Scale brings some benefits for DC schemes, but does not reliably improve investment performance.

TPR’s report looks at the available evidence on the benefits of scale and consolidation. The evidence shows that master trusts can lower costs and improve governance and may offer broader investment options. However, the link between scheme size and investment performance is weak. Often single-employer trusts tend to have higher average investment returns than the average master trust, although outcomes vary more widely.

TPR’s overall message is that scale can help, but it is not a guarantee of value and the market must remain alert to this.

Contact