The latest conflict in the Middle East raises a number of potential legal issues for the shipping community. In this article we address a number of the key legal issues which shipping companies may need to consider.

Contractual issues

Parties with chartered vessels trading to the Strait of Hormuz and other areas in the regions affected by the latest conflict will first need to understand their respective rights and obligations under the charterparty and any other contractual arrangements – such as financings.  There will be no single answer to these questions– each case will require careful reading of the terms, an understanding of the situation leading up to execution of the agreement and the characteristics of the vessel itself and its itinerary.

Charters

The clauses in any charterparty must be read in context but some of the issues to be considered will be:

Does the charter incorporate a war risks clause?

  • If it does: these are often based on BIMCO’s War Risks Clause for Time Chartering 2013 (CONWARTIME 2013) and/or BIMCO’s War Risks Clause for Voyage Chartering 2013 (VOYWAR 2013). Parties will need to consider on a case by case basis whether these clauses are engaged and what this means for the vessel – for example, does the master have the right to decide to re-route?

    Both CONWARTIME 2013 and VOYWAR 2013 operate where the vessel “may be” exposed to a defined war risk and English law applies a relatively broad test when considering the rights of shipowners and masters to exercise their rights under CONWARTIME 2013 or VOYWAR 2013.  English courts have held that the threshold of “may be” will be satisfied if, in the opinion of the shipowner or master, there is, based on evidence rather than speculation, a real likelihood of the vessel being exposed to a defined war risk. The test for this threshold is fact-specific, objective rather than subjective and any decision to re-route a vessel must be made in good faith (see The “Triton Lark” No.1 [2012] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 151 Teare J and The “Triton Lark” No.2 [2012] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 457).

    Clearly, the safety of each vessel’s crew is paramount and it is obviously a very difficult time for seafarers in particular. Crew safety is often an important limb of war risks clauses and, where this is included in charters, shipowners and masters will need to take into account the dangers and risks posed to the crew when making re-routing decisions.

    Charterers are usually required to indemnify shipowners for claims made against the shipowner which arise out of the vessel proceeding in accordance with the provisions of sub-clauses (b) to (f) of VOYWAR 2013 and the provisions of sub-clauses (b) to (h) of CONWARTIME 2013, so it is important to ensure that any notices are well documented and contemporaneous evidence supporting the decision to re-route is collected in case a dispute arises (which may be the case if the indemnity demanded is particularly high). It is also important to follow the requirements of the clause – for example if this requires that the master takes the decision rather than a committee solely ashore (as VOYWAR 2013 and CONWARTIME 2013 do) this cannot be delegated to management solely ashore and the master must be involved with, and take, the final decision.
  • If it does not: If there are not any specific war risk provisions in the charterparty, the parties’ obligations and liabilities will be established in accordance with any express or implied terms. Shipowners may be able to re-route the vessel by relying on:

    • an overriding contractual duty to ensure the safety of the vessel and its crew which would provide grounds to re-route a vessel;
    • a safe port/berth clause - most traders/charterers will have contractually agreed to warrant or exercise due diligence with respect to the safety of ports, places, and berths to which the vessel is ordered. Several trading contracts also include a similar obligation on behalf of the non-vessel-party in the transaction. It is well established that a port will be considered safe if, in the relevant period of time, the particular ship can reach it, use it and return from it without, in the absence of some abnormal occurrence, being exposed to danger which cannot be avoided by good navigation and seamanship. The scope of “safety” is extremely broad, and it extends beyond physical threats to the vessel and its crew.  It includes legal and political safety, such as the risk of arbitrary or unjustified detention by port state authorities. Owners can refuse to comply with charterers' orders to proceed to an unsafe port.  Owners may ask for alternative voyage instructions. Should charterers persist in original orders, they may risk repudiatory breach.  If charterers had given orders to proceed to a port or place that is no longer safe, charterers may be under an obligation to give alternate orders for the vessel to sail to a safe port or place; or
    • although unusual in charters (see further below), there may sometimes be force majeure provisions setting out when the shipowner may be excused from contractual obligations on the basis of events hindering or delaying performance on the grounds that it is beyond the control of the shipowner or charterer.

Force Majeure, Cancellation, Frustration/Impossibility: Typically, trading contracts include force majeure protections, but charterparties do not.  Accordingly, while relief under force majeure clauses should be considered under trading contracts, such relief may not be available under most charters. If you would like to know more about force majeure clauses please see our article The Middle East conflict: Key legal issues for commercial entities.

Some charters include cancellation clauses, which may permit some relief under the current conditions – parties will need to consider these carefully. Finally, parties may give consideration to the doctrine of frustration which may afford relief if the breakout of hostilities makes the performance of contractual obligations so radically different from that which was reasonably contemplated at the execution of the contract, such that it would be unjust to hold the parties to the obligations.

Marine Insurance

Shipping companies will need to ensure that they have the necessary insurance cover in place. A number of insurers have issued cancellation notices for various policies and so shipowners, operators and charterers will need to cooperate to ensure that vessels in affected regions have the requisite insurance in place. The US International Development Finance Corporation (DFC) has also reported that it will offer Political Risk Insurance and Guaranty products to help support American and allied businesses operating in these areas, so companies will need to consider this as part of their business planning if trading in the Middle East.

Financing arrangements

Financiers, whose security is in the asset itself, will need to consider the insurance provisions in their financing documents. For example, does the facility agreement contain an undertaking requiring consent of lenders to enter into an area which has been declared high risk by insurers? If it does, finance parties will want to ensure that their consent is being sought where required and that they receive requisite evidence of any additional insurance which might need to be put in place.  Other provisions which parties will need to consider are contractual requirements around having insurances – including war risks insurances – in place and events of default relating to maintenance of insurance. In light of recent press reports about some cancellation provisions in some marine policies being triggered, financiers may wish to understand what their agreements say about the ability to ask for copies of correspondence with insurers so they can understand the insurance position for a financed vessel. Financiers in shipping facilities will usually have mortgagee’s interest insurance in place and prudent lenders will no doubt want to check they are fully covered in this respect. As discussed above, borrowers will of course need to consider their insurance position and take all necessary steps to make sure that they have adequate cover in place, whilst also ensuring that they comply with any obligations relating to the provision of information to the lenders under the terms of the facility documentation.

However, it should be noted that if the vessel is a platform or similar which is ultimately on hire to a state-owned oil company then that state may be willing to provide insurer of last resort insurance to keep production going - the borrower should be investigating this and, if available, putting such insurance in place to satisfy the lenders.

Practical steps for shipping companies

As the conflict in the Middle East progresses, shipowners and operators affected by this will need to be mindful of their contractual rights and obligations. Some practical steps to consider for those affected by these developments are:

  • Evidence: parties should collect contemporaneous documents and communications relating to the decision to re-route the vessel to demonstrate the “real likelihood” of risk to the crew and vessel, any steps taken to mitigate losses or delays caused by the re-routing, and any evidence of loss;
  • Notice: if shipowners intend to invoke a clause such as CONWARTIME 2013 or VOYWAR 2013, they should consider if notice is required and, if so, what form the notice should take to ensure that the relevant clause is effective;
  • Amendments to contracts: any amendments to charterparties or to documents of title should be clearly documented and validly executed;
  • Indemnities: charterers are required to indemnify shipowners for any claims made under any bills of lading, waybills or evidence of contract of carriage in the event of re-routing or alternative port nomination;
  • Stakeholder liaison: to avoid the risk of a dispute, shipowners and charterers should cooperate to find solutions to issues resulting from re-routing and work together to mitigate losses and delays; and
  • Insurance: shipowners should continue to review the JWC list of areas of enhanced risk and ensure that the vessel’s insurance policies are updated if necessary and, if the vessel is financed, ensure that they are complying with any insurance requirements under the facility documents.

Please do contact us if you require further advice on any of these areas.

Contact