Focus on the fashion and luxury industry: Key developments regarding antitrust, unfair commercial practices and privacy laws.

ICA launches twin investigations into Citizen and Swatch’s online dealer pricing practices

(Link to source: Italian Competition Authority opens proceedings against Citizen and Swatch for alleged online resale price maintenance)

On 9 December 2025, the Italian Competition Authority (ICA) opened proceedings against Citizen Watch Italy S.p.A. and The Swatch Group S.p.A. for alleged infringements of Article 101 TFEU. The investigation concerns the fixing of retail prices displayed on authorised dealers’ online sales channels (jewellers and watch retailers) within selective distribution networks – so suspected resale price maintenance (RPM).

According to the ICA, Citizen – a leading watchmaker whose portfolio includes Citizen, Bulova, Vagary, Frédérique Constant and Alpina – may have required its selective network to apply fixed retail prices, monitored dealers’ online offers, and adopted retaliatory commercial measures against distributors applying discounts or prices deviating from those indicated.

Swatch, another major market operator with brands including Swatch, Tissot, Mido and Hamilton, is alleged to have engaged in similar conduct, involving the imposition of retail prices, monitoring its selective distribution network, and taking retaliatory action against non compliant dealers.

The ICA’s action underscores the increasing scrutiny of online pricing policies and practices related to RPM in selective distribution frameworks across retail sectors.
To mitigate enforcement risk and reputational exposure, companies should:

  • Ensure dealers retain autonomy over retail pricing, online and offline.
  • Avoid clauses, communications or practices that fix or indirectly impose minimum or fixed prices (including through threats, penalties, or withdrawal of supply).
  • Ensure any monitoring serves legitimate purposes (e.g. brand integrity) and is not tied to enforcing resale prices or retaliatory measures.
  • Implement robust antitrust compliance programs, including regular training for sales and distribution channel teams, and internal audits of commercial practices.
  • Review selective distribution agreements to align with the EU Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2022/720) and the related EU Vertical Guidelines, with particular attention to online promotions, discounting, price comparison tools and marketplace policies.

From General Court to CJEU: Zalando’s VLOP appeal now published

(Link to source: Zalando’s appeal published in EU Official Journal following General Court confirmation of VLOP status)

On 12 January 2026, an appeal by Zalando SE (Case C 724/25 P) was published in the EU Official Journal. The appeal challenges the judgment of the EU General Court delivered on 3 September 2025 in Case T 348/23, which had dismissed Zalando’s action against its designation as a “very large online platform” (VLOP) under Article 33 of the Digital Services Act (DSA). The European Commission’s 2023 decision had found that Zalando recorded an average of over 83 million monthly active recipients in the EU, exceeding the 45 million threshold required for VLOP designation.

The General Court held that Zalando qualifies as an “online platform” for its Partner Programme (third party sellers), but not for its own retail sales. As Zalando could not reliably separate users exposed to third party content, the Commission counted all users for the purposes of the 45 million threshold required for VLOP designation. The General Court rejected Zalando’s arguments alleging breaches of legal certainty, equal treatment and proportionality, noting that marketplaces above the 45 million threshold can facilitate the marketing of dangerous or illegal products at scale. In particular, Zalando had advanced six grounds, including misinterpretation of the hosting service definitions, failure to apply “active role” case law, unlawful presumption of exposure to third party content when counting the Average Monthly Active Recipients, burden of proof errors and breach of duty of care and legal certainty due to the Commission adopting a non standardised methodology for the calculation of the Average Monthly Active Recipients.

The General Court’s ruling confirms the Commission’s wide discretion in applying the DSA’s VLOP criteria and signals that platforms exceeding 45 million of Average Monthly Active Recipients according to Article 33 of the DSA must be prepared to comply with enhanced obligations on consumer protection and tackling illegal content.

Contact