Recent developments in the Middle East have introduced a degree of operational and commercial uncertainty across the region. In particular, constraints affecting maritime transit through key corridors such as the recent closure of the Strait of Hormuz have posed significant challenges to the construction sector, including potentially contributing to delays in the procurement of materials, escalation of costs and disruption to established delivery schedules.

Many of these challenges are not new to market participants and in several respects mirror dynamics experienced during the COVID 19 period. As a result, stakeholders can draw on the lessons from that period to manage risk and maintain continuity of operations in the current circumstances.

Whilst a considerable body of commentary exists on the principles underpinning relevant legal concepts such as force majeure, the practical lessons that have emerged from the wave of COVID-19-related claims are arguably of greater value to employers, contractors and their advisers. The construction industry across the region has now had the benefit of several years of hindsight since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, during which those lessons have been tested and refined in practice.

In this article, we discuss five issues that arose following the COVID-19 pandemic which are relevant to today’s circumstances and draw together a number of practical recommendations for parties engaged in construction contracts in the Middle East.

1. Force majeure provisions

As was observed following the COVID-19 pandemic, the current conflict is giving rise to significant supply chain disruption, including interrupted shipping routes, travel restrictions due to airspace closures, increased energy prices and constrained availability of critical materials and equipment.

Force majeure and change-in-circumstance clauses will once again come under close scrutiny, as parties on each side of construction contracts seek to minimise their exposure to the effects of the conflict. Key questions will include whether infrastructure damage, supply shocks, increased costs and project delays were reasonably foreseeable at the time of contracting and whether the relevant risks were expressly allocated under the contract.

Whilst there will certainly be unique nuances applicable to the current conflict, the COVID-19 pandemic offers an instructive precedent in this regard. The outcome of parties' claims frequently turned on the precise contractual wording and, in particular on whether the affected party had supporting evidence of the impact of the events and whether it could demonstrate that performance had been rendered truly impossible, rather than merely more onerous or expensive. A similarly rigorous approach to contractual analysis at an early stage will be essential as parties navigate the disruptions arising from the present conflict.

2. Implications of delay in formalising force majeure claims

One of the most striking features of the COVID-19 experience has been the considerable delay between the onset of the pandemic and the crystallisation of related claims. Parties across the region continue to grapple with COVID-19-related disputes, with claims still being advanced and resolved well into 2026. A significant contributing factor to this delay has been the good faith efforts of parties to negotiate and arrive at mutually acceptable solutions to overcome COVID-19-related challenges as events unfolded – a pattern that bears a notable resemblance to the approach currently being adopted by parties navigating the ongoing situation in the Middle East. While this prolonged timeline is not unusual in the context of major construction projects, it carries important practical and legal implications.

First, it underscores the importance of contemporaneous record-keeping. Where claims are pursued months or even years after the relevant events, the quality and completeness of project records become critical. The collaboration observed between parties during COVID-19 was in part related to a general assumption that the pandemic would be a short-term event which could be overcome informally. Parties that maintained detailed logs of disruption events, correspondence regarding delays and evidence of mitigation efforts have found themselves in a significantly stronger position than those that did not. Similar parallels may be drawn with the current situation, as parties increasingly come to terms with the possibility that the conflict and its effects may prove enduring beyond a few months. This makes it all the more essential for parties to compile and preserve contemporaneous records of the conflict's impact at the earliest opportunity.

Second, the long lead time between a force majeure event and the resolution of associated claims highlights the need for robust document retention policies. In a region where projects are often delivered at pace and key project communications may be sent across a variety of channels (including emails, instant messaging platforms, and other informal media), record-keeping can often fall down the list of priorities. The COVID-19 experience serves as a timely reminder that this is a false economy.

COVID-19 caused severe disruption to global supply chains, and construction projects in the Gulf were particularly exposed given their reliance on the international procurement of plant, materials, specialist consultants, and labour. COVID-19 also revealed a significant gap in many parties' understanding of how supply chain disruption interacts with force majeure provisions - a gap that remains highly relevant in the context of current geopolitical risks in the region.

In practice, many contractors struggled to establish a direct causal link between the COVID-19 and specific supply chain delays. The disruption was often diffuse, affecting multiple links in the supply chain simultaneously, and was compounded by pre-existing logistical or scheduling challenges. Demonstrating that a particular delay was attributable to the force majeure event, rather than to other contributing factors, proved a formidable evidential burden.

The issue of mitigation is also relevant to establishing force majeure and, in particular, whether alternative sources of supply were reasonably available. The Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation Judgment 835 of 2021 provides a salutary warning. A contractor advanced a force majeure claim in respect of delays to construction works, contending that essential equipment could no longer be imported from China. The Court held that the contractor had failed to prove that the materials in question were in fact sourced from China, and that the determinative issue for a force majeure claim under the previous UAE Civil Code was whether performance had become truly impossible. This ruling carries particular resonance in the current environment as key plant and material may still be procurable from alternative sources, albeit at a higher cost. The availability of such alternatives, though inconvenient or more expensive, may preclude reliance on force majeure provisions under some laws.

Looking ahead, parties would be well advised to consider how their contracts address supply chain disruption as a distinct category of risk. This includes examining whether force majeure clauses are drafted with sufficient breadth to capture not only the triggering event itself, but also its downstream consequences for procurement, shipping, and the availability of human resources.

Equally, the COVID-19 underscored the importance of early and proactive engagement with the supply chain when a force majeure event occurs. Contractors who communicated promptly with suppliers and sub-contractors, actively sought alternative sources of supply and carefully documented the steps taken to mitigate delays were materially better placed to substantiate claims.

4. Price fluctuations and readjustment

The economic aftershocks of COVID-19 brought the question of price risk into sharp focus. Construction materials experienced significant price volatility during and after the pandemic, and many contractors found themselves locked into fixed-price contracts that offered little or no protection against cost escalation.

In many standard form contracts used in the UAE and Saudi Arabia, price fluctuation mechanisms are either absent or narrowly drafted, often requiring contractors to absorb cost increases unless a specific threshold is met. COVID-19 demonstrated that such provisions can threaten the viability of projects when prices move sharply and unpredictably – which has negative consequences for both contractors and employers.

A force majeure event that fundamentally alters those assumptions can render the original pricing basis wholly inadequate, yet many contracts provide no clear mechanism for a cost adjustment. In light of the current uncertainty in the region, parties should consider whether their new contracts ought to include more flexible pricing mechanisms for force majeure events. It is worth noting that there were many cases during COVID-19 where there was no contractual provision permitting a readjustment to the pricing mechanism, yet employers acknowledged that a readjustment due to the impact of COVID-19 was necessary for the viability of the project. However, relying on such an approach poses risks for both contractors and employers.

5. Company policy as employer directions

Perhaps one of the most practically significant (and least discussed) features of the COVID-19 period was the role played by company-wide policies issued by employers and project owners. Across the Gulf, many employers introduced social distancing requirements, sanitation and PPE policies, as well as the expectation of completing tasks remotely, where possible, in response to COVID-19. These policies dictated how contractors were required to operate on site, including restrictions on workforce numbers, social distancing requirements, testing and quarantine procedures, and revised access arrangements.

Although these policies were frequently framed as general company directives rather than project-specific instructions, their practical effect was often indistinguishable from a formal employer direction under the construction contract. Contractors were required to comply, and compliance routinely gave rise to additional cost and delay. Despite this, many contractors did not treat these policies as variations or employer directions at the time they were issued and, as a result, failed to submit timely notices or claims in accordance with the contractual machinery. This, in turn, led to many contractors submitting inadequately substantiated claims long after the relevant directives were issued - claims which employers found difficult to engage with in any meaningful way. This dynamic can itself become a source of dispute, with avoidable delay and cost being incurred by employers and contractors alike.

As the current situation continues, we are likely to see an increase in risk assessment, joint safety protocols and documented site decisions (for example, restrictions on the access to the site during different periods). Employers issuing site-wide or company-wide directives that affect the manner in which works are carried out should be aware that such directives may give rise to claims for additional time and cost, regardless of how they are labelled. Contractors, for their part, should be alive to the potential contractual significance of such policies and ensure that they are captured and assessed through the lens of the contract's variation and claims provisions from the outset.

Practical recommendations

Drawing together the lessons outlined above, we recommend that parties engaged in construction projects in the Gulf and further afield take the following steps:

  1. Contracts should be reviewed to ensure that force majeure clauses are sufficiently broad to capture not only the triggering event but also its consequential effects on supply chains, labour availability, and material costs.
  2. Parties should develop and maintain robust record-keeping practices (including maintaining records of programmes, status of the works, labour on site, photos of site damage, correspondence with suppliers, invoices and minutes of meetings), recognising that claims arising from force majeure events may not crystallise for several years.
  3. Price fluctuation provisions should be carefully considered at the contract drafting/amendment stage, with a realistic assessment of the allocation of cost risk between the parties. Where bill of quantities pricing is used, the contract should address the circumstances in which rates may be revisited in the event of a material change in the cost environment.
  4. Early and proactive engagement with the supply chain is essential when a force majeure event occurs, and the steps taken to mitigate its effects should be carefully documented.
  5. Both employers and contractors should pay close attention to the contractual characterisation of the company-wide policies and directives issued by employers and project owners that affect site operations. Where such policies have the practical effect of an employer instruction, they should be treated accordingly under the construction contract, with appropriate notices issued and records maintained.

For further insights and guidance, access our series of articles which discuss key issues and challenges that arise in construction projects in the Middle East and ways to manage risk and mitigate disputes: Construction insights | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright

The authors would like to give thanks to Trainee Solicitor Louis Ribiere-Male for their contribution to this article.

Contact