A recent High Court decision relied on explanatory guides, trustee minutes and other governance documents in deciding to correct a mistake in the drafting of a scheme’s amendment power.

The High Court has granted rectification of two deeds after finding that a restriction on a scheme’s amendment power had been included by mistake. The restriction prevented amendments that would affect or prejudice benefits “already accrued and secured”, creating a Courage style fetter.

The scheme’s original governing documents did not contain this restriction. It was introduced in a new trust deed and rules adopted in 2004 and then carried forward into a further consolidating deed in 2012.

The mistake came to light after the scheme had closed to future accrual in 2010. Had the restriction applied, scheme liabilities would have increased by around £8 million because members could have retained a final salary link.

The court found strong evidence that neither the employer nor the trustee intended to introduce the restriction:

  • Explanatory guides to the 2004 and 2012 deeds did not identify any new restriction, and witness evidence confirmed that decision makers relied on these guides rather than reviewing the deeds line by line.
  • Trustee minutes did not mention the introduction of the restriction.
  • The employer’s financial position at that time meant it was unlikely that the parties would knowingly adopt a change that could increase future liabilities.
  • Drafting history suggested the restriction came from a precedent used when drafting the 2004 deed.
  • Instructions to advisers showed a desire to retain flexibility over the scheme’s future, including the possibility of closure.
  • Later negotiations about scheme closure suggested that neither the employer nor the trustee believed the final salary link was already protected by the amendment power.

This decision is a useful reminder of the evidential value of explanatory guides, trustee minutes and other governance records: where a drafting mistake comes to light years later, these documents may provide some of the strongest evidence of what the parties intended and thought they were agreeing to.

Contact