The situation in the Middle East has created a landscape of uncertainty for businesses with interests in the Gulf States and beyond. Supply chains are under pressure, energy markets are volatile, and the continued uncertainty presents challenges to businesses with operations in the region. For commercial parties, a number of significant legal and practical issues arise that demand careful consideration.

We have previously considered the kinds of issues that may arise from this disruption, and how they can be dealt with as a matter of English law here. This blog considers those same issues from the perspective of the three main legal systems in the UAE, being:

  1. Onshore UAE law – a civil law system rooted in the UAE Civil Code;
  2. Dubai International Financial Centre (“DIFC”) law – a common law legal system that adopts aspects of English law, but also diverges in significant ways; or
  3. Abu Dhabi Global Market (“ADGM”) law – a common law legal system that more closely follows English law than DIFC law, but also diverges from English law in significant ways.

Each of these regimes adopts slightly different approaches to legal concepts such as frustration and force majeure, and matters concerning supply chain disruption. This article examines the principal areas of law and regulation from the perspective of each of these three regimes and offers practical guidance on how businesses can protect their positions.

Frustration and Force Majeure

Onshore UAE Law

Under onshore UAE law, concepts of frustration and force majeure are codified in Articles 273 and 249 of the UAE Civil Code.

Article 273 provides that where a supervening event, which is not the fault of either party, makes the performance of a contractual obligation impossible (not merely more difficult or more expensive), the corresponding obligation is automatically extinguished and the contract is terminated. However, the impossibility of performance must be total; where only part of the obligation becomes impossible, only that part is extinguished, and the counterparty may elect to terminate the remainder or to accept partial performance.

In turn, Article 249 provides that where exceptional and unforeseeable events occur which renders performance of a contract excessively onerous such that the obligor is threatened with “grave loss”, a court may reduce the onerous obligation to a reasonable level. Notably, this provision does not require performance to be impossible, only significantly more onerous than initially anticipated.

In this regard, the UAE position regarding frustration and force majeure is a significant departure from the English law position, where mere hardship or increased expense will not relieve a party of its contractual obligations. It provides a potential remedy for parties for whom performance would be impossible or economically unfeasible, but still possible. Accordingly, Articles 273 and 249 may be useful tools for businesses affected by conflict-related disruption in the Gulf region.

However, simply because onshore UAE law expressly provides protections for events of frustration and force majeure, that does not mean parties should not draft contracts to include force majeure provisions. In practice, where a contract governed by onshore UAE law contains an express force majeure clause, this may serve to bolster the statutory provisions.

Accordingly, businesses should consider the extent to which their contractual relationships are affected by the current events and whether they fall within the statutory protection provided by UAE law. It would also be prudent for businesses to review their contracts to determine whether they contain force majeure provisions and whether they are engaged by the current crisis (as to which see our previous guidance here).

DIFC Law

DIFC law, while sharing similarities with English law, differs in a number of ways. In particular, it codifies a concept of force majeure (which in English law is a purely contractual remedy).

Article 82 of the DIFC Contract Law provides a statutory regime for force majeure. Under this provision, non-performance by a party is excused if that party proves that the non-performance was due to an impediment beyond its control and that it could not reasonably be expected to have taken the impediment into account, or to have avoided or overcome it or its consequences, at the time of concluding the contract.

Article 82 also provides that where the impediment is only temporary, performance will only be excused for as long a period as is reasonable, having regard to the effect of the impediment on the performance of the contract.

Nothing in Article 82 prevents the payment of a debt due under a contract.

Article 82 provisions apply regardless of whether the contract contains an express force majeure clause. Where the contract does contain an express force majeure clause, that clause will operate alongside the statutory provision.

Finally, the concept of frustration is not specifically provided for in the DIFC Contract Law. However, given the statutory force majeure provisions set out in Article 82, it may be rare that a party would seek to rely on the doctrine in isolation.

ADGM Law

The ADGM applies English common law. As a result, the English law doctrine of frustration applies in broadly the same manner as described in the English law analysis (linked here). As discussed in our previous analysis, the threshold for frustration is high, and merely increased expense of performance will not suffice. Frustration will only apply where a supervening event makes performance impossible, illegal, or something radically different from that originally envisioned by the parties. Where frustration applies, the contract is automatically discharged and future performance is released.

Given the doctrine's restrictive application, parties should not regard frustration as a reliable or predictable regime for the allocation or mitigation of legal risks.

Much like English law, there is no free-standing doctrine of force majeure in ADGM law. Rather, force majeure is a purely contractual mechanism and the extent to which a contract may be avoided for force majeure will be determined by the specific wording and content of the contract. Accordingly, parties should ensure that their contracts contain express force majeure clauses so as to provide greater protection from unforeseen events.

Liquidated Damages

There is already significant disruption to shipping routes, energy supplies, and broader supply chains across the region. Businesses that depend on the transit of goods through the Strait of Hormuz or other affected areas face the prospect of delays, increased costs, and interruption to their operations.

Onshore UAE Law

Supply and construction contracts often provide liquidated damages or penalty clauses related to delays. Where contracts governed by onshore UAE law contain such clauses, Article 390 of the UAE Civil Code permits a court to vary the agreed compensation so that it is equal to the actual loss suffered. This may afford significant protection to businesses who may be facing penalties related to supply chain disruption.

DIFC Law

Liquidated damages and penalty clauses are generally enforceable as a matter of DIFC Law. Article 122 of the DIFC Contract Law provides that liquidated damages clauses will be upheld “irrespective of [the counterparties’] actual harm”. However, similar to UAE law, Article 122 also provides that a court may reduce the liquidated damages provision to a “reasonable amount where it is grossly excessive in relation to the harm”. Again, this may offer parties facing business interruption some relief in the event their counterparty seeks to enforce a liquidated damages provision.

ADGM Law

Under ADGM law, liquidated damages or penalty clauses are generally upheld so long as they protect some legitimate interest of the counterparty.

Parties facing disruption should document all such disruptions, their mitigation efforts, and communications with counterparties, as these will be critical in the event of any subsequent dispute, regardless of the applicable legal framework.

Insurance

Regardless of the particular governing law of any parties’ commercial contracts, parties operating in the region with insurance policies should review our previous note (here) to determine key issues that may affect claims and premiums.

Conclusion

The Middle East crisis presents a complex and rapidly evolving set of legal challenges for commercial entities. The three legal frameworks operating within the UAE (namely onshore UAE law, ADGM law, and DIFC law) each approach these challenges from a different perspective, with significant differences in the treatment of frustration, force majeure, and liquidated damages.

In response to the disruption in the region, businesses should conduct a comprehensive review of all contracts, paying particular attention to their governing law clauses, and considering how the above issues may affect their obligations under those contracts.

Businesses that act swiftly to understand their legal position under the applicable regime, engage with counterparties, and take proactive steps to mitigate risk will be best placed to navigate the uncertainty ahead.

Contact