Welcome to the March edition of Tax insights, keeping you up to date with the latest developments, key takeaways from recent cases and tax trends.
In this edition, we highlight a number of updates selected for their potential impact on our clients’ businesses, including developments relating to the taxation of carried interest, advance clearances for significant UK investments, points to consider for those contemplating property reorganisations, and the taxation of offshore and onshore natural resource activities.
Carried interest in motion: recent developments in the UK and Luxembourg
The taxation of carried interest remains an evolving area of tax policy, with the UK introducing significant reforms that fundamentally reshape how such fund manager incentives are taxed; carry receipts are now within the scope of UK income, rather than capital gains tax. Recent focus on carried interest has extended beyond the UK market, particularly for global fund groups operating through multi-jurisdictional management structures. In the wider European context, Luxembourg has codified a new carried interest regime, reshaping its domestic approach to performance-based remuneration for fund managers. Together, these changes signal a renewed focus on aligning tax outcomes with policy objectives across two of Europe’s most important asset management hubs.
United Kingdom
With effect from 6 April 2026, the UK’s new carried interest regime comes into force, representing a significant change in how carried interest holders are taxed. Under the revised framework, which applies to all carried‑interest returns – not only amounts previously treated as capital gains but also ongoing profit allocations and distributions, carried interest will fall fully within the income tax regime, treated as trading profits rather than capital gains, reflecting the UK’s policy shift towards taxing carried interest in line with its characterisation as remuneration for investment management services rather than as a return on capital.
A central feature of the new rules is the introduction of a 34.1% effective tax rate for qualifying carried interest, achieved by applying a 72.5% multiplier to the taxable portion of profits. Qualification depends on a fund’s average holding period, determined under enhanced rules adapted from the existing Income-Based Carried Interest (IBCI) framework. These rules introduce additional complexity, requiring detailed tracking of holding periods across investment strategies such as real estate, credit, and fund-of-funds. Where carried interest does not meet the qualifying conditions, it may be subject to income tax and Class 4 NICs at rates of up to 47%, representing a materially higher tax burden for shorter‑term or non‑qualifying awards.
In addition, non‑UK tax resident carry recipients will need to keep track of their “UK workdays” - days involving more than three hours of investment management activity performed in the UK. If they spend 60 or more “workdays” in the UK, they may become liable to UK income tax on the carried interest received. This may prompt certain US‑based carry holders who fall within scope of UK income tax to structure their carried interest so that HMRC taxes them earlier (for example, by granting a valuable interest) and ensuring that the US recognises the income in the same year, such as through the use of an 83(b) election in order to support US foreign tax credit relief. As a result, close monitoring of international travel and working patterns is advisable.
The regime also includes a number of elections that can be made, including an irrevocable annual election allowing individuals to apply ordinary trading principles where appropriate. In such cases, the 72.5% multiplier does not apply, and standard trading reliefs - such as expense deductions and loss relief - are available, which may improve the after‑tax position in some circumstances.
All carried interest payments received on or after 6 April 2026, regardless of when awarded, will be taxed under the new UK rules. This may require a review of existing fund structures, waterfall mechanics, and carry vehicles to ensure anticipated tax outcomes are as expected under the revised framework, as well as implementing procedures to track UK workdays for non-UK tax residents.
Luxembourg
With effect from 1 January 2026, Luxembourg has fundamentally reshaped its carried interest tax regime. The reform replaces a narrow and increasingly uncertain framework with a more predictable regime that better reflects how carried interest is structured in practice across alternative asset managers.
The new rules rely on a broader definition of carried interest, focusing on performance-based remuneration linked to the outperformance of an alternative investment fund (AIF) above a genuine, market-standard hurdle rate, rather than on formalistic or employment-based criteria. This matters in practice. Under the previous regime, eligibility was largely limited to employees of the AIF manager or management company, leaving uncertainty for other carry holders. From 2026, any Luxembourg-resident individual directly or indirectly involved in the management of an AIF may qualify, irrespective of the contractual or corporate channel through which the carry is granted.
Importantly, the reform removes the requirement that investors fully recover their invested capital before carried interest can accrue. As a result, the new tax treatment also applies to deal-by-deal waterfall structures, which are common in US-style private equity funds. The rules apply irrespective of whether the AIF or carry structure takes the form of a tax-opaque entity or a tax-transparent partnership.
The reform further draws a clear distinction between contractual carry and participation-based carry. Contractual profit-sharing rights are taxed as extraordinary income at one quarter of the progressive income tax rate, resulting in a rate of up to 11.45%. Where carried interest is structured through a genuine equity or fund participation, the resulting income may instead fall within the capital gains regime, including a full exemption after a six-month holding period where the interest does not represent a substantial participation, i.e., more than 10%.
The reforms introduced in the UK and Luxembourg mark a notable move toward more consistent and transparent taxation of performance‑based remuneration. As both regimes take effect from 2026, fund groups should assess the impact on their existing carried interest structures, cross‑border arrangements, and operational processes to ensure they remain aligned with the updated rules.
A new era of advance clearances on major UK investments?
HMRC will open a new advance tax certainty service from July 2026, offering upfront clearances to taxpayers with the aim of encouraging major financial investments into the UK. For background, please see our article which provides a summary of the proposed service following its announcement at the Budget 2025. Since the Budget 2025, the Finance Bill 2025-26 has been published which provides the legislative basis for the service, and HMRC have released draft guidance providing a more granular breakdown of the clearance process.
By way of reminder, both UK and overseas investors will be able to apply for a clearance, with a single nominated entity able to apply in the case of shared ownership structures (e.g. joint ventures or consortiums). The service will be available only to new projects, and even then, only to the largest UK investments – projects with UK expenditure of £1 billion or on tangible and intangible assets, and/or services used in the UK or the UK continental shelf, excluding equity and financing costs. Clearances issued in respect of qualifying projects will cover corporation and income taxes, VAT, stamp duty land tax, PAYE and the Construction Industry Scheme. These clearances will set out HMRC’s view on the application of those taxes to the relevant project, and are binding for five years, extendable by further five-year periods where HMRC considers it appropriate and the legislative and case law landscape has not changed. In short, the aim of the new service is to provide investors into the UK with comfort as to the ongoing UK tax position of investments ahead of capital being deployed.******
Where might the value of clearances lie?
While, of course, the ‘value’ of a clearance to a taxpayer will depend on the areas of tax uncertainty that are relevant to the circumstances of a particular investment, there are two areas of uncertainty that are typically particular concerns for investors on large UK infrastructure projects:
- Capital allowances – the availability of capital allowances is typically critical to the financial modelling of long-term infrastructure or energy projects. At the time of publishing, we are awaiting the decision of the Supreme Court in Orsted West of Duddon Sands (UK) Limited and others (Respondents) v Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs UKSC/2025/0069 (Gunfleet Sands), being just one in a line of recent cases in which HMRC have challenged the availability of allowances.
- VAT – as such projects typically involve significant expenditure on goods and/or services, particularly engineering and procurement, as well as supplies of land. Consequently, complex VAT recovery analyses are often required in support of the assumptions in the financial modelling.
The binding effect
The introduction of the advance tax certainty service represents a marked shift in approach by HMRC in the provision of assurances outside of specific existing clearance procedures. Unlike other forms of engagement currently available, such as informal clearance discussions or non‑statutory correspondence, the advance tax certainty service will produce binding rulings that HMRC must in theory follow.
However, the binding nature of the clearances is not without its limitations. Clearances will only remain binding where both the underlying facts and the law remain unchanged – including case law developments that alter HMRC’s view of the law. This qualification is particularly relevant in areas such as capital allowances, where ongoing litigation, such as the awaited Supreme Court decision in Gunfleet Sands, may yet confirm that the law, and HMRC’s view of it, do not necessarily align. Equally, the requirement that the factual position remains the same raises questions for areas like VAT recovery, where entitlement often turns on the evolving patterns of expenditure, supplies and their actual use. Large-scale infrastructure projects are typically developed over long construction periods, during which commercial arrangements, supply and financing structures are likely to fluctuate.
The Government is hoping that the advance tax certainty service will help unlock investments for major projects by delivering a stable and transparent environment which reduces tax uncertainty. Yet the extent to which the regime will provide concrete certainty on issues of genuine tax uncertainty, given the qualifications to the binding nature of clearances, remains to be seen.
Court of Appeal offers further guidance on the scope of the SDLT section 75A provisions for property holding reorganisations
In an important decision for those reviewing their property‑holding structures, the Court of Appeal has found that the SDLT anti‑avoidance provision in section 75A FA 2003 applied in the context of a group re-organisation. It involved the grant of a lease, a share transfer, followed by a transfer of the lease, with group relief from SDLT being claimed in relation to each transaction. The transactions were undertaken following advice from tax advisers and were designed to secure a corporation tax advantage, which did not in fact arise.
No enquiry was made in relation to the claim for group relief on the initial grant of the lease on the basis that this would benefit from sub-sale relief, but group relief was denied in relation to the subsequent transfer of the lease on the basis that while the arrangements were for bona fide commercial purposes, the arrangements formed part of tax‑motivated planning. HMRC assessed SDLT by reference to the market value of the transfer, on the basis that the parties were connected and the deemed market value rule was not disengaged.
By the time this reached the Court of Appeal, the taxpayer had conceded that group relief was not available on the transfer but argued that an exception to the deemed market value applied, so that SDLT was only charged on the actual consideration given.
The Court adopted a purposive approach to this question, looking at the intended purpose of the provisions and finding that the deemed market value rule was disengaged as there had not been a valid claim for group relief made in the last three years; the exception could only be disapplied where the taxpayer had actually benefitted from group relief, not where it had merely made an application for group relief.
The Court however then considered section 75A, which had not previously been considered by the tax tribunals. Section 75A applies on a transfer of property from the vendor to the purchaser where a number of transactions are involved in connection with the disposal and acquisition (the scheme transactions) and the sum of the amounts of SDLT payable in respect of the scheme transactions is less than the amount that would be payable on a notional land transaction. The particular point of issue before the Court was which transactions fell within the definition of ‘scheme transaction’. The taxpayer sought to argue that the share purchase fell outside the relevant series of transactions for the purposes of section 75A or, alternatively, that it was merely an incidental step to the property transfer. The Court rejected this approach and emphasised that section 75A requires taking a holistic view of the series of transactions in question. Although the share sale was not legally required to effect the transfer of property, in reality the property transfer was conditional upon the share sale having first occurred and thus formed part of the series of transactions by which the property was transferred.
Therefore, the Court agreed with HMRC that the consideration given for the grant of the lease, the share purchase and the transfer of the lease should all be aggregated when determining the consideration for the ‘notional’ section 75A transaction. As this combined amount exceeded the SDLT paid on the individual transactions, the anti‑avoidance rules were triggered. SDLT was therefore recalculated by reference to the notional transaction, and the taxpayer’s appeal was dismissed.
Looking ahead, this decision may have implications for groups planning de‑enveloping or other property reorganisations. The Court’s approach means that multi-stage transactions, particularly those involving several land transfers and share sales, could fall within the scope of section 75A irrespective of the intended commercial outcome. It raises the importance of considering questions such as which transactions are connected with the land transfer, and the consequent value at which SDLT will be assessed.
OECD issues new model provision for taxing offshore and onshore natural resource activities
Exploration and exploitation of natural resources are frequently cross-border endeavours. In terms of allocating the taxing rights, this gives rise to a tension between the state of residence of the entity conducting the exploration or extraction and the state where the activity takes place. This tension is frequently resolved by the presence of a double taxation convention between the two countries. However, there has been a growing sense that existing model double tax provisions do not allow the state in which the natural resources are located to exert as many taxing rights as it may wish, given the one-off nature of a mineral extraction transaction. This is particularly the case in relation to operations carried out in the territory that are more transient, such as offshore exploration activities.
On 19 November 2025, the OECD released an update to the Model Tax Convention, including changes aimed at giving source states additional rights to tax natural resources activity in its jurisdiction. These changes include a new optional provision which could be adopted by contracting states and which is aimed at strengthening how countries tax income from natural resource extraction in their territory. This responds to concerns that traditional permanent establishment (PE) rules do not adequately capture modern offshore and mobile extractive activities. It is not intended to apply to renewables, instead being focussed on extractive activities with a view to creating a stronger balance between the source jurisdiction (where the resources are located) and the residence jurisdiction (where the operator is based), shifting the balance towards the source jurisdiction. This new provision offers a lower threshold for establishing a PE, deeming activities to be carried on through a PE where a non-resident carries out “relevant activities” in a contracting State for longer than an agreed (aggregated) period in a in any twelve-month period. The provision may be incorporated in double tax treaties through bilateral agreement and provides a basis for a more consistent approach.
A New Framework for “Relevant Activities”
The new provision is designed to operate alongside existing PE and immovable property rules. States may choose to implement the provision in an offshore‑only form or to implement a broader offshore‑and‑onshore scope.
While onshore mining extraction operations often meet existing PE thresholds as they will have a fixed place of business and a degree of permanence, highly mobile services may not. The new provision works by reference to “relevant activities” to provide clarity here. Bringing specialised, short‑term services into scope should enable a closer alignment of taxing rights with underlying economic activity.
The updated Commentary provides helpful examples distinguishing specialised services—such as engineering, seismic surveys or installation of mining infrastructure—from generic services like catering, internet facilities or utilities, which fall outside the scope. It also clarifies the treatment of vessels used in offshore support, an area that can give rise to difficulties, providing a specific exclusion for certain activities and giving detailed guidance on the type of activities this does and does not apply to. This can be an area of uncertainty under existing double tax treaty provisions. This detailed guidance is a helpful addition when considering treaty provisions already in place.
The duration-based threshold
“Relevant activities” are deemed to give rise to a PE if carried on for period(s) which, in aggregate, exceed a specified bilaterally agreed period within a 12‑month span. Current treaty practice where this kind of threshold is included includes a range of different timescales including 30, 90, and 183 days; the new approach may drive greater consistency. Optional anti‑contract‑splitting language is included for States seeking to prevent avoidance by fragmentation of activities.
Gains and Employment Income
Paragraph 4 consolidates rules on taxing gains from disposals of assets such as immovable property (including exploration or exploitation rights), some movable property, shares and other comparable interest. It gives priority to the source State where, broadly, those assets relate to or are used in connection with the exploration or exploitation of relevant natural resources, including where shares are sold that principally derive their value from activities in the source state. This could prove difficult to manage in practice, particularly if a state implements this provision as well as a deemed disposal rule when an asset leaves the jurisdiction. This could mean offshore drilling assets are taxed in the state of operation on income derived from the drilling activity as well as any gain in the value of the drilling asset itself during its time in the jurisdiction.
Implications for Multinational Enterprises
The OECD acknowledge the wide variety of existing provisions across the treaty network. The new model clause may serve both to harmonise future treaties and prompt renegotiation of existing ones. Many European treaties already apply a 30‑day offshore PE rule, which may influence global practice. For MNEs, the changes mark a shift toward more coherent and assertive source‑taxation standards although given the pace at which bilateral treaty negotiations take place it may be some time before the new provision becomes standard.
Conclusion
The OECD’s new provision modernises the international tax framework for extractive industries through clearer definitions, improved guidance and a more adaptable mechanism for taxing offshore and onshore activities. In practical terms, it is most likely to affect those operating in the offshore sector, and in particular providers of service activities, such as drilling and other specialist offshore services, rather than businesses directly engaged in the extraction of oil, gas or minerals. The updated Commentary also provides helpful clarity for other affected sectors, including shipping, by more clearly delineating which activities will fall within scope and which will not. As States begin incorporating these changes into their treaty networks, businesses should monitor developments closely and assess their operational and tax implications. For a deeper dive into the new provision, see this article prepared by our Dutch colleagues.