The Pensions Ombudsman confirms that where a discretion exists, trustees and administrators must actively consider whether to exercise it, rather than relying on standard policies, and should record their decision.

This decision from the Pensions Ombudsman underlines the importance of properly identifying and exercising discretions in scheme rules / regulations.

The complaint arose where a member sought a reassessment of her ill health benefits outside a three-year time limit. The member’s request was refused because it was out of time. However, there was a power that afforded the decision maker a discretion to extend the time limits.

The decision maker confirmed to the Ombudsman that it had not considered whether to exercise the discretion in this member’s case. The Ombudsman found that this was wrong and directed the decision maker to reconsider whether to exercise this discretion.

****The decision is a helpful reminder that, where a discretion exists, trustees and administrators must actively consider whether to exercise it in the particular case. It is not enough to rely on a general policy setting out how a discretion will usually be applied. While having such a policy is acceptable, it cannot replace the need to look at the individual facts or rule out making an exception. It is also important to keep a clear record showing that the discretion was identified, that the relevant circumstances were taken into account, and that a reasoned decision was reached on whether or not to exercise it.

Contact