In this banking and finance litigation update, we focus on key cases, developments and hot topics to help in-house counsel to stay up to date. In this issue, we cover the following:
-
1. The Privy Council removes the conscious awareness requirement in deceit claims 2. The High Court extends practical control over third-party documents 3. The Court of Appeal considers causation in email interception fraud 4. The High Court defines the limits of conversion for digital assets and the UKJT publishes guidance on control 5. The Commercial Court transparency pilot begins
6. Norwich Pharmacal orders, disclosure and tracing remedies for cryptoassets 7. AI and tort liability: The UKJT confirms English law can address AI-related harms 8. Warning notice on misuse of AI 9. Introducer fees: Common pitfalls and litigation risk 10. Good faith in framework agreements 11. Sanctions and letters of credit
You can access more detailed briefings using the links; and if you would like further information on a topic then please contact us.
1. The Privy Council removes the conscious awareness requirement in deceit claims
Key takeaway: A claimant does not need to prove conscious awareness of a representation to establish reliance in a claim for deceit
The Privy Council has made a significant change to the tort of deceit under English law. It held that a claimant does not need to prove conscious awareness of a representation in order to establish reliance. This recommendation may lead to an increase in deceit claims. In particular, the recommendation is likely to have an impact on claims brought against banks and financial services providers, where claims stem from advice being provided rather than express statements.
A fuller analysis of this decision is available here: Rethinking reliance in deceit claims | Inside Disputes
2. The High Court extends practical control over third-party documents
Key takeaway: _Practical control for disclosure purposes can extend beyond the immediate legal entity to documents held by group subsidiaries_
In IPJSC United Company Rusal v Whiteleave Holdings Ltd and Others [2026] EWHC 154 (Comm), the Commercial Court reinforced the principle that practical control for disclosure purposes can extend beyond the immediate legal entity. It found that the President and General Director of the parent company exercised control over documents held by a subsidiary, on the basis of factors including the group's integrated operations, a shared document management system, the fact that subsidiary documents had previously been provided, and the absence of any evidence that subsidiaries had refused requests for documents. The decision is a reminder that separate corporate personality alone will not prevent disclosure obligations extending to documents held elsewhere within a group. Shared systems, integrated operations and a history of cooperation may all support a finding of practical control. The decision also highlights the need to think carefully before routinely collecting documents from across a group structure, as doing so may help establish practical control in future proceedings.
Our team has prepared a detailed overview of this case and the pilot here: High Court finds practical control over documents held by foreign subsidiary | Inside Disputes
3. The Court of Appeal considers causation in email interception fraud
Key takeaway: The intervention of a third-party fraudster breaks the chain of causation in an email interception fraud, and satisfying the “but for” test alone is not sufficient to establish liability for breach of contract
The Court of Appeal has confirmed that the intervention of third-party fraudsters in an email interception scheme broke the chain of causation between a breach of a confidentiality clause and the claimant’s loss. The decision offers important guidance for parties seeking to allocate losses arising from business email compromise fraud and reinforces that satisfying the “but for” test of factual causation is necessary but not sufficient to establish liability for breach of contract. Our team has produced an overview of the decision and its implications here: Fraud breaks the chain: Court of Appeal on causation in email interception cases | Inside Disputes
4. The High Court defines the limits of conversion for digital assets and the UKJT publishes guidance on control
Key takeaway: _The High Court has struck out a claim for conversion of a digital asset, but the UKJT has published authoritative guidance on the concept of control that will support the development of digital asset law_
In Yuen v Li [2026] EWHC 532 (KB), the High Court struck out a claim for conversion of bitcoin, holding that OBG v Allan was “a clear block” to extending conversion to digital assets. The decision is a disappointing one, given that the Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025 was intended to enable judge-led development of proprietary remedies in this area. Separately, the UK Jurisdiction Taskforce has published its Report on Control of Digital Assets, an authoritative guide that will serve as a reference for judges and practitioners grappling with the development of digital asset law.
Our team has produced an overview of the decision and its impacts here: Yuen v Li: Conversion of digital assets | Inside Disputes; UKJT publishes Report on Control of Digital Assets | Inside Disputes; UK Jurisdiction Taskforce publishes Report on Control of Digital Assets | Inside Disputes; Digital assets and applicable law: in defence of the lex situs | Inside Disputes
5. The Commercial Court transparency pilot begins
A two-year pilot scheme providing for public access to key court documents in the Commercial Court, the London Circuit Commercial Court, and the Financial List (the Pilot) is now underway. The Pilot is governed by Practice Direction 51ZH and an accompanying Guidance Note. The Pilot introduces additional filing requirements for parties and may result in increased public scrutiny of documents filed at court.
Our team has prepared a fuller summary of the Pilot and its impacts available here: Commercial Court pilot to make more court documents publicly available | Inside Disputes
6. Norwich Pharmacal orders, disclosure and tracing remedies for cryptoassets
Key takeaway: NPOs may be extended to future persons unknown without the need for a fresh application, and tracing remains available for cryptoassets despite mixing
We have continued to see clients receive a lot of Norwich Pharmacal and other disclosure order requests this year. One potential driver is that we’ve seen applicant firms increasingly obtaining them on the papers and without the cost of a hearing. Recent developments include:
Procedural flexibility: In Williams v Nest Services Limited [2025] EWHC 1409 (Comm), concerning cryptoasset fraud, the Court confirmed that NPOs may be extended to future persons unknown (i.e. those who are not yet identifiable but who will come to light through ongoing disclosure), and that the orders could be served on those falling within the described category once identified, without the need for resubmitting an application.
Mixed funds and proprietary remedies: In Stephen Wilden v Person Unknown and Huobi Global S.A. [2026] EWHC 1355 (KB), the Court confirmed that tracing and following remained available as a matter of principle where the identity of the crypto asset is preserved despite mixing. Notably, the Court also awarded indemnity costs against Huobi, criticising its "dismissive and non-cooperative" response to the claimant's legitimate requests for information, an illustration of the English courts' willingness to penalise uncooperative respondents.
7. AI and tort liability: The UKJT confirms English law can address AI-related harms
Key takeaway: _Existing English common law is well equipped to address liability for AI-related harms, but businesses should take practical steps to manage their exposure_
The UK Jurisdiction Taskforce has published its Legal Statement on Liability for AI Harms, which analyses how existing English law principles may apply to non-deliberate harms caused by AI. The Statement concludes that the flexibility of English common law means it is already well equipped to address many questions regarding AI-related liability and rejects the premise that the absence of an AI-specific regime leaves a vacuum. As AI does not have legal personality under English law, liability will always attach to a legal person, e.g. individuals or corporate entities. However, as AI becomes more integrated into business workflows, the circumstances in which negligence claims may arise are likely to increase and businesses should take steps to manage their potential exposure.
Our team has considered these issues further here: AI and tort liability: The UKJT’s Legal Statement on Liability for AI Harms | Inside Disputes
8. SRA Warning Notice on Misuse of AI
The SRA published its Warning Notice on Misuse of AI in August, reminding regulated firms and in-house teams that solicitors remain personally accountable for AI-generated work product, including the risk of "hallucinated" case references and that entering client information into public AI tools may breach confidentiality and waive legal professional privilege.
Our team has prepared a fuller summary of the Warning Notice and its impacts available here: SRA publishes Warning Notice on misuse of AI | Inside Disputes. Our global investigations team has published a cross-border Privilege Horizon Scanner examining how courts in the US, UK, Australia, Canada and elsewhere are considering whether AI-generated outputs attract privilege: Key developments in privilege in cross-border investigations | Global Horizon Scanner
9. Introducer fees: Common pitfalls and litigation risk
We have seen an increased number of disputes arising in connection with introducer fees. The key points for financial institutions are: (i) binding fee obligations can arise without a written contract, for example orally or by conduct; (ii) unjust enrichment provides an alternative route to recovery. Even without a contract, an introducer may claim a fee if the company received a benefit at the introducer's expense and retaining it without payment would be unjust; (iii) entitlement under unjust enrichment depends on whether the introduction was the effective cause of the transaction; and (iv) silence on the question of payment, combined with acceptance of an intermediary's services, risks being treated as acceptance of an obligation to pay.
Our team has prepared a guidance note on the pitfalls and areas of litigation risk around introducer fees, available here: Introducer fees: Common pitfalls and litigation risk | Inside Disputes
10. Good faith in framework agreements
_Key takeaway: A_contract being a ‘relational’ contract does not automatically create a duty of good faith. The usual rules for the implication of terms in fact applies and detailed express terms leave little room for implication.
In Svella Connect Ltd v Virgin Media Ltd [2026] EWHC 2223 (TCC), the High Court considered once again relational contracts and implied good faith obligations. Svella provided network services to Virgin Media, pursuant to framework agreements. Svella alleged, inter alia, fraudulent misrepresentation, unlawful means and a breach of an implied duty of good faith. Upon Virgin Media applying for summary judgment or strike-out, Svella withdrew all claims save for the claims arising from an alleged duty of good faith. Pepperall J struck out these remaining claims, downplaying the important of the ‘relational’ nature of the contract. Rather, the key question was whether the parties had set out their full agreement and, if not, whether the pleaded terms should be implied under the usual Marks & Spencer test of necessity, noting: “A term cannot of course be implied in respect of a matter that the parties have already provided for in their agreement…”
Svella is an important reminder that Bates factors (the list of features of a relational contract from Bates v Post Office) only acts to assist the court as “a sense-check”, and the orthodox rules for the implication of terms in fact apply even if a contract is relational in nature.
11. Sanctions and letters of credit
Key takeaway: The Supreme Court has offered some assurance to entities seeking to comply with sanctions regulations in good faith regarding the protection afforded to them by section 44 of the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018
In UniCredit Bank GmbH, London Branch v Constitution Aircraft Leasing (Ireland) 3 Ltd & Anor [2026] UKSC 10, the Supreme Court dismissed appeals by Irish aircraft lessors concerning whether UK sanctions prohibited a bank from making payments to them under letters of credit issued as security for aircraft leases to Russian airlines and allowed the bank’s cross-appeals.
The Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision that the bank was prohibited under regulation 28(3)(c) of the Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (SI 2019/855) (the Regulations) from making the payments under standby letters of credit until the appropriate licences were obtained. Regulation 28(3)(c) prohibits a person from (among other things) providing funds “in connection with” an arrangement whose object or effect is making restricted goods available for use in Russia (aircraft are restricted goods). The Supreme Court interpreted Regulation 28(3)(c) as requiring only a ‘factual nexus’ rather than a ‘causal nexus’.
By way of cross appeal, the bank contended that if Regulation 28(3)(c) did not prohibit the payments, its reasonable belief that regulation 28(3)(c) applied meant that section 44 of the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018 (SAMLA) offered it protection. Section 44 provides protection from liability in civil proceedings for an act done in the reasonable belief that it complies with regulations under SAMLA. Although the cross appeal did not require determination, Lord Stephens addressed the issue because of its wider practical significance. The Supreme Court disagreed with the Court of Appeal's obiter view and found that section 44 provides protection against claims for pre-existing debts, interest and costs if a person has acted with the requisite reasonable belief. Section 44 does not prohibit civil proceedings (which would require clear words as it would prevent access to justice) but rather provides a defence.
With thanks to Humza Nadeem for his assistance in preparing this article.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.