Overview
For decades, the pre-emption right granted to project promoters has been a cornerstone of Italian project financing. The mechanism was designed to reward private initiative: an operator who identified an infrastructure opportunity and brought it to the attention of the public administration would enjoy an advantage in the tender process, as a reward for its efforts. On 5 February 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) declared this mechanism incompatible with EU law.
In Case C-810/24 (Urban Vision), the Court held that the pre-emption right under Article 183(15) of Legislative Decree No. 50/2016 (the Former Public Procurement Code) breaches both the principle of equal treatment under Directive 2014/23/EU and the freedom of establishment under Article 49 TFEU.
The ruling arrives at a critical juncture: the European Commission is pursuing parallel infringement proceedings against similar provisions in Legislative Decree No. 36/2023 (the Current Public Procurement Code), and the Italian PPP market has now reached a fundamental crossroads.
The factual background: A familiar scenario with unfamiliar consequences
The Municipality of Milan sought to award a concession for the design, installation, and operation of 70 automated public toilets as part of an urban regeneration initiative. A temporary consortium submitted the original proposal in March 2021 and secured a pre-emption right in the subsequent tender.
When Urban Vision S.p.A. emerged as the highest-ranked bidder in March 2023, the consortium matched Urban Vision's offer and was awarded the contract. To contest this resolution, Urban Vision brought proceedings that ultimately reached the Council of State.
The Council of State, in turn, referred the matter to the CJEU raising the following question of EU law: could a system that effectively guaranteed the promoter's success - regardless of what competitors offered - survive scrutiny under EU procurement principles?
The Court's reasoning: Equal treatment as a non-negotiable standard
On the question of equal treatment, the Court's reasoning was uncompromising. The pre-emption right grants the promoter a privilege denied to all other participants: the ability to revise its offer after seeing what competitors have proposed. This is not a procedural technicality - it inverts the fundamental logic of competitive tendering.
When price is a decisive award criterion - as it typically is - allowing one party to optimise its position after the ranking is published transforms the competition into a formality. The best offer no longer wins: rather, the promoter's willingness to match it does.
The Court rejected Italy's reliance on Articles 30 and 41 of Directive 2014/23/EU, which allows Member States flexibility in designing concession procedures. It was clear that procedural autonomy cannot be invoked to justify mechanisms that structurally disadvantage certain bidders.
Market access and the deterrence problem
The freedom of establishment analysis added a cross-border dimension to the Court's decision. Preparing a competitive bid for a complex concession requires substantial investment (e.g. technical studies, financial modelling, and legal due diligence). An operator from another Member State must presently factor in not only the usual competitive uncertainties but also the possibility that a successful bid simply will be replicated by a domestic incumbent.
The Court considered that this constitutes a restriction on the freedom of establishment under Article 49 TFEU. Italy's attempts to justify the mechanism on grounds of encouraging private initiative and fostering innovation were dismissed as falling outside the list of permitted derogations under Article 52(1) TFEU.
A coordinated challenge: The Commission's infringement proceedings
The Urban Vision judgment forms part of a coordinated challenge to the Italian project financing model from multiple EU institutions. The European Commission's letter of formal notice of 8 October 2025 (Infringement Procedure INFR(2018)2273) targets Article 193 of the Current Public Procurement Code, raising objections that closely mirror the CJEU's reasoning. The Commission argues that the mechanism under Current Public Procurement Code for reimbursing unsuccessful promoters who decline to exercise their right lacks adequate safeguards, potentially creating a further barrier to entry if operators perceive the assessment of reimbursable costs as subject to “manipulation”.
The Brennero motorway tender provides a further illustration of these concerns. The tender, launched by the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport on 31 December 2024, was suspended on 26 June 2025 pending the ruling by the CJEU. The European Commission raised doubts about the legitimacy of the pre-emption right granted to Autostrada del Brennero S.p.A., the project financing promoter, on the grounds that the mechanism could violate the principles of transparency, non-discrimination, and effective competition. The case is further complicated by pending appeals before the Administrative Courts and potential actions by the National Antitrust and Competition Authorities, which can challenge the extensions and advantages granted to the outgoing concessionaire.
Practical implications and open questions
Authorities contemplating new PPP initiatives should look to design award mechanisms that incentivise promoter initiative through solutions other than competitive advantage at the award stage. At the same time, future promoters will compete on the same terms as all other bidders, which may affect both the volume and nature of unsolicited proposals reaching public authorities.
The judgment raises uncomfortable questions about contracts already awarded under the incompatible mechanism. Italian administrative courts will likely see a wave of litigation to determine the scope of Urban Vision and the remedies available to operators who lost contracts to pre-emption rights that EU law now condemns.
The Italian legislature has limited room for manoeuvre. What is required to address the EU Commission’s expectations is a fundamental rethinking of how Italy balances the promotion of private infrastructure initiative against the demands of competitive neutrality. That process will shape the Italian PPP market for years to come.