On 27 May 2026, the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee (the Committee) published its report (the Report) as part of the pre-legislative scrutiny of the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill (the Bill). For a summary of the main aspects of the draft Bill, see our article: Commonhold, caps and curveballs: Making sense of the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill. The Report aims to test the draft Bill against the government’s stated policy objectives. On that basis, the Report essentially concludes that, while the draft Bill is a significant step towards giving leasehold homeowners greater control of their buildings, the final Bill would require several changes to meet leaseholders' expectations and reflect the government’s promises. In this article we consider the Report’s main findings and recommendations, and what happens next.
Capping ground rents
- Amount: the Committee welcomes capping ground rents at £250 per year, acknowledging that some stakeholders will lose out. However, it is not clear why a 40-year transitional period before changing to a peppercorn ground rent is justified, and why a shorter 20-year period would not also strike a fair balance between the parties. The Committee therefore requires more comprehensive and accurate data from the government in order for the Committee to come to a definitive judgement on the optimum transitional period.
- Timetable for enactment: the government’s current timetable would bring the ground rent cap into force in late 2028, subject to parliamentary timings and its consideration of "remaining policy choices" (such as whether to allow leaseholders to agree to pay a ground rent in exchange for a lower purchase price). The Committee does not believe extra time should be required and recommends that the cap come into force in late 2027, with the final Bill including a clause providing that the cap will come into force two months after the Bill is given Royal Assent, not at a time to be decided by ministers (as is currently the case).
Strengthening leaseholders' rights
- Law Commission recommendations not enacted: in its previous reports in 2020, the Law Commission made certain recommendations which, according to its manifesto, the government promised to enact. These include measures such as allowing leaseholders to avoid paying development value upfront by voluntarily agreeing to a restriction on future development of their property, as well as changes to the right-to-manage process that would allow leaseholders to appoint their own managing agent. The Report expresses disappointment that the draft Bill does not contain these remaining recommendations and urges the government to enact them following the specific approach set out in the Appendix to the Report.
- Regulation of managing agents: the Report concludes that a significant shortcoming of the draft Bill is that it does not include provisions for the “long overdue” regulation of property managing agents. It argues there is a need for a credible independent regulator with stringent enforcement powers to deal with current issues of unaccountability and low standards from managing agents who primarily serve the freeholders. This would benefit all leaseholders, both those unable to convert to commonhold and those who do, since it is likely commonhold associations will opt to contract with them for services. Enforcement powers should include issuing fines or revoking licences of managing agents who breach a statutory Code of Practice. The government should not pursue the current option of mandatory qualifications by professional bodies due to leaseholders’ lack of confidence in these bodies.
Making commonhold work
- Conversion from leasehold to commonhold: currently, the draft Bill has a two-step process of conversion to commonhold: first, collective enfranchisement, and second, a vote to convert to commonhold. To promote the uptake of commonhold as the default ownership tenure and streamline the process, the final Bill should establish conversion to commonhold as the default outcome of a collective enfranchisement, with leaseholders given the choice to “opt-out” of automatic conversion by a 50% vote.
- Non-consenting leaseholders: the Committee recommends that, in order to prevent them from avoiding contributions, non-consenting leaseholders who subsequently participate in a conversion to commonhold should be required to contribute to the shared costs incurred by those who previously participated in a collective enfranchisement. This would include the shared premium paid for buying the freehold of a building’s common parts, as well as the legal and professional costs incurred.
- Building safety defects: the Report emphasises the need for a requirement on freeholders to disclose information about the building safety status of a block as part of the enfranchisement process. This will enable leaseholders to be fully informed of any liabilities they may be assuming when converting to commonhold.
- Reserve funds: the final Bill should ensure that the new requirement to hold a reserve fund applies not only to commonhold blocks, but also new and existing leaseholders. This will prevent financial hardship caused by large, unexpected bills across the different types of tenure.
- Commonhold associations: the Report concludes that the effectiveness of commonhold associations will depend on unitholders being supported to come to fair, informed decisions about the management of their block. It recommends that, after Royal Assent, the government issues guidance on the relevant documents which directors must provide to unitholders for different types of votes in a commonhold association.
- Shared ownership: the draft Bill is unclear on what voting rights shared owners will have during the 10-year initial repair period (the initial period in which the landlord is responsible for paying for structural and some internal repairs). As it currently stands in the draft Bill, a shared ownership provider is allowed to exercise a shared owner’s vote during the 10-year initial repair period. This has led to concerns that shared owners may be shut out of decisions that directly affect them during that time. The Committee asks the government to make provision for shared owners to share the unit's vote (along with the shared ownership provider) during the 10-year initial repair period.
- Land Registry: the Report recognises that a failure to modernise the Land Registry’s legacy systems poses a significant risk to the successful implementation of commonhold. It recommends further investment in digitising the Land Registry’s systems to make them more accessible and user-friendly, thereby supporting the move to commonhold.
Banning leasehold for new flats
The Report emphasises that the provisions in the draft Bill introducing a ban on new leasehold flats are vital to advance commonhold as the default tenure. As such, it recommends that the government continues close engagement with industry throughout the passage of the legislation to ensure a transition to commonhold that minimises unintended impacts on the wider housing market. It should also ensure that any exemptions for the retirement housing sector from the ban on new leasehold flats (and other aspects of the legislation) are strictly limited.
Next steps
The Committee asks the government to continue with its fundamental aim of introducing the ban on new leasehold flats as soon as possible. In particular, it recommends that the government:
- respond to its recommendations within two months;
- introduce the final Bill to Parliament by autumn 2026;
- schedule a Second Reading before the November recess; and
- ensure that the final Bill receives Royal Assent by mid-2027.
Keeping to this schedule would allow some of the provisions, such as the cap on ground rent, to come into force in late 2027.
We will be keeping a close watch on the Bill as it progresses.
With special thanks for Thahmid Rahim (Trainee Solicitor).