The Court of Appeal’s decision in The Winros Partnership v Global Energy Horizons Corporation[2026] EWCA Civ 654 is a timely reminder of the need for parties to consider their termination options carefully, as a failure to exercise contractual remedies in instances of breach of contract can have significant consequences.

The case concerned a sophisticated conditional fee agreement (CFA), under which the parties had carefully calibrated the allocation of legal fees and disbursements depending on the outcome of the litigation and the way in which the retainer ended. The Court held that, where a contract expressly allocates risk and addresses the circumstances that have arisen, a restitutionary claim in unjust enrichment is not available to circumvent that allocation.

Background

The Appellant, The Winros Partnership (formerly Rosenblatt Solicitors, Rosenblatt), was retained by Global Energy Horizons Corporation (Global Energy), the Respondent, in relation to proceedings against a third party. Rosenblatt and Global Energy entered into a series of CFAs, with the final CFA (CFA-3) dated 6 March 2013.

Under the terms of CFA-3, Rosenblatt was entitled to its full fees, as well as a success fee on the condition that Global Energy won its claim. Should Global Energy lose the claim, Rosenblatt would only be entitled to retain an advance fee of £300,000. Clause 14.3 gave  Rosenblatt the option to terminate CFA-3 should Global Energy not meet certain requirements set out in CFA-3, and also provided that, in those circumstances, Rosenblatt could recover fees and disbursements up to the termination date.

In 2016, following Global Energy’s alleged failure to pay disbursements and its instruction of another firm to act on its behalf, Rosenblatt terminated CFA-3 on the basis of a repudiatory breach by Global Energy. Rosenblatt decided to accept the repudiatory breach and initiated a claim for damages, while also seeking to bill Global Energy for the work done while CFA-3 was in force (and appropriating funds belonging to Global Energy which it held, in the sum of over £5 million). Crucially, Rosenblatt did not invoke clause 14.3 to terminate CFA-3.

Global Energy disputed that it had to pay any fees to Rosenblatt, arguing that at termination, there had been no “win” under the terms of CFA-3, such that Rosenblatt had no contractual entitlement to fees. Global Energy issued proceedings pursuant to section 70 of the Solicitors Act 1974 to recover the payments taken by Rosenblatt. Rosenblatt appealed, arguing that Global Energy’s repudiatory breach gave rise to a “failure of basis”, and that it was justified in appropriating Global Energy’s funds because Global Energy had been unjustly enriched by Rosenblatt’s work.

Decision

The Appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal.

The Court held that Rosenblatt had no claim in unjust enrichment. It was found that the Court was “concerned with a sophisticated and highly calibrated conditional fee agreement which allocates risk between the parties and addresses numerous situations.” Given that clause 14.3 of CFA-3 explicitly allocated risk in the very circumstances which occurred, Rosenblatt could not use the law on unjust enrichment to attempt to circumvent the risk allocation and claim damages following its failure to exercise a remedial clause. To do so would, as noted by Lady Justice Asplin, “upset the considered exercise of risk allocation expressly contained in CFA-3 […]”.

The Court also held that Rosenblatt’s decision not to rely on clause 14.3 did not create a “failure of basis” – this was a tactical decision to pursue damages at common law rather than invoking the contractual remedy. As stated by Lord Justice Stuart-Smith: “The basis of the contract included the provision in clause 14.3, which directly addressed the situation… That situation arose here and clause 14.3 governs the parties’ obligations notwithstanding Rosenblatt’s strategic and tactical decision to terminate the contract by accepting their client’s repudiatory breach.”

The Court also rejected Rosenblatt’s argument that there is a difference between discharged and subsisting contracts, such that the prospective discharge of a contract after an accepted repudiatory breach gives rise to a presumption that a remedy in unjust enrichment would be available. The Court held that there was no substantive difference between instances of repudiatory breaches and subsisting contracts for the purpose of unjust enrichment claims; the availability of a remedy in unjust enrichment must turn on the relevant facts and circumstances.

Key takeaways

Contractual freedom

Where contractual arrangements are made by which parties have defined their mutual obligations and consequences of a breach, the court will hold parties to that agreement and will not permit unjust enrichment claims to override the agreed risk allocation.

Termination options

There are different consequences when a contract is terminated for material breach (pursuant to a contractual term) and when a contract is terminated at common law for repudiatory breach. This decision highlights the need to carefully consider all termination options available in a contract and their consequences prior to terminating, to ensure that terminating party receives the best remedy. The chosen basis of termination should be clearly stated in the termination notice, together with the associated consequences.

With thanks to Sam Matravers for his assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post