In MJS Projects (March) Ltd v RPS Consulting Services Ltd [2026] EWHC 884 (TCC), the Technology and Construction Court refused to depart from the usual costs order that the successful party should receive its costs, despite the Claimant's arguments that the Defendant had unreasonably failed to mediate and that the Defendant's expert had made a late change in evidence. The Court also refused the Defendant's application for indemnity costs for the expert evidence phase, notwithstanding significant judicial criticism of the Claimant's expert.

There has been increased focus on Alternative Dispute Resolution (“ADR”) in recent years, and it is well established that a party could face costs sanctions if it unreasonably refused to engage in ADR. However, this decision demonstrates that a refusal to mediate will not automatically result in a costs sanction, particularly where the refusing party engaged constructively in other forms of ADR or settlement discussions, made settlement offers, and had reasonable grounds for requiring further information before agreeing to mediate.

The decision also confirms that the threshold for indemnity costs remains high, even where expert evidence has been heavily criticised by the Court. Strong judicial criticism of expert evidence will not necessarily justify indemnity costs where the party’s legal representatives were not on notice before trial of defects that later emerged in cross-examination.

Background

The costs judgment followed the dismissal of the Claimant's professional negligence claim arising out of the design and construction of a container park near Felixstowe Port. The Claimant alleged that extensive damage to a container yard, which manifested within months of practical completion, resulted from the Defendant’s defective design. The Defendant denied liability, asserting that the damage was due to serious workmanship errors.

The claim was dismissed following trial, the Court finding that workmanship caused the damage. At the costs and consequential orders hearing, the Claimant accepted that the usual order would be that costs follow the event but argued that there were two reasons to depart from that order: (i) the Defendant's unreasonable failure to mediate; and (ii) the late change of evidence by the Defendant's expert. The Claimant argued that the appropriate order was "no order as to costs." In contrast, the Defendant argued that there was no reason to depart from the usual order and, sought indemnity costs against the Claimant in respect of the expert evidence phase.

The Court's costs discretion is governed by CPR 44.2, under which the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, although the Court may order otherwise. In deciding what order to make, the Court will consider all circumstances, including the parties’ conduct and whether a party succeeded on part of its case. Relevant conduct includes whether a party unreasonably failed to engage in alternative dispute resolution.

The Court restated established principles on unreasonable refusal to engage in ADR, noting the fact that parties appear far apart is not, of itself, a reason to refuse mediation. The Court applied the factors in Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust [2004] 1 WLR 3002 for assessing unreasonable failure to engage in ADR, including the dispute’s nature, merits, prior settlement efforts, proportionality of ADR costs, potential delay, and prospects of success. A failure to engage in ADR, even if unreasonable, is not determinative but one factor in the overall costs discretion.

When a court is considering an award of indemnity costs, the test from Excelsior Commercial & Industrial Holdings Ltd v Salisbury Hammer Aspden & Johnson [2002] EWCA Civ 879 applies: “Is there something in the conduct of the action or the circumstances of the case which takes the case out of the norm in a way which justifies an order for indemnity costs?"

Decision

Kelly J concluded that the usual costs order was appropriate, and that the Claimant should pay the Defendant’s costs.

Failure to mediate

The Court accepted that the Defendant did not agree to mediation proposals but held that focusing on this alone oversimplified the parties’ dealings. It was not unreasonable for the Defendant to refuse pre-proceedings mediation, having raised unresolved workmanship issues to which the Claimant failed to respond for 19 months. When the Claimant later asserted expert support, it still did not address those issues or provide the requested report, even on a without prejudice basis.

The Court further accepted the Defendant’s need to understand the expert evidence before mediating. The Court treated mediation as one form of ADR, rather than as the only means by which a party could demonstrate constructive engagement with settlement. The Defendant had proposed alternatives and made settlement offers. It was not unreasonable for the Defendant to require a meaningful response before mediating. Kelly J concluded that mediation would not have had a reasonable prospect of success, given the Claimant’s failure to engage on key issues or disclose expert evidence.

Late change of expert evidence

The alleged late change by the Defendant’s expert on the mass concrete taper was inconsequential. This issue was not part of the Claimant’s case, and the expert’s late calculations were a routine “sense check” typical of litigation.

Indemnity costs

The Court found that costs should be assessed on the standard basis, as there was nothing in the conduct of the action or circumstances of the case that took the case out of the norm so as to justify an order for indemnity costs.

The Defendant sought indemnity costs due to criticisms of the Claimant’s expert, including failures under CPR 35, misapplication of the applicable legal test, and flawed methodology. Despite this, the Court found the expert had been properly instructed and had set out the correct test in writing; the problems only emerged in cross-examination. The Court was not persuaded that the pre-trial expert reports contained sufficient material to alert the Claimant’s legal team to the manner in which their expert would ultimately give evidence. The alleged failure to identify these issues was therefore insufficiently serious to meet the indemnity costs threshold.

The Claimant's tactical decision to focus on identifying a negligent design rather than addressing all workmanship issues was unsuccessful but did not take the conduct of the case "out of the norm", particularly given the compressed expert timetable.

Key takeaways

This decision provides helpful guidance on the relationship between costs orders and ADR. A refusal to mediate will not automatically attract a costs sanction where the refusing party can show constructive engagement with settlement by other means, such as Calderbank offers, without prejudice discussions, or requests for information needed to make mediation meaningful. The Court's emphasis on looking at the "whole picture" of the parties' conduct, rather than focusing on individual refusals to mediate, is a practical reminder that costs arguments are fact-sensitive.

For parties resisting mediation, the decision underlines the importance of explaining the reasons for that position contemporaneously and continuing to engage with settlement. A party that simply refuses mediation without offering any constructive alternative will be in a materially different position from a party that seeks evidence or information necessary for a meaningful mediation, proposes ADR steps, or makes settlement offers.

The decision also confirms the high threshold for indemnity costs. Strong criticism of expert evidence will not necessarily be enough where the party’s solicitors acted reasonably and the relevant defects in the evidence only became apparent at trial. It nonetheless highlights the need for close oversight of experts, clear instructions, and careful testing of whether the expert has addressed all material issues in dispute.

With thanks to Mia Powney for her assistance with this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post