Trustees could soon pay defined benefit members a share of scheme surplus without triggering a tax charge. Under new draft rules, members would pay income tax at their marginal rate on a member authorised surplus payment, but the payment would not impact their annual allowance or lump sum allowances.

The draft surplus regulations, out for consultation now, assume that trustees will be able to pay surplus to members. But the tax rules do not back this up: if a scheme makes a member surplus payment today, and it counts as an unauthorised payment, this would trigger an unauthorised payment tax charge.

New draft tax regulations close this gap. They create a new authorised payment: an authorised member surplus payment, which would be available once a member reaches normal minimum pension age (or earlier if they are in ill health). Trustees can also grant the right to a payment earlier than normal minimum pension age, but hold off paying it until the member reaches that normal minimum pension age.

Members will pay income tax on an authorised member surplus payment, just as they would on their pension. But it will not count towards the annual allowance or eat into the member's lump sum allowances, so it should not trigger extra tax charges elsewhere.

The rules also give existing surplus payments to employers a new name: authorised employer surplus payments.

This clears a big tax hurdle, but it is only one piece of the puzzle. There is currently no overarching statutory power for trustees to pay surplus directly to members. Trustees will therefore need to rely on existing rules and discretionary powers, or seek a new power. In either case employer consent will often be needed. That creates a potential impasse if trustees wish to use surplus for the benefit of members: the employer can block that use unless it is satisfied with the surplus allocation between the employer and members.

The consultation on the draft legislation closes on September 7, 2026, and the government wants the changes in force by April 7, 2027. Trustees should use that time to check their scheme rules and plan ahead.

For more on how the wider surplus release regime works, see our briefing, Seven steps to releasing DB pension scheme surplus.

Contact