Introduction

Authorised Push Payment (APP) fraud continues to be one of the most damaging and rapidly evolving forms of financial crime in the UK. In these scams, victims are tricked into willingly transferring money to fraudsters under the guise of legitimate transactions. Unlike unauthorised fraud, where criminals gain access to accounts without consent, APP fraud exploits trust, making it harder to detect and prevent. A July 2025 report by the fair banking all-party parliamentary group (APPG) (the Fair Banking Report) estimated the annual cost of APP fraud at £3.3 billion.

The UK has seen significant developments in relation to APP fraud in recent years, including the APP fraud reimbursement requirement (the Reimbursement Requirement) which came into effect in October 2024 (the key documents for which are set out on the website of the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR), including Specific Direction 20), further preventative steps taken by the industry to reduce instances of fraud and a number of cases working their way through the courts.

In this briefing we discuss: (i) some of the issues facing firms in operating the Reimbursement Requirement; (ii) the practical impact of the Reimbursement Requirement; (iii) proposals regarding a review of the Reimbursement Requirement by the PSR; and (iv) recent litigation relating to APP fraud and the key takeaways for firms.

In summary, whilst it appears that the Reimbursement Requirement is having a positive impact in this area, firms have been experiencing a number of issues in its application and the APPG has highlighted a number of areas for the PSR to consider in its independent review of the effectiveness of the Reimbursement Requirement. APP fraud victims who don’t qualify for reimbursement are continuing to turn to litigation, with potential retrieval duties and derivative claims emerging as key areas of focus.

Issues facing firms

The Reimbursement Requirement, which came into effect in October 2024, replaced the voluntary Contingent Reimbursement Model Code introduced in 2019 (the CRM Code). In summary, it mandates reimbursement for victims of APP fraud subject to certain specific exceptions; covers payments made via Faster Payments and CHAPS; and applies to consumers, micro-businesses, and charities.

The cost of reimbursement is shared equally between the sending and receiving payment service providers (PSPs), with refunds to be issued generally within five working days. The maximum reimbursement per claim is £85,000 and PSPs are permitted to apply a £100 excess. Exceptions to reimbursement include cases where the customer knowingly participated in fraud, acted with gross negligence, or where the dispute is civil rather than fraud-related (e.g., dissatisfaction with goods or services).

A range of issues have arisen as in-scope firms have been getting to grips with the operation of the Reimbursement Requirement in practice:

  • Circumstances in which the Reimbursement Requirement applies: The application of the Reimbursement Requirement is not always straightforward in practice, in particular where there is an international element to the transaction but with certain legs of the payment journey completed in the UK. In addition, for the Reimbursement Requirement to apply, the payment must be: (i) not to the recipient the consumer intended; or (ii) for a purpose other than that intended by the consumer. This can give rise to difficult assessments as to whether a payment was made to the intended recipient or for the intended purpose. By way of example, the customer may have intended to transfer money to a third party for an investment purpose which, with the benefit of hindsight, turns out not to have been all that it seemed or was promised.
  • The “consumer standard of caution exception”: Reimbursement is not required where a sending PSP can demonstrate that a consumer has, as a result of gross negligence, not complied with one or more of certain listed standards, including having regard to any intervention made by the sending PSP (such as a warning given to the consumer prior to the payment being made). The CRM Code included a similar provision under which reimbursement was not required if an ‘effective warning’ had been given to the consumer but ignored. However, the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) has tended to apply this exception narrowly. For example, the FOS has deemed warnings to have been ineffective where they did not entirely match the fraud that was subsequently perpetrated on the consumer, and also concluded that a warning was not ignored where the consumer took some steps to check whether there may have been a fraud even if the consumer ultimately proceeded with the payment in question. We have also seen examples of the FOS deciding, in other contexts, that the bar for gross negligence is high and that certain actions did not constitute gross negligence, for example writing down card and online banking details which resulted in fraud, or failing to remove a card from an ATM. We expect that the FOS will take a similarly ‘customer-centric’ approach in relation to the ‘consumer standard of caution exception’ in the Reimbursement Requirement.
  • Challenging FOS decisions: Challenging a decision of the FOS relating to APP fraud reimbursement also has its difficulties. First, the bar to succeed in judicial review is a high one, with the firm in question having to establish that the decision was unlawful, usually on the basis that the decision was irrational or unreasonable. This is particularly difficult where Parliament has given the FOS a broad discretion to decide what is “fair and reasonable” in the circumstances. In addition, pursuing a formal FOS determination carries high stakes for firms as they are bound by the outcome (which is highly unpredictable) and an adverse decision might have wider implications and potentially affect its overall strategy for dealing with APP fraud claims. Proposed reforms to the FOS, which aim to improve clarity and consistency of decisions, may assist but do not include any additional mechanism allowing firms to appeal decisions of the FOS and the ability to refer matters to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) may create additional uncertainty and risk for firms.
  • Differing views of sending PSP and receiving PSP: The cost-sharing aspect of the Reimbursement Requirement such that sending and receiving PSPs split the reimbursement 50/50 can also cause issues.  For example, a sending PSP may decide to reimburse a customer in circumstances where the receiving PSP would not have done so. There is currently no mechanism under the Reimbursement Requirement for the resolution of any resulting disputes or to ensure consistency of approach.

Whilst there has historically been a lack of enforcement action by the PSR, compliance with the Reimbursement Requirement is likely to be an area that the PSR will be looking at closely.

Impact of the Reimbursement Requirements

In May 2025, the PSR published a "snapshot" of the key issues observed by the PSR since the introduction of the Reimbursement Requirement, including how PSPs had implemented changes and the impact on victims of APP fraud (the PSR Report).

The PSR concluded that the Reimbursement Requirement is having a positive impact, with a high proportion of APP fraud victims being reimbursed consistently across a larger number of PSPs. The PSR considers that, because both parties in the payment journey (i.e. the sending PSP and the receiving PSP) share the cost of reimbursing victims, there is a much stronger incentive for all PSPs to prevent APP fraud from occurring in the first place and that PSPs are starting to collaborate more in the effort to fight APP fraud.

The PSR Report contains data on APP fraud in the period from the introduction of the Reimbursement Requirements on 7 October 2024 to 31 December 2024. Points of note from that data include:

  • 86% of money lost to APP fraud was returned to victims, totalling around £27m, whilst reimbursement for consumers in 2023 was approximately 68% (by value);
  • 14% of total APP fraud claims were made by consumers with a vulnerability, equating to £7m;
  • 86% of claims were reported by the sending PSP to the receiving PSP within two business hours of the consumer raising the claim and 84% of claims were closed within five business days, indicating that sending and receiving PSPs are working together and sharing information to identify APP fraud and reimburse victims;
  • just 2% of total claims were rejected on the basis that the consumer failed to meet the “consumer standard of caution exception” and this exception has only been used by 23% of firms.

Despite an initial fear that reported fraud would spike with the introduction of mandatory reimbursement, this does not appear to have transpired. Around 46,000 claims were made by consumers in the period from the introduction of the Reimbursement Requirement on 7 October to 31 December.  Although a precise comparison against the prior period is not possible, according to UK Finance’s 2024 fraud report, approximately 232,000 cases of APP fraud arose in 2023, which equates to 58,000 cases across an average three-month period.

UK Finance has also reported in its 2025 fraud report that, in 2024, overall APP losses fell by 2% to just over £450 million and the number of cases fell by 20%, the lowest figures for both losses and cases since 2021. As these declines began well in advance of implementation of the Reimbursement Requirement, it is likely that collective action, particularly the ongoing major investment in fraud protections taken by the industry, has been driving this decline.

Whilst the Reimbursement Requirement is comprehensive when it comes to payments made via Faster Payments and CHAPS, the PSR Report indicates that gaps in coverage may become a target for fraudsters. For example, a notable increase in APP fraud took place between UK and international accounts, which are out of scope of the Reimbursement Requirement, with international payments accounting for 11% of APP losses in 2024, up from 6% in 2023.

On 18 November 2025 the PSR published the results of its 2025 APP fraud survey. Key findings of the APP Fraud Survey include:

  • over a third of UK adults have been targeted by APP fraud, with purchase fraud the most common type;
  • UK consumers are willing to tolerate minor payment delays to enhance transaction security;
  • reimbursement is victims’ main concern after fraud, with nearly three in five receiving at least partial repayment;
  • awareness of reimbursement rights and of the new Reimbursement Requirement in particular remains low; and
  • fraud continues to affect victims’ financial trust, confidence, and behaviour, though reimbursement helps to mitigate the impact.

Proposals for a review by the PSR

An independent review on the effectiveness of the Reimbursement Requirement has commenced with the report due to be published in Q2 2026.

Ahead of that review, the July 2025 Fair Banking Report, entitled “No Half Measures – A Blueprint to Beat APP Fraud”, noted that fraud is now the most prevalent crime against individuals in the UK and that APP fraud remains rampant and continues to evolve. It explained that AI was transforming fraud, with criminals increasingly able to tailor their approach to their target and utilise deepfake technology to engender trust, with 70% of APP fraud originating online. The Fair Banking Report expressed the view that effective cross-sector data and intelligence sharing, including with social media companies, was key to establishing a collective counter-fraud response.

In light of conversations with industry stakeholders in interviews and a series of roundtables, the Fair Banking Report sets out several themes which it says should be key focus areas for the PSR’s independent review of the Reimbursement Requirement:

  • whether the £85,000 reimbursement threshold appropriately balances consumer protection and costs to PSPs, especially given early data showing that victims in the first three months following the introduction of the Reimbursement Requirement were only reimbursed 86% of losses by value;
  • whether PSPs are investing adequately in fraud detection and prevention, and if the current incentives and standards are sufficient or require further standardisation and guidance;
  • to clarify and address ambiguities in applying consumer standards of caution and distinguishing fraud from civil disputes to ensure consistent treatment of cases by PSPs;
  • to assess the full impact of the Reimbursement Requirement and compliance costs on PSPs, particularly smaller providers, and evaluate whether these costs negatively affect competition;
  • to consider the effectiveness of current data-sharing arrangements between PSPs, and whether mandatory, statutory-level data sharing should be implemented;
  • whether the Reimbursement Requirement has increased friction between customers and PSPs, and whether consumer experience and customer awareness of the Reimbursement Requirement has impacted consumer behaviours and attitudes towards reimbursement and fraud prevention;
  • whether the Reimbursement Requirement is inadvertently pushing fraudsters to other fraud types and channels, including unauthorised fraud and international transactions, and whether further regulatory steps may be necessary.

The Fair Banking Report also expressed the view that, whilst financial institutions will have a crucial, ongoing role to play in the fight against APP fraud, viewing financial institutions as the beginning and end of fraud prevention and protection places an excessive burden on them, whilst also failing to comprehensively tackle the issue of fraud in all its complexity. It recommended that the Government’s announced update to the Fraud Strategy (which is now expected early this year) adopts a holistic ‘whole-of-ecosystem’ approach which balances responsibilities and liabilities, including a cross-sector strategy involving banks, tech platforms, regulators, and law enforcement, improved data sharing and fraud intelligence, stronger support for victims, reform of the criminal justice system, and inclusion of cryptocurrency platforms and international transfers in reimbursement schemes.

Recent litigation and key takeaways for PSPs

While the Reimbursement Requirement offers significant assistance to the victims of APP fraud, not all victims qualify, including those whose transfers were international and reimbursement is capped at £85,000.  As a result, some victims have and will continue to explore alternative legal avenues to recover their funds. Two developments in the courts in 2025 merit close attention:

  • Retrieval Duty – The High Court suggested (in response to an application to strike out a claim) that a sending PSP may owe to its customer a ‘retrieval duty’, namely a duty to act with due care and skill in its recovery efforts following a fraud. The case was subsequently discontinued, but we anticipate the High Court’s comments will encourage further attempts to establish such a duty exists.
  • Derivative Claims – A claim, which is partially under appeal, has successfully argued that a Quincecare duty was applicable in the context of an APP fraud. The claim was brought by two individual victims, as a derivative claim on behalf of an insolvent corporate victim.

Retrieval duty

In Dawn Barclay-Ross v Starling Bank Limited [2025] EWHC 2158 (KB), the High Court considered an application to strike out a claim that the sending PSP owed a retrieval duty to its customer after she became the victim of an APP fraud. The Supreme Court in Philipp v Barclays Bank UK PLC had previously discussed the possible existence of such a duty, and the judge in this case found that it was arguable that such a duty exists. The claimant, Ms Barclay-Ross, was a litigant in person and although the judge found her pleadings contained the “essential case”, they were not compliant. The claimant was therefore given permission to re-plead this element of her claim but the claim was subsequently discontinued in September 2025.

In the absence of further developed pleadings, a large number of questions as the potential nature and role of a retrieval duty remain open to speculation. The retrieval duty is attractive as there is no suggestion that such a duty might be constrained by either the quantum or jurisdiction of the payment. Victims who fall outside the scope of the Reimbursement Requirement or suffer losses in excess of £85,000 will no doubt attempt to use the High Court’s decision in this case to resist any attempt to strike out such a claim.

One practical issue for claimants is that fraudsters often dissipate funds to further accounts. In circumstances where such a retrieval duty is found to exist, and the sending PSP is found to have breached its duty, claimants will still need to show that, but for the sending PSP’s negligence, the claimant would have been able to retrieve the funds. Practically, this may be a difficult burden for the claimants to discharge, as both questions of law and fact.

There will naturally be an asymmetry of information between the PSP (who knows what steps it took to recover any funds) and a claimant, who will likely have to infer a breach of duty from the fact that the PSP has failed to recover the funds. However, the recent case of Babco Chemicals Inc v HSBC UK Bank PLC [2025] EWHC 1749 (Comm), in which the High Court allowed a potential claimant to use documents it received from a bank under a Norwich Pharmacal Order to found a claim against that same bank as the receiving party in an APP fraud, shows that claimants may be able to obtain documentary evidence through existing court processes (see High Court grants variation of Norwich Pharmacal undertakings to allow use of documents against disclosing bank | Inside Disputes).

In the event that a court determines that a retrieval duty exists, such that sending PSPs are required to take steps to retrieve a customer’s funds with due care and skill, PSPs who have established effective policies and processes regarding the recovery of such funds (e.g. seeking the victim’s instructions once the PSP is aware of the fraud), and who follow those steps and record their actions, will be better placed to resist allegations that they breached such duties.

Derivative claims

In Hamblin and another v Moorwand Ltd and another company [2025] EWHC 817 (Ch), two individual victims were tricked into paying funds to the account in the name of a company, RND which had been opened by a fraudster who had stolen the identify of one of RND’s directors. The fraudster then gave instructions to the PSP to pay those funds to a separate account (see Triggering PSPs’ Quincecare duties in APP fraud cases: The ‘derivative claim’ | Inside Disputes).

As RND had gone into insolvency, the two individual victims brought claims against the sending PSP on their own behalf and on behalf of RND (the derivative claim), for a breach of the Quincecare duty. There were a number of factors which suggested RND’s director was being impersonated, and the central question was whether the sending PSP had been “put on inquiry” under its Quincecare duty to investigate the validity of those instructions.

While the first instance judge dismissed the claim, the appeal judge found that RND had been a victim and that the sending PSP had been put on inquiry. The sending PSP was subsequently ordered to restore the monies to RND’s account, for RND’s use.

The question of whether the individual victims had standing to bring the derivative claim was not addressed. Permission to appeal was granted in November 2025. It will be interesting to see if a superior court takes a similar approach.

The unusual fact pattern of this APP fraud means that, whatever the result of an appeal, it is likely to be of limited application to most APP fraud claims. The fact that the sums are necessarily repaid to the corporate victim, rather than the individual, means that any individual claimant risks being an unsecured creditor of an insolvent company even where they successfully achieve reimbursement by the sending PSP of its corporate customer. This further complication is another reason this approach may prove of less interest to claimants than the potential existence of a retrieval duty.

Conclusion

There is no certainty that claims based on a retrieval duty or derivative claims will be successful, but the growth of APP fraud and limits to the Reimbursement Requirement mean that we expect this area of law to continue developing over the next few years.

For now, sending PSPs should continue taking steps to protect against future claims, by developing, maintaining and implementing processes for retrieving funds, particularly to show that steps were taken promptly after becoming aware of any misappropriated funds.

Contact