HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has published new Guidelines for Compliance for fund managers to determine whether outsourced fund management services are a single or multiple supply for VAT purposes, prompting managers to check their contracts, pricing and invoicing to ensure that VAT is being correctly applied.

The question of whether a supply of services is a single or multiple supply can impact whether VAT should be charged on the services, particularly where supplies are made in connection with the management of a special investment fund (VAT exempt).

Fund managers commonly outsource parts of their investment management and fund administration roles to third parties under a single master agreement. The supplier’s services can be exempt from VAT only if they relate to management of a special investment fund and, viewed broadly, form a distinct whole that is specific to, and essential for, the management of that fund.

A difficulty can arise where one provider services a mix of both qualifying and non-qualifying funds (that is, some VAT exempt and some VATable). As the Court of Justice of the European Union confirmed in BlackRock Investment Management (UK) Ltd v HMRC (Case C-231/19), a single supply has a single VAT liability and that supply cannot be apportioned between a number of funds. If the management services provided are economically one supply, they are VAT exempt only if every fund they relate to is a special investment fund. While the guidance makes it clear that there are no special single or multiple supply rules for fund management, the guidance seeks to provide a clear statement of how HMRC expects the ordinary principles to apply outsourcing arrangements in the fund management context.

The indicators

HMRC sets out four broad indicators which should be taken into account: the number of suppliers, the view of the typical consumer (here, the fund manager), the contract terms and economic reality, and the intention of the legislation. A single contract is not decisive; the contract is the starting point, but the answer turns on the economic reality. For fund management, factors pointing towards multiple supplies include:

  • Separate decisions by the fund manager, fund by fund, on whether and which services to buy.
  • Services tailored to each fund and recorded in fund-level documentation sitting under the master agreement.
  • Delivery for one fund that does not support delivery for any other.
  • Pricing set fund by fund (for example, by reference to each fund’s assets under management), with invoices showing a separate fee for each fund.

On the contrary, a standardised package bought for all funds together, at a single or apportioned price, points the other way.

Next steps

The guidance has been long awaited and provides a useful set of principles to consider when determining the correct VAT treatment of certain supplies. This is particularly important for fund managers who buy in services from overseas providers, where they have to operate the reverse charge.

Fund managers who outsource certain services should take the time to check their current arrangements and take particular care when negotiating new contracts.

Contact