On November 21, 2025, Richard Smith J in the High Court handed down his judgment in 3i plc v Decesare and upheld the validity of a pension scheme closure deed terminating future benefit accrual.

The trustees of the 3i Pension Plan (the Plan) had become concerned following the Court of Appeal’s decision in 2024 in BBC v BBC Pension Trust Ltd, (the BBC case) which held that a restriction (or fetter) on the BBC scheme’s power of amendment covered future service rights as well as those already accrued.

The Plan was in the process of winding-up and, following the assignment of individual annuities to members, the trustees proposed to pay the surplus to the employer. If the BBC decision was applied in the same way to the fetter in the Plan’s amendment rule, the earlier closure of the Plan to future accrual would potentially be invalid, the Plan’s liabilities would increase as a result and the surplus payable to the employer would accordingly be reduced (or eliminated).

The payment of surplus was put on hold and the Court was asked to determine whether the fetter in the Plan’s rules protected members’ future service rights as well as those already accrued at the time of closure.

The fetter on the power of amendment

The fetter in the BBC case

The Court of Appeal’s judgment upheld the earlier High Court decision in the BBC case and focused on the meaning of the word “interests” in the context of the pension scheme’s amendment power.

The fetter in the BBC scheme’s rules provided that no modification or alteration could take effect “as regards the Active Members whose interests are certified by the Actuary to be affected” unless certain protective conditions were met.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the High Court that in the context of the BBC scheme’s rules, “interests” here should be construed widely. It was “…an open-textured word…not tied to ‘rights’…still less to rights that had been ‘accrued’ or ‘secured’...” and it was therefore held to include the ability of members to accrue future service benefits under the scheme.

However, the Court of Appeal made clear that the meaning of words used in scheme rules in general and in the fetter on the amendment in particular in this case, was context dependent.

The fetter in the 3i case

In the 3i case, the trustees’ concern was that the fetter in the Plan’s amendment power also included the word “interests”.

At the time of closure to future accrual, the fetter provided that no amendment could be made to the Plan’s rules if it would “diminish any pension already being paid under the Plan or the accrued rights or interests of any Member or any other person in respect of benefits already provided under the Plan”.

If “interests” here also included future service benefits, the validity of the deed purporting to close the Plan to future accrual could be called into question. Before taking a final decision on the distribution of the Plan’s surplus, the Court was asked to confirm the meaning of the fetter.

Looking at the principles of construction

The Court considered the principle identified by Bright J in a 2023 commercial contract case, Cantor Fitzgerald & Co v YES Bank Ltd:

  • While there is no firm grammatical rule that an adjective or determiner at the start of a list of nouns qualifies them all, the nature of the list may well indicate that it does.
  • Unless something in the drafting of the list suggests otherwise, the reader will naturally assume that an adjective or determinant at the start of the list qualifies the entirety of it.

Thus, under conventional grammatical construction, the phrase “accrued rights or interests” in the Plan’s fetter meant both rights and interests were covered by the adjective “accrued”.  The Court was asked to decide whether “interests” was (as in the BBC case) broad enough to include future service benefits, or whether it was limited to past service benefits.

The Court of Appeal in the BBC case had, as stated above, been clear that the meaning of a particular clause turns on its specific wording, interpreted in context.

In the BBC scheme’s fetter, the word “interests” was “untethered to any composite phrase”. In contrast, Smith J held that in the Plan’s fetter, “…far from being untethered, the word ‘interests’…does feature in a composite phrase. It also features in conjunction with the word ‘rights’. Both words are then qualified by the same expression ‘already provided under the Plan’, echoing the ‘already being paid’ element of the first part. There is nothing in that composite phrase to suggest that the relevant ‘interests’ are concerned with future service accrual. To the contrary, and reinforced by the word ‘accrued’ before ‘rights or interests’, its focus is very much on what has already occurred.”

The Court concluded that the wording in the Plan was very different to the wording in the BBC scheme fetter. The Plan’s fetter was concerned with preventing amendments that would diminish past service benefits.

Commentary and practical considerations

It will provide comfort to other trustees that Smith J was unhesitating in his conclusion that closure to accrual was permitted under the Plan’s “unambiguous” amendment power. The decision is a welcome one for other schemes with references to members’ “interests” in their amendment powers, as it clarifies how such provisions should be read and construed.

The Court of Appeal’s decision in the BBC case (which some practitioners may question given the lack of explicit text stating that “interests” protected future service rights, casting doubt on whether that could have been in the parties’ intention) may have caused some concern among trustees over whether previous amendments to schemes with a fetter mentioning “interests” could be invalid. However, the context in which the words are used is fundamental and fetters in amendment powers should be read and considered carefully. A fetter which includes the word “interests” will not necessarily be construed as including the ability to accrue future benefits.

Rather than looking at the historical administration of the scheme and the commercial context, the Court will attach significant importance to the words actually used in the scheme rules. It is essential that the whole provision in the relevant rule should be read in context and particular words are not considered in isolation.

Contact