The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal in Logix Aero Ireland Ltd v Siam Aero Repair Company Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 510, confirming that the intervention of third-party fraudsters in an email interception scheme broke the chain of causation between a breach of a confidentiality clause and the claimant’s loss. The decision offers important guidance for parties seeking to allocate losses arising from business email compromise fraud, an increasingly common problem facing corporates.
Background
Logix, an Irish company, agreed to purchase two aircraft engines from Siam Aero, a Thai company, for a total price of US$935,000. The parties signed a Letter of Understanding on 4 July 2024, which was predominantly non-binding but contained a binding confidentiality clause prohibiting disclosure of information and documentation to third parties.
Unknown fraudsters intercepted email correspondence between the parties by gaining access to an email sent by Siam Aero’s representative on 29 July 2024. There was no evidence that either party’s IT systems had been compromised. Using fake email addresses with subtly altered domain names (ending “.co” rather than “.com”), the fraudsters inserted themselves between the parties. Neither side noticed the changes. The fraudsters altered the bank details in draft purchase agreements and invoices, substituting their own Vietnamese bank account for Siam Aero’s Thai account. On 21 August 2024, Logix paid US$824,900 to the fraudsters’ account, believing it was paying Siam Aero. The funds had left the account before the fraud was discovered.
Logix commenced proceedings against Siam Aero. By the time of the appeal, the only remaining claim was that Siam Aero’s breach of the confidentiality clause — by unwittingly sending documents and information to the fraudsters — caused Logix’s loss. At first instance, Heather Williams J struck out the claim, accepting it was arguable that Siam Aero had breached the confidentiality clause but holding that the fraudsters’ intervening actions, not the breach, caused the loss. Males LJ granted permission to appeal solely on the issue of causation.
The Court of Appeal’s decision
Phillips LJ, delivering the lead judgment (with which Cockerill LJ and Peter Jackson LJ agreed), dismissed the appeal.
Logix argued that the Judge had wrongly failed to follow London Joint Stock Bank Limited v Macmillan and Arthur [1918] AC 777, which it said was authority for the proposition that the interposition of an act of fraud does not prevent loss being attributable to the party that provided the fraudsters with the opportunity to commit the fraud.
The Court rejected this. Phillips LJ held that Macmillan was not authority for the broad proposition that the intervention of a third-party fraudster cannot break the chain of causation. Rather, that case was “firmly based on the existence of a specific contractual duty to prevent the very fraud which was in fact perpetrated (and the very loss which ensued), so that the loss was effectively caused by the breach, was within the scope of duty and was not unlikely to occur” (para. 37).
Turning to the facts, Phillips LJ found that the first instance judge was correct in determining that “intervention of the fraudsters occurred before any assumed breach of contract by Siam Aero.” Siam Aero’s assumed breach was “one of a number of necessary stages in the fraud, brought about by the fraudsters as part of their overall fraudulent scheme which depended for its success on Logix being deceived and making payment to the wrong account” (para. 48). Critically, “that final stage of deception by the fraudsters and mistaken payment by Logix occurred without any involvement of Siam Aero” (para. 48). Phillips LJ concluded that this was “a clear case of the breach being part (and only part) of the opportunity for the fraud rather than the cause of the fraud” (para. 48).
The Court also upheld the distinction drawn between this case and Macmillan. The confidentiality clause was primarily concerned with protecting the parties from commercial damage if their information fell into the hands of competitors. There was “no hint that it imposed a special duty to protect the other party from being deceived by fraudsters gaining sight of anodyne or otherwise publicly available information and manipulating it.”
Key takeaways
This decision reinforces that satisfying the “but for” test of factual causation is necessary but not sufficient to establish liability for breach of contract. Even where a breach is a necessary precondition for the loss, the court will still ask whether it was the “effective” or “dominant” cause, or merely the opportunity or occasion for the loss.
For businesses affected by email interception fraud, the judgment highlights the difficulty of recovering losses from the other innocent party to the transaction. Even where a contractual obligation (such as a confidentiality clause) has arguably been breached, the deliberate and independent actions of fraudsters will ordinarily break the chain of causation.
The decision also provides a practical reminder that Macmillan is confined to its particular context: a specific contractual duty to prevent the very type of fraud that occurred. Parties wishing to impose obligations on counterparties to guard against email fraud should consider drafting specific clauses addressing verification of payment instructions, rather than relying on general confidentiality provisions.
Finally, it is worth noting that Logix did not take any step independently of the email correspondence to verify the bank details before making payment. Simple verification procedures — such as confirming payment details by telephone — remain an effective defence against this type of fraud.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.