The Court of Appeal has issued its judgment on the meaning of the word “building" for the purposes of tenants’ first rights of refusal under Part 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 (LTA 1987) and in doing so, has established a new test, overturning the long-standing decision in Long Acre Securities Ltd v Karet [2005] Ch 61 (Karet). The decision provides clarity on how landlords should serve Section 5 offer notices under the LTA 1987 when disposing of developments comprising multiple buildings.
Background
The law
Part 1 of the LTA 1987 grants certain residential tenants the right of first refusal when a landlord proposes to make a disposal affecting the whole or part of the premises in which the tenants’ flats are situated. A landlord wishing to make a relevant disposal is required to serve notice on the qualifying tenants under Section 5 of the LTA 1987. Section 5(3) provides that where a landlord disposes of an interest in more than one building (whether or not involving the same estate or interest), it must sever the transaction so as to deal with each building separately. If a landlord makes a relevant disposal without complying with Section 5, the tenants can serve a notice under Section 12B of the LTA 1987 requiring the third-party buyer to dispose of the premises to the tenants on the same terms.
The facts
Fox Street Village is a residential development in Liverpool comprising five blocks of accommodation (blocks A through E). Block A is a refurbished warehouse building converted into flats with its own utility services and stands separately from the other Blocks. Blocks C and E are adjoining new-build structures which share a single entrance, staircase, and plant room, while Block B is a separate new-build structure that relies on the plant room in Block C for its heating and other services. Blocks B, C and E all share a car park and access points. The redevelopment of Block A took place before the other Blocks were built. Blocks B, C, and E were built as Phase 2 of the development. Block D has largely been demolished following a fire in 2024 and was not in issue in the claim.
The landlord of Fox Street Village, FSV Ltd (FSV), entered into administration. Its administrators sought to dispose of the landlord’s freehold interest in the blocks of flats and therefore negotiated with SGL 1 Limited (SGL1) for the sale of the whole development. Before the transfer, the administrators of FSV Ltd served two Section 5 offer notices on the qualifying tenants in the blocks of flats. One notice was served in respect of Block A and another in respect of Blocks B, C, and E. No notice was served in respect of Block D. The tenants of the Blocks did not accept either offer, and the administrators of FSV Ltd subsequently sold the Blocks to SGL1.
Following the sale, the qualifying tenants appointed FSV Freeholders Limited (Freeholders) as their nominee for the purpose of acquiring the freehold interest in Blocks A, B, C and E. Freeholders served notices on SGL1 under Section 11A of the LTA 1987 seeking information about the terms of the disposal, and then under Section 12B claiming the right to purchase Blocks A, B, C, and E.
The issue
The central question on appeal was the meaning of "building" for the purposes of Part 1 of the LTA 1987 and, in particular, Section 5(3), which provides that where a landlord proposes to dispose of an estate or interest in "more than one building," the transaction must be severed "so as to deal with each building separately." The LTA 1987 contains no statutory definition of "building”.
The District Court decision
At first instance, Judge Hodge KC had followed the reasoning in Karet, in which a deputy High Court judge held that "building" could be construed to mean "either a single building or one or more buildings, where the occupants of the qualifying flats in each of those buildings share the use of the same appurtenant premises" (namely, shared amenities). The judge reasoned that Parliament could not have intended that integrated developments with shared amenities should have to be split into inappropriate and unwieldy parts in order to satisfy the requirements of Section 5(3) and held that the appropriate Section 5 notice for such integrated developments was a single notice in relation to the whole of the residential part of the estate.
The High Court decision
On appeal, the High Court expressed concern with the correctness of the decision in Karet but ultimately decided to apply the judge’s reasoning as neither party had advanced an argument that sought to challenge the authority of the case. When considering whether more than one structure constitutes a single “building” for the purposes of the tenants' right of first refusal under the LTA 1987, it must be necessary to pay attention to a variety of factors “which may exert a magnetic attraction in favour of a certain conclusion”. The "magnetic factor" in the High Court’s assessment was the shared access road which is the only means of access to the car parking spaces demised to certain leaseholders of Block A. Consequently, it was held that the four Blocks constituted a single "building” and that the two Section 5 notices served by the administrators of FSV Ltd were invalid.
The Court of Appeal's decision
The Court of Appeal accepted that there is nothing in the LTA 1987 to support the argument that the word "building" can be interpreted to include a "building scheme" – that is, a single development of one or more buildings constructed at the same time. However, the Court of Appeal rejected the proposition that separate structures could be treated as one "building" merely because their occupants share the use of certain amenities.
Lady Justice Asplin reasoned that the judge in Karet had approached the issue through the lens of a Section 12 purchase notice (where the initiative lies with the tenants to purchase the land being sold by the landlord), rather than a Section 5 offer notice (where the initiative lies with the landlord in determining what parts of a building or development to sell). When the initiative lies with the landlord, it is for the landlord to determine what to sell and how to parcel the estate. The landlord may choose to include some or all shared amenity land in a notice relating to one building and some or none in a notice relating to another, or otherwise to split the amenity land. Section 5(3) does not prescribe how a transaction must be severed, apart from the requirement that the landlord must deal with each building separately.
Application to the facts
The Court of Appeal held that the High Court had adopted the wrong test. The central question should be whether structures are within a "functionally integrated built envelope." Applying this test should avoid the uncertainty and lengthy consideration of a large number of factors to determine the status of the structure.
Applying the "functionally integrated built envelope" test, the Court of Appeal reached the following conclusions.
- Block A was held to be a separate building. It was a converted warehouse with its own services and utilities. It was not part of a functionally integrated built envelope with Blocks B, C, and E. Accordingly, the Section 5 notice served in relation to Block A was valid.
- Blocks C and E were held to constitute a single building. They were built together to a very similar design using similar materials, shared a single plant room, and had a single entrance and stairwell. It was impossible to access Block C without passing through Block E. They were structures within a functionally integrated built envelope.
- Block B was also held to form part of the same building as Blocks C and E. Block B had no plant room and was reliant on the shared plant room in Block C. To enable Block B to function independently would require the installation of a new plant room in or under the Block, a result the court held Parliament could not have intended when requiring a transaction to be severed so as to deal with each building separately.
As a result, the Section 5 notice served in respect of Blocks B, C, and E was also held to be valid, and the appeal was allowed.
Agreeing that the appeal should be allowed, Lord Justice Lewison called on the Secretary of State to give serious consideration to make regulations modifying the provisions of Section 5(3), noting that there is no satisfactory interpretation of Section 5(3) as it stands which avoids inconvenient results.
Practical implications
This decision marks a significant shift in the interpretation of "building" under Part 1 of the LTA 1987, and ultimately brings a degree of clarity and (depending on the structural and functional characteristics of buildings within a development) potentially more flexibility for landlords.
Rather than relying on the previous focus on shared amenities and management arrangements, landlords can assess buildings on the basis of structural and functional characteristics. However, there might still be considerable uncertainty over whether multiple structures form a functionally integrated built envelope, and landlords should still seek specialist advice when structuring disposals of multi-block residential and mixed developments to ensure that Section 5 notices are validly served, particularly in light of criminal penalties for non-compliance.
Investors looking to acquire residential or mixed use developments will need to consider any section 5 notices already served in order to assess whether there is any risk for residential tenants to claim invalidity given the new test.
Finally, landlords and tenants alike should monitor any future legislative developments in this area, particularly in light of Lord Justice Lewison’s call for legislative intervention, and the proposed review of the rights of first refusal provisions of the LTA 1987 contained in the Law Commission’s 14th Programme of Reform.