The House of Lords' Constitution Committee has published HL Paper 246 on the Pension Schemes Bill 2024/26, referencing conclusions made by the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee in an earlier report.
The Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee’s report highlighted the “skeletal” nature of the Bill, noting that it contains “much more in the way of delegated powers than is normal in Bills (in general) and in pensions legislation (in particular)” and that it provides “a licence for Ministers to make subordinate legislation”.
Whilst recognising the complex legal regime for regulating pension schemes, the House of Lords paper states “the blanket justification provided by the Government for taking this approach is insufficient to justify the extent to which this Bill is reliant on delegated powers”. The report adds: “The House may wish to seek further justification for the skeletal nature of this Bill, in order to be assured of the necessity of the Bill’s extensive delegations of power”.
The report also highlights the Bill's inconsistencies in its approach to providing for appeals processes against penalties, suggesting that this should not be left to “governmental discretion”. The report states: “while — in the absence of an appeals process — regulator decisions may be subject to judicial review, a judicial review can only proceed on specific, and limited, grounds. The Government should either provide an explanation for the differences of approach within the Bill or amend it to bring consistency between these provisions”.