The Kalinga case serves as an important reminder that the application of the Construction Industry Scheme (“CIS”) should be considered at an early stage and that property investors can be regarded as “mainstream contractors” where the works undertaken are material.

In this case, Kalinga Holdings Ltd (“Kalinga”) considered that it was a property investor, and therefore only required to register as a contractor when its spend on construction works exceeded £3 million in any 12-month rolling period. In fact, the works were so material that it was found to be a “mainstream contractor” and required to register as a contractor from the start of the works. Kalinga sought to rely on “Reg 9”, which allows HMRC to direct that Kalinga was not obliged to withhold tax. However, this requires the taxpayer to have taken “reasonable care” when determining whether works fall within the scope of the CIS. The tribunal found that reliance on HMRC guidance alone may not be sufficient to show that a party has taken reasonable care to comply with the CIS, and that professional advice should be sought when substantial payments are made.

Who is a contractor?

There are two categories of contractor: mainstream contractors (who are in the business of construction) and deemed contractors (businesses that spend more than £3 million in any rolling 12-month period on construction operations). As such, property investors may fall within the scope of CIS by virtue of their expenditure on construction operations in a given year.

The key takeaway is that whilst property investors may be deemed contractors, in some cases where the works are material, they could alternatively be regarded as a mainstream contractor.

The decision

The taxpayer, Kalinga, made payments to sub-contractors of £1.45 million, and did not make any CIS deductions as they fell below the deemed contractor threshold and did not consider themselves a mainstream contractor as they were not a property developer. HMRC found that there were under-deductions amounting to c £380,000. Kalinga sought to apply Regulation 9 of The Income Tax (Construction Industry Scheme) Regulations 2005 to discharge its duty to make CIS deductions.

Regulation 9 provides that where either Condition A or Condition B is met, HMRC “may” direct that a contractor is not liable to make up the shortfall of the amounts that it should have deducted under CIS. In this case, Condition A applies if a contractor:

  1. took reasonable care to comply with the CIS; and
  2. the failure to deduct was due to an error made in good faith, or the contractor held a genuine belief that the CIS did not apply to the payment.

HMRC accepted that Kalinga had genuinely believed that CIS did not apply, and as such the question was whether they had taken reasonable care to comply with the scheme.

Kalinga had asked its accountant for advice and checked the HMRC guidance themselves. The accountant noted that property investors may not be mainstream contractors and advised Kalinga to consult the HMRC guidance, noting that the accountant was not an expert in CIS. Whilst Kalinga had reviewed the guidance, they failed to review the additional guidance which addresses the distinction between a property developer and a property investor. The tribunal found that it was not reasonable for Kalinga to have relied solely on the guidance and that it would have been reasonable to expect Kalinga to seek further professional advice to clarify the situation given the materiality of the works.

Kalinga was found not to have taken reasonable care, and as such, Regulation 9 did not apply. Kalinga should therefore have withheld.

Practical implications

This case serves as a useful reminder that special care must be taken to establish whether payments made under construction contracts could fall within the CIS regime. This is especially important when property investment businesses, who may not expect to fall within the scope of CIS, engage in large projects to construct, convert or renovate properties as this may result in their falling into the category of a mainstream contractor.

The judgment also helps clarify what level of care is required when making into investigations into whether deductions should be made. Businesses should take professional advice where large amounts are at stake – with the advice required being proportionate to the potential works. Any decisions taken should be recorded, and advice taken early on before works begin.

Contact