The Law Commission has published its consultation paper on overcoming barriers to transactions, which focuses on reforming the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 ("LTA 1987") and the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ("LTCA 1995") (the "Consultation"). In particular, the review considers whether the right of first refusal under the LTA 1987 should continue to apply to grants of commercial leases in mixed-use buildings, and whether anti-avoidance provisions in the LTCA 1995 (i.e. measures designed to stop the aims of the LTCA 1995 being circumvented) are preventing commercially sensible transactions.
Relevant to anyone involved in commercial leasehold transactions in England and Wales, this consultation seeks views on reforms to make the law fairer, less confusing and ultimately lead to more streamlined commercial leasehold transactions. This article sets out the legal background to the Consultation and the key reforms it proposes.
Right of first refusal under LTA 1987
Under LTA 1987, residential tenants of a mixed-use property have, subject to certain qualifying criteria, a right of first refusal (where the landlord must first offer the property for sale to the qualifying residential tenants) when a landlord wants to dispose of an interest in that property (such as by selling it). A landlord commits a criminal offence if they breach this right and potentially faces being liable to pay an unlimited fine.
Although designed to protect residential tenants, the right of first refusal generally applies to grants of commercial leases within qualifying mixed-use buildings, creating cost, complexity and delay for landlords and investors in complying with Part 1 of the LTA 1987. Landlords can already sidestep the right, such as through headleases to a special purpose vehicle, but only at the cost of unnecessary expense, bureaucracy and risk. Furthermore, residential leaseholders now have more effective tools for protection, like collective enfranchisement and the right to manage, that did not exist when the LTA 1987 was passed.
As such, the Consultation proposes the following:
- Excluding non-residential disposals from the right: The grant of a lease of a part of the premises that is (or is intended to be) exclusively occupied or used for non-residential purposes would no longer trigger the right of first refusal. This would take ordinary commercial lettings — such as the lease of a shop, restaurant or supermarket unit within a predominantly residential building — outside the regime.
- Protecting genuinely shared areas: The exclusion would not extend to parts of the building that residential tenants share as an adjunct to occupying their flats (for example, a common entrance lobby, bin store, or service ducts serving both the flats and the commercial units). Disposals of such shared areas would remain caught, preserving the protection that the right of first refusal was designed to give residential leaseholders.
- Limiting the exclusion to the grant of leases: The proposed exclusion is deliberately confined to the grant of a lease, rather than all forms of disposal. This is to guard against the landlord's overall reversionary interest (which the right of first refusal was originally intended to capture) being fragmented and disposed of piecemeal.
Anti-avoidance provisions under section 25 of LTCA 1995
LTCA 1995 was introduced to abolish privity of contract as between original landlord and original tenant to a lease, preventing the unfairness that would otherwise cause outgoing tenants from indefinite liability for covenants (such as, to pay rent) even after the lease has been assigned. Under section 25 of LTCA 1995, any agreement is void if it attempts to exclude, modify or frustrate the operation of the LTCA 1995.
However, section 25 has been interpreted so strictly by the courts over a number of years, that it can block what most parties consider commercially sensible arrangements. The Consultation proposes creating targeted new exceptions to the automatic release and anti-avoidance rules under LTCA 1995, so that certain transactions would no longer be rendered void. Some examples include:
- A tenant's guarantor guaranteeing the incoming tenant: Where a lease is assigned from one tenant to another, the outgoing tenant's guarantor cannot directly guarantee the new tenant's obligations — whether at the time of the assignment, or under a prior arrangement requiring it later. Where a lease is assigned from one subsidiary to another within the same corporate group, and the parent company already guarantees the outgoing tenant’s obligations, the parent cannot simply continue or repeat that guarantee for the incoming tenant’s obligations. The Consultation proposes that, where the relevant parties are members of the same corporate group, such guarantee arrangements should be permitted.
- A tenant assigning its lease to its own guarantor: The current law can also block a commercially practical solution where, for example, a struggling company wishes to assign the lease to the individual or parent company that already stands behind its obligations. The Law Commission proposes that the assignment of a lease by a tenant to its guarantor should be permitted generally, though any advance agreement requiring the guarantor to accept such an assignment would remain unenforceable.
- Group company and partnership transfers: Where a lease might be assigned between companies in the same corporate group, or a partnership lease might need to be assigned when one partner retires or is replaced, existing guarantee arrangements may be prevented from being carried over or repeated for the incoming tenant. Therefore, the Consultation proposes that these assignment and guarantee arrangements should be valid in specified circumstances, including for repeat guarantees within corporate groups and substantially the same partnership.
Key takeaways and next steps
The Consultation’s proposals aim to allow landlords developing and investing in mixed-use buildings to make ordinary disposals of commercial leases more easily, while preserving protections for residential tenants. For corporate groups and partnerships holding commercial leases, these reforms would make intra-group reorganisations, partner changes and guarantee arrangements considerably more straightforward.
The Consultation closes on 16 September 2026, and you can respond to the proposed reforms here. The Law Commission will publish a final report including its recommendations for overcoming barriers to commercial transactions, as well as its response to a separate, but related, consultation on the right to renew business tenancies (on which we have reported separately here).
With special thanks to Adam Lee (Paralegal).