In BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor v Municipio de Mariana & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 294, the Court of Appeal considered whether seeking an anti-suit injunction or equivalent remedy from a foreign court, which is designed to restrain claims being brought in England and Wales, amounted to a criminal contempt of the English Court.

In allowing the appeal in favour of the BHP Group, the Court of Appeal held that such action would not amount to criminal contempt, save in exceptional circumstances which did not exist on the facts of this case. The decision will be of interest to commercial parties involved in cross-border disputes where there are concurrent proceedings in both the English courts and a foreign court.

Background

The underlying claim arose in connection with the collapse of the Fundão Dam in southeast Brazil. The claimants, including 46 Brazilian municipalities (the Municipality Claimants), brought a claim in the English Court against the BHP Group (BHP) seeking damages for losses arising out of this incident. BHP challenged the English Court’s jurisdiction to hear the claim, which was successful at first instance but overturned on appeal. The underlying claim therefore proceeded in the English Court and, as complex group litigation, a number of key liability issues were selected for determination at a first stage trial (which took place between October 2024 and March 2025). This included an issue raised by BHP as to whether the Municipality Claimants had standing to pursue the claims outside Brazil under Brazilian constitutional law.****

About four months before the first stage trial was due to be heard, BHP procured the commencement of a claim in the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court by the Brazilian Mining Association (the IBRAM Claim). The IBRAM Claim sought as final relief: (i) a declaration that the Municipality Claimants had no standing to bring claims outside Brazil and (ii) an order requiring them to discontinue foreign proceedings and refrain from issuing new foreign proceedings (as well as interim relief including the immediate suspension of dealings between the Municipality Claimants and their foreign lawyers that had as their object the pursuit of claims outside Brazil).

Post commencement, the IBRAM Claim could not be withdrawn by the claimant – it raised a constitutional issue that would be decided by the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court, unless that court decided to discontinue it of its own motion.

Anti-suit injunction, criminal contempt and strike out applications

The Municipality Claimants sought an anti-suit injunction from the English Court, to restrain BHP from taking steps to promote the IBRAM Claim. BHP gave undertakings not to take any steps that would progress the IBRAM Claim, and to procure that its Brazilian subsidiary would request that IBRAM would not take any further action to pursue the IBRAM Claim. BHP complied with these undertakings but this did not result in an end to the IBRAM Claim.

In October 2024, the Municipality Claimants made an application to the English Court against BHP for criminal contempt of the English Court, alleging that BHP’s purpose in supporting the IBRAM Claim was to interfere with the administration of justice, particularly given the timing at which the proceedings had been commenced. BHP applied to strike out this application – its strike out application was dismissed at first instance.

Decision on appeal

BHP appealed to the Court of Appeal, which allowed BHP’s appeal and struck out the Municipality Claimants’ application for criminal contempt against BHP.

Relevant principles

In reaching its decision, the Court of Appeal held that criminal contempt involves conduct which is not necessarily unlawful but improper in the circumstances as it gives rise to a sufficient risk of interference with the administration of justice (even if the interference does not arise). It may or may not require an intention to interfere, but as this was not necessary to decide the Court of Appeal left this open.

In the context of an anti-suit injunction from a foreign court, the Court of Appeal observed that this translated into the following relevant principles:

  • It would be wrong for the English Court to criminalise pursuit of a foreign anti-suit injunction or equivalent, if an English Court would grant interim relief if the roles were reversed.
  • The importance of judicial comity, which requires respect for the good faith invocation of a foreign court's jurisdiction.
  • The fact that an English Court has granted or would grant anti-suit relief seeking to restrain the foreign proceedings does not automatically mean the foreign proceedings amount to criminal contempt. The applicable legal tests are different – what is oppressive for the purposes of an anti-suit injunction is not the same as what is improper for criminal contempt. Further, criminal contempt is concerned with the protection of the public interest, whereas anti-suit injunctions are concerned with the interests of private law litigants.
  • Criminal contempt must be limited to what is reasonably necessary to protect the administration of justice, which involves a balance of competing interests.

The Court of Appeal held that these principles point to the conclusion that seeking foreign anti-suit relief or equivalent can only exceptionally amount to criminal contempt.

Principles applied

On the facts, the Court of Appeal held:

  • The Brazilian Supreme Federal Court was a court of competent jurisdiction and would “obviously be the natural forum” in which to resolve the issue of the Municipality Claimants’ standing.
  • A claim there could be brought in good faith and its decision should dispose of the standing issue in the English underlying claim, as the English Court’s role in addressing foreign law issues is generally to determine what would be held by the relevant foreign court, assisted by expert evidence.
  • There could therefore have been no criminal contempt if the IBRAM Claim had been brought at the outset of English proceedings. The issue was whether the timing of procuring the IBRAM Claim just four months before the English Court would determine the standing issue, alleged to have been “initiated at a time which could cause maximum disruption to the Municipality Claimants' claims” changed the analysis.
  • The Court of Appeal held that it did not take the case into the exceptional category of cases required for criminal contempt, finding that if procuring the claim “at the outset” would not constitute criminal contempt as a matter of principle, the timing of the claim could not make it so.

Key takeaways

This decision provides important clarification on the relationship between foreign anti-suit proceedings and the English’s Court’s jurisdiction to find criminal contempt of its proceedings.

The Court of Appeal’s discussion of the applicable principles will be of interest to parties involved in cross-border litigation as lawful conduct that is nevertheless regarded as “improper” can, in exceptional cases, be in scope of the English Court’s criminal contempt jurisdiction.

However, international litigants can take comfort in the Court of Appeal’s position that seeking foreign anti-suit relief or equivalent will only exceptionally amount to criminal contempt, and in the decision in this case that late commencement of a claim for such relief from a competent foreign court, alone, did not cross the Court’s line into criminal contempt.

With thanks to Alfie Holder for his assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post