The First-tier Tribunal’s (FTT) decision in Chester Lettings Limited v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 614 (TC) provides a useful discussion of the relevant principles to be applied in determining the tax treatment of compensation payments made to companies. While the same rate of corporation tax applies whether income or capital, there could be very different ultimate results, depending on the availability of losses and how the tax charge is computed (and potentially the capital gains exemption that applies to some damages payments).

The case concerned the tax treatment of a sum received by Chester Lettings Limited (‘CL’) as compensation for having been mis-sold Interest Rate Hedging Products (‘IRHPs’) under various loan arrangements with Clydesdale Bank, and whether the sum should be treated (for tax purposes) as a capital or income receipt.  The decision provides a useful insight into the tribunal’s reasoning and methodology in considering this subject and is thus a helpful reminder for taxpayers considering the character of compensation and damages receipts.

  • The first task is to identify the nature of the payment (i.e. what the compensation is received for). This should not be conflated with identifying the source of legal right which entitles the taxpayer to the compensation, or the methods by which the compensation is calculated. Leaning on prior decisions in London & Thames Haven Oil Wharves v Attwooll [1967] Ch 722; Donald Fisher (Ealing) Ltd v Spencer [1989] STC 256; and Deeny & Ors v Good Walker Ltd (in liquidation) [1996] STC 299, the FTT restated that if on considering the facts, compensation is received in respect of a failure to receive sums which would have been taxable trading receipts in the hands of the relevant taxpayer, the payment should be subject to tax as trading income. Similarly, compensation received in respect of expenses which have been treated as deductible trading expenses (and which would not have been incurred but for the action which gave rise to the claim to compensation) should be subject to tax as trading income.

    Applying these principles,  the FTT found that: (i) the compensation was paid for CL’s liability to pay sums of money, that is excessive amounts and break costs paid because of the IRHPs that had been mis-sold to it; and (ii) the payments made by CL pursuant to the mis-sold IRHPs were deductible (for tax purposes) from the profits of the business (i.e. revenue expenses). Consequently, the FTT concluded that the compensation paid by reference to those expenses must be a revenue receipt taxable in the hands of CL. Specifically, the compensation payment was viewed as profit arising on non-trading loan relationships (noting CL operated a property business, which for the purpose of the UK’s loan relationships rules, is not considered a trade), taxable as non-trading credits. In other words, the compensation payment was determined to be taxable income, not capital in nature.
  • Secondly, attempts to frame payments as capital receipts on the basis that they represent compensation for ‘opportunity cost’ are unlikely to succeed. In this case, CL argued that the sum received was not income but compensation for a "lost opportunity" (which is a capital sum and which was then exempt by virtue of an Extra-Statutory Concession - ESC D33), reflecting the fact that CL had been deprived of the chance to enter into a more appropriate financial product. It is worth noting that the same argument has been made in two other FTT cases (Hackett v HMRC [2024] UKFTT 749 (TC); Wilkinson v HMRC [2020] UKFTT 362) and has been rejected by the tribunal in those instances, as well as the current case with the FTT noting that CL’s submissions were “misconceived, and completely miss the mark”.
  • Lastly, in the context of a compensation payment to a UK borrower for mis-sold derivatives in connection with a loan, this decision suggests that if the mis-sold derivative is embedded in the relevant loan itself, the payment may be taxed as income under the UK’s loan relationship rules even if the compensation is not income on ordinary principles.

Contact