Trustees and providers now have more detail of what DC pension reform will demand of them over the next few years. The government has published further detail on three major changes under the Pension Schemes Act 2026: guided retirement, scale requirements and the new Value for Money Framework.

Value for Money Framework

Trustees and providers will soon have to collect, assess and publish value data every year – and act on poor results. The Value for Money (VFM) Framework will assess and compare the value delivered by workplace defined contribution (DC) pension arrangements. A joint Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and The Pensions Regulator (TPR) consultation, together with the accompanying draft regulations and FCA rules, sets out how the new framework will work across both trust based and contract based workplace pension schemes.

Under the proposals, trustees and providers must collect the following data for the previous calendar year and submit it to a central database by March 31, each year:

  • Investment performance (backward and forward-looking metrics).
  • Asset allocation.
  • Costs and charges.
  • Quality of service (including things like record-keeping, transaction promptness, complaints and percentage of members that have nominated a beneficiary, which is an indicator of member engagement).

Schemes must then carry out a VFM assessment using the collected data, comparing their default and quasi-default arrangements to a commercial comparator group. The consultation sets out a three-step process for this. Schemes must then reach a red, amber, light green or dark green (RAGG) rating:

  • Red: the arrangement is not delivering value. Generally, trustees and providers must transfer members to a better value arrangement, provided this is in members' best interests.
  • Amber: the arrangement is not currently delivering value but could do so if improvements are made. Trustees and providers must develop and implement an improvement plan.
  • Light green: the arrangement is delivering value, but there remains scope for improvement.
  • Dark green: the arrangement is delivering strong value and consistently outperforms comparable arrangements, with little or no improvement required.

Under the proposals, the database will show data to assessors from March/April, but will only make it publicly available from November, once assessments are complete. Schemes must complete and publish their VFM assessments by October 31.

The consultation also considers how the Framework will interact with existing governance requirements, such as the chair's statement, and the FCA and DWP are considering changes to cut duplication.

When will it apply from?

The government proposes to phase in the VFM Framework. From March 31, 2028, master trusts, large single-employer trusts (50,000+ active and deferred members) and open, firm-designed multi-employer contract-based arrangements must complete a full VFM assessment and publish a rating. All other in-scope arrangements need only submit their data to the database by March 31, 2028; they will not need to carry out a full VFM assessment, and their data will not be published in 2028.

The government also proposes no penalties (for example, forced transfers) for poor ratings during 2028, and a first data collection period covering only six months (July 1, to December 31, 2027), rather than the normal 12 months, to give schemes time to prepare.

From 2029, all in-scope arrangements must comply with all the requirements.

Next steps

  • Consultation closes: September 1, 2026.
  • Response to the consultation and final regulations: expected by January 2027.
  • TPR code/guidance: expected ahead of first VFM assessments in March 2028.
  • FCA policy statement and rules: expected Q1 2027.

Scale requirements

The DWP has published a discussion paper seeking views on how the new scale requirements for master trusts and group personal pension schemes will work in practice. Trustees of these schemes should start planning now for the scale requirements and consider whether they will push them towards consolidation.

Under the Pension Schemes Act 2026, master trusts and group personal pension schemes used for automatic enrolment will generally need a main scale default arrangement (MSDA) holding at least £25 billion of assets by 2030 if they are to keep receiving automatic enrolment contributions, or £10 billion under a transition pathway to reach £25 billion by 2035. For a brief overview of the scale requirements under the Pension Schemes Act 2026, see here.

The discussion paper focuses on three key elements that will determine how schemes meet the scale threshold:

  • How the MSDA will work in practice.
  • What counts as a common investment strategy (assets held within an MSDA must be managed under a common investment strategy).
  • How to decide whether schemes are "connected" and therefore able to share an MSDA.

The government still intends that only schemes within the same corporate group should be able to combine assets to meet the scale requirements. Schemes that cannot reach the threshold alone, and sit outside a wider corporate group, may need to consider consolidation options.

Next steps

  • Discussion paper closes: September 7, 2026.
  • Consultation on regulations: expected second half of 2027.
  • Consultation on TPR code and guidance: expected mid-2028.
  • Final regulations and TPR code and guidance: expected first half of 2029.

Guided retirement

Schemes will soon need to build a default retirement income option into their offering, but the government has now pushed back the deadline for doing so. It has also asked for views on four guiding principles that schemes must follow when offering guided retirement options.

As a reminder, guided retirement is meant to ensure that members get a default retirement income solution, rather than being left to navigate complex decumulation decisions on their own. For more information, see our brief overview here.

The same requirements will apply across both trust-based and contract-based workplace pension schemes, and the same principles apply to both.

The four principles are:

  • Members should not have to make complex financial decisions.
  • Default solutions should protect against longevity risk – members must get a retirement income that lasts throughout retirement.
  • Members must remain free to choose alternative options.
  • Members must consent before payments under the default pension begin.

Schemes will have flexibility over how they design retirement income solutions, but the guided retirement option must be capable of providing an income throughout retirement. Schemes can provide this directly, or transfer members to another scheme offering a suitable retirement income solution.

The government has pushed back guided retirement: it now expects this to apply from summer 2029 for master trusts and group personal pension plans, and from summer 2030 for all other defined contribution schemes. This gives schemes more time to prepare, but also means members retiring before these dates will not yet benefit from a default income solution.

Next steps

  • Consultation on DWP policy / FCA discussion paper: expected in second half of 2026.
  • Consultation on draft regulations and FCA rules: expected in second half of 2027.
  • TPR guidance: expected in mid-2028.
  • Regulations and FCA policy: expected in second half of 2028.

Contact