agreements be read literally and in isolation. The court also cautioned against formalistic or highly technical interpretations of contractual language, as such an approach could produce indeterminacy and inconsistent results.
For the specific contractual language at issue, the court found that “at any time,” read in the context of the entire termination provision, meant a “without cause” termination will be legally effective regardless of when it occurs. Further, such language did not override the ESA’s prohibitions on terminations in protected circumstances, and it would be improper to read it as intending to render legally effective an expressly prohibited termination.
The court found that the more expansive language of “at any time and for any reason” meant only that termination would be consistent with the contract and therefore legally effective regardless of the reason. It was noted that employers need not provide a reason for terminating the employment contract.
For the “with cause” provision at issue in Baker, the court found that because the clause expressly preserved minimum statutory entitlements, there was no violation of the ESA and the employer need not differentiate in the contract between the legal concepts of just cause and wilful misconduct.
Contractual language which consistently referred to minimum entitlements under the ESA also signalled to the court an intention to comply with statutory provisions on termination.
In all, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in Baker, dismissed the appeal in Li, and enforced the contractual terms both employers entered with their employees.
Significance for employers
This is an important and welcome decision that promotes a modern, practical and common-sense approach to interpretating employment contracts.
It is a good time to revisit active employment law litigation, particularly wrongful dismissal matters where the primary issue in dispute is the termination clause language.
Language permitting termination “at any time” and/or “for any reason” will not, by itself, violate the ESA where the language is otherwise clear that ESA compliance will be met. Further, “just cause” can be referenced more broadly so long as an employee’s minimum entitlements are preserved. On a more general note, the Court of Appeal signalled a return to a common-sense approach to interpreting termination provisions in employment agreements. Gone are the days (for now) where any conceivable interpretation of a word in isolation could render a termination provision unenforceable.
Employers, however, must not treat this decision as carte blanche. Drafting termination provisions still requires employers to tread carefully. In particular, the Court of Appeal declined to reconsider Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc. (2020 ONCA 391), meaning that if any aspect of a termination clause violates the ESA, all termination provisions risk being invalidated. As before, termination provisions must remain clear and ESA-compliant on their language.
Employers should be optimistic about this decision, keeping in mind that leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada may be sought. In the meantime, the Norton Rose Fulbright Canada team will continue to assist its clients in drafting enforceable employment agreements and in building upon the momentum of this well-reasoned decision.