The EU Pay Transparency Directive (EU) 2023/970 (the “Directive”) significantly strengthens the requirements for fair, non discriminatory pay structures. Germany must transpose the Directive by 7 June 2026. To prepare for this, the Federal Government has appointed an expert commission whose final report provides important guidance for national implementation as well as initial indications of what employers should anticipate.

Objectives

The Directive aims to address the ongoing gender pay gap and enforce the principle of “equal pay for equal work or work of equal value”. In contrast to the German Pay Transparency Act, which largely relied on individual information rights and partially voluntary review mechanisms—with limited practical impact—the Directive introduces binding transparency obligations. These include mandatory disclosure of salary ranges during recruitment, periodic pay reporting for employers with more than 100 employees, a reversal of the burden of proof, and enforceable sanctions. By implementing these measures, the Directive replaces the previously cautious transparency framework with a stricter, harmonised EU wide regime. Employers will be required to ensure that their pay systems are objective, gender neutral and verifiable.

The interdisciplinary expert commission which produced the report “Bureaucracy Light Implementation of the Pay Transparency Directive”, recommends a clear, practical design of these transparency tools. National legislation should neither fall short of the Directive nor exceed its requirements.

Employers should prepare early. The following key points from the commission’s final report provide further guidance.

Reporting obligations

Pay subject to reporting (Art. 9 of the Directive)

Under Art. 3(1)(a) “pay” is defined as including not only base pay or minimum wages but also all elements of remuneration granted directly or indirectly from the employment relationship, including additional and variable monetary or non monetary benefits.

The commission proposes that pay reporting should be based on the actual pay shown in payroll records. This requires a focus on clearly identifiable remuneration elements consistent with the German Payslip Regulation. Components unrelated to work performed during the reporting period—e.g. severance payments—should be excluded, as converting these into an hourly gross equivalent would not be meaningful.

Calculation of the gender pay gap

To calculate the gender pay gap (average and median under Art. 9(1)(a) and (c)), employers must use actual gross annual pay and gross hourly pay, not target or notional pay.

The commission recommends that the terms “median” and “average” be clearly defined in the legislation, or at least in the explanatory memorandum, based on their use in Art. 3(1).

Under Art. 9(1) in conjunction with Art. 3(1)(b), employers must report both gross annual pay and gross hourly pay. The commission considers it acceptable for employers to base the hourly calculation on the contractually agreed working hours.

Pension-related pay

It remains unclear whether and to what extent pension entitlements or occupational pension benefits are reportable. Following the approach of the Payslip Regulation, employer‑financed contributions or accruals during employment would not be reportable, which would support a low‑bureaucracy approach.

However, occupational pensions fall within the broad EU definition of “pay”, and the equal pay principle applies. Still, it is not settled whether this type of remuneration—typically received only after employment ends—should be excluded from reporting (Art. 9) and information rights (Art. 7).

Group-level reporting

The commission considers it permissible for a parent company to compile and submit the pay reports of its subsidiaries. However, subsidiaries may fall under different national rules, and reports must be submitted in the language required for each competent authority (Art. 29(3)(c)).

Whether indicators may be aggregated at group level remains unresolved. This is likely not compliant with the Directive and would dilute transparency, as data must be meaningful per legal entity.

Pay gaps for groups of workers

Job evaluation: equal work or work of equal value

Under Art. 9(1)(g), employers must also report the gender pay gap for groups of workers performing equal work or work of equal value.

Art. 4(4) requires that this is assessed based on objective, gender neutral criteria agreed with employee representatives. These must include, at a minimum, (i) skills, (ii) effort, (iii) responsibility, and (iv) working conditions, as well as other relevant job factors where appropriate.

Comparator groups and job-related factors

The commission recommends establishing comparator groups according to the evaluation criteria set out in Article 4(3) of the Directive. When forming these groups, it is essential to consider the additional job‑related factors permitted by the Directive, provided these factors are relevant to assessing the specific role.

The commission considers that the legislator should refrain from requiring or referring to the use of scientifically based job‑evaluation tools. Instead, the concept of “work of equal value” should be defined more clearly in the legislation so that, in particular, small and medium‑sized enterprises can establish legally sound and robust comparator groups. To ease the burden, employers could use government‑provided analytical instruments, digital tools and guidance materials that comply with Article 4(4) of the Directive. Their use, however, should remain voluntary.

Site-specific pay data

Employers should be allowed to provide pay data separately by location (e.g. where regional pay differences exist) and for legacy contracts. This would support fair and transparent comparisons.

Justifying pay differences

The commission recommends including a non‑exhaustive list of legitimate grounds for justification, that are consistent with CJEU case law. These should include “acquired‑rights” arrangements, such as those following restructurings or business transfers,—provided these were agreed before 7 June 2026.

However, the commission acknowledges a potential inconsistency: business needs may create grounds for justification which arise after that date. A strict time limit therefore appears impractical and may require future adjustments.

Legitimate justifications must relate either to the individual or to objective, gender‑neutral criteria. Examples include regional labour market conditions or local salary benchmarks.

Works councils should receive targeted training to support this assessment process.

Conclusion

It remains to be seen how far the legislator will follow the commission’s recommendations. The final report offers initial guidance but also highlights areas that employers should begin preparing for. Companies should therefore start reviewing their pay structures, data quality, information processes and reporting systems now. Early action will support compliance and reduce the risk of later adjustments, sanctions and equal‑pay litigation.

Contact