Article 2 – SAFEs and ASAs

Introduction

In the four articles of this venture capital series, we discuss some of the most commonly used equity and equity-like instruments used by emerging companies in the UK, the US and Canada. Last week we discussed priced equity rounds.1

In the coming weeks we will discuss:

  • Convertible debt and warrants
  • Token issuances and warrants

Up this week: SAFEs and ASAs

SAFEs and ASAs

SAFEs and ASAs are all variations of the same theme: in essence, they are a pre-paid right to acquire shares at a future date subject to certain conditions precedent.

As we noted in our previous article on priced equity, like any financial decision, SAFEs and ASAs are both straightforward and challenging at the same time.

  • Straightforward: Generally, one agreement, market standard terms, valuation is determined at a later date.
  • Challenging: Ensuring that different investors who invest at different times have the same terms and keeping strict control of the cap table and the impact of future funding rounds.

SAFE: SAFEs (simple agreement for future equity) were originally created by US start up accelerator Y Combinator in 2013 and allow an investor to pre-pay for shares in return for shares issued at a discount or capped valuation at a later date.

  • Advantages: Since their release, the post-money Y Combinator form of SAFE has become the US market standard and is used extensively in North America, terms well-understood, few terms to negotiate, can avoid valuation discussions (although see below)
  • Considerations: Tax and securities law requirements are different from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, so the form on the internet should not be used without legal and financial review

ASA: ASAs (advance subscription agreement) similar to a SAFE, but used in the UK.

Unique to the United Kingdom: preferred equity can have the benefit of including Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) and Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) tax relief for investors, but conditions will apply and tax advice should be sought.

Considerations

Both SAFEs and ASAs are typically very quick to negotiate and finalize. As noted above, both instruments enable investors to “pre-pay” for shares that are issued and allotted by the company at a future date. Typical considerations include:

  • Size of the raise: Flexible, with some caveats

    • Advantages: Flexible
    • Considerations: Founders have to keep strict control of the cap table and model various valuation scenarios to predict ownership after the next priced equity round.
  • Valuation: While the company receives the funds on day one, the issuance of shares is deferred to the next specified liquidity event (usually a qualifying funding round in which a certain amount is raised and equity shares are issued), a specified termination or longstop date, or an insolvency event.

    • Advantages: may postpone a valuation discussion
    • Considerations: many SAFEs and ASAs contain a “valuation cap” which means that the price of the shares into which the SAFE or ASA may convert will be the lower of a discounted price per share (usually a 10%-20% discount) and the price per share on a valuation cap.
    • Founders should be wary to ensure that they understand the scenarios in which the SAFE / ASA will convert and the number of shares that they will convert into, so as not to be caught with a larger dilution than expected on the next fundraise.
  • Control: SAFE and ASA holders are not shareholders of the company, so will not have any rights as shareholders

    • Advantages: no lengthy investor documents
    • Considerations: investors may request a side letter which contains some typical shareholder rights, including director appointment rights, specific approval rights, information rights, or any regulatory rights and the company may be required to undertake that such rights will be included in any shareholders agreement and amended articles adopted at the conversion event.
  • Ranking: The investor will usually receive the most senior class of share in issue on the conversion date with pro rata rights in respect of such shares.

  • Conversion to equity:

    • Automatic conversion to equity will usually happen on a trigger event such as an exit (for example, IPO), a qualifying funding round, change of control or M&A transaction.
    • There is usually an optional conversion where a certain majority threshold of SAFE holders can decide to convert at a particular time or on the occurrence of a particular event (such as a change of control).
  • Cautionary note: The treatment of SAFEs and ASAs from a tax and bankruptcy perspective can vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

  • Unique to the United Kingdom: ASAs designed for UK companies can have the benefit of including Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) and Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) tax relief, if the conversion longstop date is less than six months.

    • The treatment of ASAs for tax and accounting purposes is still uncertain in the UK and so professional advice should be sought.

Quick Summary

Below is a table comparing the key features of a priced equity round, ASA and SAFE.

Funding structure Time consuming / long form documents Valuation of company or price per share decided at a later date? Repayable? Maturity date?
Priced equity round Yes No No No
ASA No Yes No No
SAFE No Yes No No

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Venture Capital Series: Early stage funding structures Article 1 - Priced equity | Global law firm …

Contact