Introduction

The crisis in the Middle East has created a landscape of uncertainty for businesses with interests in the Gulf States and beyond. Supply chains are under pressure, energy markets are volatile and the continued uncertainty presents challenges to businesses with operations in the region.

This disruption will likely give rise to disputes across the region, making it essential for businesses to carefully review their contracts and business practices now to best position themselves to handle future disputes.

This article considers some of the ways businesses can protect their interests in the context of the current disruption from an English law, onshore United Arab Emirates (UAE) law, and Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) law perspective, being some of the common contractual governing laws found in the region.

Force majeure

Force majeure is a concept found in English, onshore UAE and KSA law. In general, force majeure may provide a lawful excuse to parties from performing their contracts where intervening events make performance impossible. However, the way the doctrine operates in each of these legal systems differs significantly.

Under English law, force majeure exists only to the extent it is expressly provided for in a contract. As a result, the scope and effect of any force majeure protection depends entirely on the drafting of the relevant clause. This creates an emphasis on contractual interpretation as parties will have to identify whether the current situation falls under a qualifying event (such as “war” or “armed conflict”) or if it can fall under general wording such as events “beyond the reasonable control” of parties. How a force majeure notice is to be exercised will also be a matter of contractual interpretation. Therefore, parties with an English law-governed contract should carefully construe the force majeure provisions before invoking them.

Conversely, force majeure is statutorily codified in onshore UAE and Saudi law.

Article 273 of the UAE Civil Code (CC) provides that where a supervening event, which is not the fault of either party, makes the performance of a contractual obligation impossible (not merely more difficult or more expensive), the corresponding obligation is automatically extinguished and the contract is terminated. However, the impossibility of performance must be total; where only part of the obligation becomes impossible, only that part is extinguished, and the counterparty may elect to terminate the remainder or to accept partial performance.

Similarly, under Article 294 of the Saudi Civil Transactions Law (CTL), if a supervening event beyond the parties’ control results in the impossibility of performing the contractual obligation, the affected obligation may be terminated, either in whole or in part depending on the nature of the impossibility.

Contracts governed by onshore UAE law or Saudi law may also have contractual force majeure clauses, which may provide additional contractual rights to parties beyond those granted by the force majeure provisions set out in the CC and CTL. As with English law, such provisions should be carefully construed before being relied upon.

Frustration and exceptional circumstances

While English law does not recognize a standalone concept of force majeure, it does recognize the common law concept of “frustration.”

Under this doctrine, contractual performance will be excused if certain narrow tests are met, namely, circumstances that were not contemplated at the time of contracting have made performance impossible, illegal, or radically different from what was envisioned by the parties. These are high bars, and mere hardship, increased expense, or the fact that performance has become more onerous will not suffice. Frustration cannot be demonstrated where a risk has been expressly or impliedly allocated under the terms of the relevant contract.

Where frustration applies, the contract is automatically discharged. Obligations that have already become due will survive, as will certain clauses such as jurisdiction and dispute resolution clauses. The automatic discharge happens without the need for either party to take further steps.

While onshore UAE and Saudi law do not recognize a concept of “frustration,” they do distinguish between supervening events that render performance impossible and those that render performance excessively onerous. In this way, onshore UAE and KSA law are more favorable to contractual obligors than English law.

Article 249 of the UAE CC provides that where exceptional and unforeseeable events occur which render performance of a contract excessively onerous such that the obligor is threatened with “grave loss,” a court may reduce the onerous obligation to a reasonable level. Crucially, performance does not need to be impossible, only significantly more onerous than the parties could reasonably have contemplated at the time of contracting.

Similarly, Article 97 of the KSA CTL recognizes a doctrine of exceptional circumstances, often described as “hardship.” Where extraordinary and unforeseeable events occur that render performance excessively onerous, the court may intervene to rebalance the contract, including by reducing the burden of performance to a reasonable level.

In this regard, the onshore UAE and Saudi positions are significantly different to English law, where mere hardship or increased expense will not relieve a party of its contractual obligations.

The statutory framework of the onshore UAE and KSA legal systems provide a potentially valuable avenue of relief for businesses facing conflict-related or supply chain disruption, whether because performance is impossible or simply because it has become significantly more onerous.

Business interruption and supply chain disruption

There is already significant disruption to shipping routes, energy supplies and broader supply chains across the region. Businesses that depend on the transit of goods through the Strait of Hormuz or other affected areas face the prospect of delays and interruption to their operations. Where contracts contain liquidated damages or penalty clauses (commonly found in supply or construction contracts), businesses may face significant liability for delays that are ultimately attributable to the conflict.

Under English law, parties are permitted to charge liquidated damages or penalties in order to protect their genuine commercial interests. That is, English law tends to be permissive of parties seeking to enforce a liquidated damages clause and will rarely intervene to strike out the penalty.

Conversely, where contracts governed by onshore UAE law contain liquidated damages clauses, Article 390 of the UAE CC permits a court to vary the rate of compensation, so that it is equal to the actual loss suffered. This may afford significant protection to businesses who may be facing penalties related to supply chain disruption.

Similarly, pursuant to Article 178 of the KSA CTL, while parties are free to agree liquidated damages provisions, the courts may increase or reduce the agreed amount to reflect the actual harm suffered. KSA courts may do so where a debtor can demonstrate that the calculation of liquidated damages was excessive compared to the loss actually suffered, or that the underlying obligation was partially performed.

Article 179(3) of the KSA CTL allows a court to increase the agreed amount in order to match the actual loss suffered by the obligee. However, this right of recourse is limited, as a creditor must show that it was the debtor’s breach that caused the harm to exceed the agreed-upon compensation, and that the breach was wilful or grossly negligent.

Practical steps

In response to the disruption in the region, clients should conduct a comprehensive review of all contracts, paying particular attention to their governing law clauses, and consider how the above issues may affect their obligations under those contracts.

Comply with contractual obligations

Businesses should ensure that they continue, as best they can, to comply with their contractual obligations, especially notice requirements.

Care is needed when sending any notice asserting force majeure or frustration, as some contracts require notice be given within a certain period after a frustration/force majeure event, and a failure to do so may mean that the ability to rely on the clause is lost.

Further, parties should continue to perform their obligations as best they can and to carefully document these efforts in order to demonstrate that, if performance becomes genuinely impossible or significantly more onerous, they can demonstrate the impact of intervening events that has caused them to terminate the contract, and that a force majeure notice is not simply an attempt to avoid a suddenly unfavorable contract.

Claims of frustration or force majeure or hardship are fact-specific and should be accompanied by proper documentation to demonstrate how it is that a contract has suddenly become more onerous or impossible to perform. If this evidence cannot be furnished, then any claim for relief may fail.

Gather evidence

When a business’ operations look like they are heading to a dispute, parties should do all they can to consolidate as much contemporaneous evidence as possible. Inhouse counsel should attempt to speak to personnel who have a hand in operations, and who may hold relevant information. Such documentary evidence, including records of disruptions, mitigation efforts and communications with counterparties, should be recovered and stored centrally, as they will be critical to any forthcoming dispute. As best they can, parties should maintain records of operational delays and their causes, as well as their actual losses. Doing so will help parties make force majeure claims or challenge liquidated damages claims.

Avoiding and preparing for disputes

Businesses should proactively engage with their counterparties; such engagement should be done promptly and with decision-makers at an appropriate level. Discussions and outcomes should be well documented so that there are no disputes as to what has and has not been agreed. Early and constructive engagement can often reduce the risk of prolonged dispute resolution.

Among other things, parties should consider whether contractual variations or standstill agreements may be appropriate to preserve commercial relationships while the situation remains fluid.

Importantly, businesses should consider the governing law of their contract when they are engaging with their counterparties. For example, generic reservations of rights are unlikely to be effective under English law; rather reservations of rights must identify the specific rights or defenses that are reserved and only be in place for a short period. On the other hand, as a matter of onshore UAE and KSA law, there are good faith obligations with which parties must comply when carrying out a contract and when engaging with one another. Businesses should also bear in mind that some legal systems, such as onshore UAE and Saudi law, do not recognize “without prejudice” privilege in principle; therefore care should be exercised when making disclosures in such discussions. Taking legal advice at an early stage can ensure that any risks surrounding business discussions can be mitigated.

Where a dispute seems inevitable, businesses should seek legal advice on the appropriate steps to preserve their position in any forthcoming arbitration or litigation. This includes whether they have complied with any contractual or statutory pre-dispute steps. Failure to do so may lead to time-consuming and costly jurisdictional disputes.

Conclusion

Delays or inability to transit through the Strait of Hormuz, flow on supply chain issues, and general economic shocks are all likely to cause problems for businesses with operations in the Gulf region. While this will likely cause all businesses some difficulty, those that take immediate steps may position themselves better than others to weather any coming storms.

Businesses that act quickly to review their contracts to ensure they understand their rights and obligations, who collect evidence to back those rights, and who engage proactively with their counterparties will find the wind at their backs once smoother sailing is again possible.

Issue 24

  • content-type:insights/publication
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/hubs/international-arbitration-report/issue-24
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
International arbitration report
/en-middle-east/insights/topics/international-arbitration-report-hub

Contact