June 2026

Focus on the fashion and luxury industry: Recent updates related to Antitrust and Foreign Subsidies Regulation.

Morellato appeals ICA’s €25 million fine to the TAR Lazio

Following a decision of the Italian Competition Authority (ICA) on 17 March 2026 imposing a fine of €25,895,043 on Morellato S.p.A. for anti-competitive vertical restraints in the distribution of mid-range jewellery and watches (I876), the company has filed an appeal before the Regional Administrative Court for Lazio (TAR Lazio), seeking the annulment of the decision.

The appeal also challenges a number of the ICA’s related acts, including its communication initiating the investigation, its statement of objections, its decision of 18 November 2025, rejecting Morellato’s commitments proposal, and its decision of 16 July 2025, extending the objective scope of the proceedings.

On 5 June 2026, the President of the First Section of the TAR Lazio issued a decree granting Morellato’s request to file sensitive documentation on a physical storage device rather than through the standard electronic court filing system. According to Morellato, the disclosure of these documents could prejudice its commercial strategies and distort competitive dynamics in the relevant market.

The President accepted this request on the basis of Article 136(2) of the Italian Administrative Procedure Code and Article 9(8) of the Decree of the President of the Council of Ministers No. 40/2016, which allow courts, in exceptional circumstances linked to confidentiality concerns, to dispense with standard electronic filing requirements. The decree also orders the redaction of the appellant’s identity and any other identifying data from the published version, pursuant to data protection regulations.

Morellato’s decision to challenge the ICA’s ruling before the TAR Lazio was widely expected, given the magnitude of the fine and the significance of the underlying legal questions concerning the permissibility of marketplace bans and pricing guidance within selective distribution systems. The appeal will likely test the boundaries of the ICA’s interpretation of Article 101 TFEU in the context of vertical restraints in the fashion and accessories sector, particularly regarding the proportionality and discriminatory nature of restrictions on online sales through third-party platforms imposed on authorised distributors.

The confidential filing order underscores the commercially sensitive nature of the evidence at the heart of this case, which relates directly to Morellato’s distribution model, pricing architecture and relationships with its retail network.  The substantive hearing on the merits has not yet been scheduled. Companies operating selective distribution systems in the fashion sector should continue to monitor developments in this case, as the TAR Lazio's ruling may provide important guidance.

To read more about this case, see: ICA fines Morellato over €25 million for resale price maintenance and marketplace ban.

UK Court of Appeal overturns CAT ruling on resale price maintenance in standalone claim against HOKA owner Deckers

On 8 May 2026, the Court of Appeal of England and Wales overturned a 2024 decision of the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT), which had found that Deckers UK Limited (Deckers) unlawfully prevented the retailer, Up & Running (UK) Limited (Up & Running), from discounting and selling its HOKA branded running shoes online. The Court of Appeal held that the CAT had applied the incorrect legal test in concluding that the supply agreement between the parties amounted to a “by object” infringement of competition law.

The case originated as a standalone antitrust claim by Up & Running, a retailer of running shoes and accessories, which previously purchased HOKA branded products from Deckers on a wholesale basis. In July 2020, Up & Running proposed to Deckers the launch of a new website on which excess stock, including HOKA products, would be sold at a discount. Deckers declined the proposal, and when Up & Running nevertheless commenced selling HOKA products on the new website, Deckers ceased supply in reliance on its terms and conditions, which required distributors to obtain its permission to sell products via a website. Up & Running alleged that this infringed the Chapter I prohibition under the Competition Act 1998 (the UK equivalent of Article 101 TFEU) and sought damages and an injunction requiring Deckers to recommence supply.

In its 31 October 2024 decision, the CAT found that Deckers operated a two-channel distribution system (“Main Retail” and “Clearance”) that did not meet the Metro v Commission (C 26/76) “safe harbour” criteria for selective distribution agreements. The CAT instead held that Deckers’s terms and conditions amounted to a by object restriction of competition as they: (a) restricted passive sales via a Deckers controlled clearance channel, limiting online sales; and (b) prevented significant discounting in that channel, constituting indirect resale price maintenance. It also ruled out the application of the Vertical Block Exemption (Commission Regulation (EU) 330/2010 (VBE)), as both were “hardcore” restrictions.

However, the Court of Appeal held there was “no basis” for the CAT to have reached its conclusion had it assessed the agreement under the “proper legal and economic context”.  The CAT’s decision rested on “a particular and limited analytical basis” and failed to consider the “implications of the facts that it found to exist”. In particular, the CAT had wrongly treated objective or purpose as the sole test required to establish a by object infringement, a conclusion described as “inconsistent with the settled position in law”. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), which intervened in support of Deckers, similarly argued that the CAT had incorrectly treated the presence or absence of a legitimate aim as the decisive factor in assessing a by object restriction.

As to economic context, the Court of Appeal noted that Deckers held only a “modest” market share in a competitive sector with a “significant number” of rival suppliers, and that vertical agreements present a “systemically lower risk” to competition than horizontal arrangements. The Court further held that, in any event, the VBE applied: since Deckers's market share was below the 30 per cent threshold and the restrictions did not amount to hardcore restrictions in their real and practical scope, the challenged conduct was block exempted. The Court also observed that “[i]t is not the function of competition law to save parties from bad bargains, or deals they come to regret”.

The Court of Appeal’s judgment reinforces that (as established by EU case law) a finding of a by object infringement requires a thorough analysis of an agreement’s content, objectives, legal context and economic context – so cannot rely solely on the identification of a restrictive purpose. This is an important judgment for all sectors, including the fashion and sportswear sectors where selective and controlled distribution models are common.

For more on the implications of this judgment, see our separate briefing: Not So Fast: Court of Appeal overturns CAT's approach to By-Object Restrictions in Deckers v Up & Running.

European Commission opens in-depth foreign subsidies investigation into JD.com’s proposed acquisition of CECONOMY

On 28 May 2026, the European Commission opened an in-depth investigation under the Foreign Subsidies Regulation (FSR) into the proposed acquisition by JD.com, Inc. (JD.com) of CECONOMY AG (CECONOMY), the German retail company that operates the MediaMarkt, MediaWorld and Saturn brands in several EU Member States.

JD.com, headquartered in the Cayman Islands and listed on the Nasdaq and the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, heads a group operating a retail business and an e-commerce marketplace in the People's Republic of China (PRC), as well as providing logistics and technological solutions. CECONOMY, headquartered in Germany, is a major retailer specialising in consumer electronics and home appliances, with both online and brick-and-mortar operations in several Member States.

The Commission's preliminary investigation indicates that JD.com may have received foreign subsidies that could distort the EU internal market, including preferential financing, tax incentives and grants provided by entities possibly attributable to the PRC. In particular, the Commission has preliminary concerns that these potential foreign subsidies may have enabled JD.com to offer conditions that distorted the negotiation process for the acquisition of CECONOMY, notably by enabling JD.com to offer a high price and to support CECONOMY's economic activities and growth plan through JD.com’s own technological and logistics capabilities. The Commission also has preliminary concerns that the transaction could allow the merged entity to adopt investment and business strategies that could negatively impact competitive conditions in the EU internal market.

The transaction was notified to the Commission on 17 April 2026. The Commission now has 90 working days, until 2 October 2026, to take a decision. At the end of its in-depth investigation, the Commission may accept commitments proposed by the company if they fully and effectively remedy the distortion, prohibit the concentration, or issue a no-objection decision. The opening of an in-depth investigation does not prejudge its outcome.

This marks an important step in enforcing the FSR (applicable since July 13, 2023), aimed at ensuring fair competition in the EU internal market while remaining open to trade and investment. The case is notable for the consumer electronics sector, given that CECONOMY’s MediaMarkt and Saturn are among Europe’s largest retailers. It will test how the Commission applies the FSR to acquisitions of EU retailers by non EU companies, particularly regarding subsidised pricing and post merger advantages. Companies planning similar transactions should note the Commission’s willingness to assess both the subsidies and their potential impact on the acquisition process and the merged entity’s competitive position in the EU.

Contact