What happened

Mrs K received a correct early retirement quotation in May 2020, followed by several automated, much higher, estimates which were incorrect. Mrs K queried the incorrect estimates repeatedly but received further incorrect estimates. She retired based on these incorrect estimates and later received the correct, lower benefits.

The Ombudsman found maladministration by the administrator due to the system errors and awarded £1,000 to the member for distress. However, the Ombudsman found there was no negligent misstatement because:

  • The incorrect figures were estimates, not quotations, and were not reasonably intended to be relied upon. Only a formal retirement quotation is intended to be relied upon.
  • The estimates contained clear warnings that the figures were illustrative and not guaranteed to be paid.

Practical takeaways

This determination makes clear administrators remain responsible for the accuracy of outputs produced by automated systems. It also highlights the importance of retirement estimates including clear warnings that they are illustrations only and that the figures shown are not guaranteed to be paid.

As we become more conscious of how AI features are being incorporated into administration processes, it is prudent to assume they will be subject to the same standards of accuracy and oversight as automated systems.

Contact