In Investec Bank Plc v Protopapa & Anor[2025] EWHC 3202 (Comm), the Commercial Court upheld an English jurisdiction clause in a facility agreement and dismissed an application for a stay of proceedings on the grounds that the English courts were not the most convenient forum to hear the dispute (known as forum non conveniens). While the English courts retain a discretion to consider if England is in fact the appropriate forum, it is a high hurdle to persuade them to depart from a jurisdiction agreement in their favour. An applicant must demonstrate very strong reasons to override the parties’ contractual agreement on jurisdiction, and such reasons did not exist in this case.

Interestingly, the Court also found a separate ground for dismissing the application – wording in the jurisdiction clause by which the parties positively agreed that the English courts were the most appropriate to settle disputes under the contract created a contractual estoppel. The applicants were therefore prevented from even arguing that England was not the most appropriate forum. Commercial parties should consider including positive wording of this sort in their jurisdiction clauses to reinforce their choice of the English courts, as explained further below.

Background

The Claimant, a bank incorporated in England, advanced two credit facilities to the Defendants, two Swiss-resident businessmen. The facilities incorporated the Claimant’s standard terms which provided that they were governed by English law and included an asymmetric jurisdiction clause granting the English courts exclusive jurisdiction to hear any disputes, while giving the Claimant (but not the Defendants) the option to start proceedings elsewhere.

The Claimant brought proceedings against the Defendants in the English courts. Despite the jurisdiction clause, the Defendants applied to the English court for an order that the English court should decline to exercise jurisdiction because Switzerland was the more appropriate forum to hear the claim. The Claimant opposed the application on the grounds that England was the more suitable forum to determine the claim and, in any event, that the Defendants were contractually estopped from arguing to the contrary.

Decision

Whether England or Switzerland was the more appropriate forum

The Defendants accepted that where there was an English jurisdiction agreement, the English court would not grant a stay of proceedings on the grounds of forum non conveniens unless the applicant could demonstrate strong reasons for overriding the contractual agreement between the parties. The Defendants submitted that there were such strong reasons in this case. These included that:

  1. the facilities formed part of a broader, Swiss‑centred transaction and several related agreements were all governed by Swiss law and subject to exclusive Swiss jurisdiction;
  2. the Claimant had already commenced proceedings against a related party in Switzerland so there was a risk of a multiplicity of proceedings plus the likelihood of further related litigation as the Claimant would need to enforce the English court judgment against the Defendants’ assets in Switzerland; and
  3. the parties might wish to join related parties to the claim and the agreements relevant to this were governed by Swiss law and jurisdiction.

The Defendants argued that taken together, these reasons demonstrated that rational commercial parties would have intended for disputes arising from these interconnected agreements to be resolved in a single forum, namely Switzerland.

In response, the Claimant argued that the Defendants had not demonstrated strong reasons for overriding the unequivocal agreement to English court jurisdiction. This threshold could not be met by foreseeable factors such as the parties’ residence, the location of assets or the presence of related Swiss‑law contracts. The Claimant emphasised that its claim was a straightforward debt action arising under English‑law agreements, and that the parallel proceedings in Switzerland were irrelevant as they involved a different party and distinct obligations. Neither Defendant could demonstrate any prejudice in defending the claim in England.

The Court held that the Defendants were not entitled to a stay on the grounds of forum non conveniens. In coming to its decision, the Court emphasised well‑established principles that parties who freely agree an exclusive jurisdiction clause will generally be held to it unless there are very strong reasons to depart from it. Factors of convenience that were foreseeable when the parties entered into the clause could not amount to such reasons.

The reasons advanced by the Defendants were not sufficiently strong to override their contractual agreement on jurisdiction. The facilities were governed by English law and expressly designated the English courts as the “most appropriate and convenient” forum. The mere existence of related contracts did not override a clear jurisdiction agreement in the primary contract. The related Swiss‑law documents mostly involved different parties, and factors relating to convenience such as the Defendants’ residence or assets in Switzerland were foreseeable. While it might be desirable for the parties to have all their disputes resolved in one jurisdiction, a term to that effect would not be implied where the parties had entered into agreements which expressly provided for the jurisdiction of different courts.

Whether the Defendants were contractually estopped from arguing that Switzerland was the appropriate forum

The alternative argument advanced by the Claimant was that the jurisdiction agreement in the standard terms created a contractual estoppel preventing the Defendants from denying that England was the most appropriate jurisdiction to hear the claim. Contractual estoppel is a principle that operates to hold parties to a prior agreement in a contract that a state of affairs will be the basis of their dealings with one another, even if they know that that state of affairs is not the case.

The jurisdiction clause contained a contractual forum non conveniens waiver stating: “The Bank and the Borrower agree that the courts of England are the most appropriate and convenient courts to settle Disputes and accordingly neither of them will argue to the contrary.” The clause therefore contained two elements: the first part recorded the parties’ agreement that the courts of England were the most appropriate forum, and the second part was a promise by the parties not to argue the opposite.

The second part of the clause is commonly seen in jurisdiction agreements and, in line with existing authorities, the Court held that it did not remove its residual discretion to examine whether England was in fact the appropriate forum. However, the Court found that the additional first part (the positive agreement that the courts of England were in fact the appropriate forum) created a contractual estoppel and the Defendants were therefore prevented from arguing that England was not the appropriate forum.

Key takeaways

Where parties agree a jurisdiction clause in favour of the English courts, the courts retain a discretion to consider if England is in fact the appropriate forum to resolve a dispute. However, it is a high hurdle to persuade an English court to refuse jurisdiction; a party must show very strong reasons to justify a departure from their earlier contractual agreement. Connections with another jurisdiction are unlikely to override an express jurisdiction clause where those connecting factors were foreseeable at the time of contracting.

The decision also indicates that a jurisdiction clause which includes a positive agreement that the English courts are the most appropriate to settle any disputes will provide another basis on which a party can enforce the clause. Such wording may create a contractual estoppel which will stop a party raising forum non conveniens arguments at all. Although this is a first instance decision and will not be binding on other courts, commercial parties should consider including both elements of the contractual waiver clause discussed above in their jurisdiction agreements.

With thanks to Amanpreet Bajwa for her assistance in preparing this post.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post