Executive Summary

  • On April 16, 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a judgment concerning the interpretation of Article 8(1) of the Recast Brussels Regulation. The judgment clarifies the conditions under which national courts can exercise jurisdiction over damages actions brought against anchor defendants and co-defendants in cross-border competition litigation, specifically for circumstances in which national courts are adjudicating disputes where the key elements of the case, including the claimants, the co-defendants (other than the anchor defendant), and the underlying facts, are located outside the jurisdiction of the national court.
  • The CJEU confirmed that such claims are sufficiently closely connected to be heard in the jurisdiction of an anchor defendant where they relate to the participation of multiple undertakings in a single infringement.
  • The CJEU further held that it is not necessary for the infringement decision underpinning the claims to be addressed to the particular defendants in each action, provided that each formed part of the undertaking that committed the infringement.
  • Importantly, the notion of “undertaking” may extend to group companies that are economically active and, in certain circumstances, even to holding companies. As a result, an anchor defendant need not itself be economically active on the relevant market.
  • While the substantive merits of a claim are, in principle, irrelevant for determining jurisdiction, national courts must assess any evidence that the claim in respect of the anchor defendant is manifestly unfounded, as the use of such claims may constitute an abuse of jurisdictional rules.

Disputes before the national courts

In two separate sets of proceedings,1 claimants brought damages actions before the District Court of Amsterdam, following infringement decisions adopted by the EC and the Italian company authority (AGCM), respectively. The claims were directed not only against the addressees of the infringement decisions, but also a number of other companies within their corporate groups. In each case, only one defendant company (the “anchor defendant”) was established in Amsterdam.

In both sets of proceedings, the anchor defendant was a holding company that had neither been found to have participated in the cartel nor held liable for the fine by the relevant competition authority. In the first case, however, the anchor defendant’s subsidiary had been found to have participated in the infringement (with the parent company held liable for the fine), whereas in the second case the anchor defendant’s indirect subsidiary had participated and been fined.

Despite these similarities between the two cases, the District Court of Amsterdam reached divergent conclusions on its jurisdiction to hear the claims against co-defendants established outside the Netherlands. These decisions were appealed by the claimants and the defendants, respectively, before the Amsterdam Court of Appeal, which stayed the proceedings and referred questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling on the applicable jurisdictional test under the Recast Brussels Regulation.

Anchor defendants under the Recast Brussels Regulation

The Recast Brussels Regulation sets out the relevant framework for determining jurisdiction in such circumstances. Under the general rule in Article 4(1), defendants must be sued in the Member State of their domicile.2 However, Article 8(1) provides an exception for claims brought against multiple defendants, where those claims are “so closely connected that it is expedient to hear and determine them together to avoid the risk of irreconcilable judgments resulting from separate proceedings”.

Against that background, the key issues before the CJEU concerned the application of these provisions in two scenarios: (i) actions brought against an anchor defendant that was not the addressee of the competition authority’s decision but formed part of the undertaking held liable for the infringement, and (ii) actions brought against co-defendants belonging to a different undertaking found to have infringed competition law, regardless of whether those entities were themselves addressees of the infringement decision.3

Sufficiently close connection

The CJEU held that the exception in Article 8(1) must be interpreted strictly, taking particular account of the risk of irreconcilable decisions in respect of the “same factual and legal situation”, and to the requirement that a well-informed defendant must be able to reasonably foresee the Member States in which it may be sued. That condition is satisfied where claims are brought against several undertakings in respect of their participation in a single and continuous competition law infringement.

Accordingly, a key element of the jurisdictional analysis is whether the anchor defendant forms part of the same economic unit, or “undertaking”, as the entity that participated in the infringement. In that respect, the CJEU recalled its established case law4 that legally distinct entities form a single undertaking where they do not act on the market independently but are subject, in light of the economic, organisational, and legal links between them, to the decisive influence of a parent company.

  1. Identifying the relevant undertaking

In this regard, a rebuttable presumption of decisive influence arises where a parent company directly or indirectly holds all, or almost all, of the capital of an infringing subsidiary, linking the two within a single economic unit. By contrast, a subsidiary may be considered part of the same undertaking as an infringing parent only where, in addition to decisive influence, there is a concrete link between the subsidiary’s economic activity and the subject matter of the infringement for which the parent is held liable.

The CJEU held that, where such a link is not established in the infringement decision, it is for the claimant to demonstrate it. This may be done by adducing evidence showing that: (i) the infringement committed by the parent (or even “grandparent”) company relates to the same products as those marketed by the subsidiary or sub-subsidiary; or (ii) the subsidiary or sub-subsidiary is responsible for the production, sale, delivery, or distribution of those products, or in the provision of the services covered by the infringement.

The Court further clarified that the absence of a finding of joint and several liability between a parent company and its subsidiary in the infringement decision does not preclude the application of the anchor defendant rules under Article 8(1). At the jurisdictional stage, the CJEU held that it is sufficient for the national court, at the stage of deciding jurisdiction, to conclude that it cannot rule out that the defendants concerned form part of the same undertaking.

  1. Anti-circumvention

The CJEU also recalled the national courts must guard against abuses of Article 8(1) by ensuring that claims are not brought against multiple defendants for the sole purpose of removing one of them from the jurisdiction of the courts of the Member State in which it is domiciled, by artificially creating or maintaining the conditions for the application of Article 8(1). This assessment falls to the national courts to determine, alongside their analysis of whether the claims concern the same legal and factual situation.

While the merits of a claim against an anchor defendant are, in principle, irrelevant for jurisdictional purposes, they remain pertinent insofar as they may indicate an abuse. To this end, the CJEU clarified that it is not sufficient for a claim to appear unfounded. Instead, at the time it is brought, the claim must be manifestly unfounded, artificial, or devoid of any real interest to the claimant.

Conversely, the existence of the same factual and legal situation between the claims is capable of excluding a finding of abuse.

Extraterritorial losses, holding companies, and foreseeability

The CJEU also addressed claims for damages for extraterritorial harm, concluding that it is irrelevant that the loss for which compensation is sought occurred outside the European Union, provided that it has a causal link with the anticompetitive conduct in question. Where such conduct has been implemented within the EU internal market, the application of EU competition law is justified under the principle of territoriality, as well as by the EU’s interest in strengthening the effective enforcement of its competition rules through its dual system of public and private enforcement.

The CJEU also held that, although the mere holding and management of shares does not in itself constitute economic activity on the market, the general rules on attribution of conduct remain applicable. As a result, an intermediate holding company may be identified as an anchor defendant where it exercises decisive influence over subsidiaries that carry out economic activities with a concrete link to the subject matter of an infringement committed by the holding company’s parent.

Implications for practice

The judgment clarifies the circumstances in which claims brought against multiple defendants may be considered sufficiently closely connected to be heard together, including where the underlying infringement decision on which the claimant relies is not addressed to those companies. It also confirms, in particular, the scope for claimants to rely on anchor defendant such as a holding companies, even where these are not economically active, provided that the claimant can prove a sufficiently “concrete” link to the infringement.

The Court’s confirmation that damages may be sought for losses incurred outside the European Union – where they are causally linked to anticompetitive conduct implemented within the internal market – further reinforces the role of national courts in Member States as fora for competition litigation vis-à-vis other major jurisdictions.

From a defence perspective, the judgment places renewed emphasis on jurisdictional challenges at an early stage. In particular, defendants are likely to focus on: whether the entities relied on by claimants properly form part of the same undertaking; whether it was reasonably foreseeable for them to be sued in the chosen forum; and whether the claim brought against the anchor defendant is so artificial or manifestly unfounded as to constitute an abuse of process.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Joined Cases C 672/23 and C 673/23 (link here).

  2. 2

    Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2012 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters (OJ 2012 L 351, p. 1) (Recast Brussels Regulation).

  3. 3

    Paragraph 40.

  4. 4

    Including its judgments in CDC Hydrogen Peroxide, Volvo et al., Sumal, and Athenian Brewey and Heineken. For the latter, see also our article CJEU ruling: Parent company’s domicile may have jurisdiction in competition damages litigation.

Contact