In February 2026 the First-tier Tribunal issued its judgment in Charge My Street Limited v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 318 TC. The Tribunal’s decision raises the possibility that public EV charging point operators may be entitled to charge VAT on supplies of electricity to customers at the reduced 5% rate; a consequence that would have significant commercial implications for those operators and consumers alike. While those operators should continue to charge VAT at the standard 20% rate in the meantime, there is nothing to stop protective repayment claims being made now in light of the possibility that the Tribunal’s decision is subsequently confirmed in the higher courts.
The taxpayer’s appeal concerned the supply by it of electricity from public EV charging points. HMRC contended that those supplies were subject to VAT at the standard 20% rate, and that the reduced 5% rate, which applies to supplies of electricity for domestic use, did not apply. This position was consistent with HMRC’s published guidance. The Tribunal allowed the taxpayer’s appeal in part, holding that the reduced 5% rate of VAT should apply to supplies of electricity made to drivers from public EV chargers where those supplies did not exceed 1,000 kilowatt hours per customer, per EV charging point.
When the judgment was handed down it generated substantial media coverage, and understandably so given the potential implications it could have for public EV charging suppliers, EV charging infrastructure investors and consumers. Since then, HMRC have issued a new briefing paper (link) confirming that HMRC’s existing practice of applying VAT at the 20% standard rate continues to be effective, and HMRC have appealed the Tribunal’s decision. While the appeal to the Upper Tribunal should mean that we have a judgment which establishes a precedent on the application of the domestic electricity supply rules in due course, it may well be one that proceeds to the higher courts given the wider policy implications.
Although HMRC’s policy of applying VAT at the standard rate continues to be in place, this does not prohibit potentially affected taxpayers from lodging protective repayment claims for historic overpaid VAT. Any decision on whether to proceed with making a repayment claim should consider the following:
- Time limits – there is typically a four-year limit on correcting errors in historic VAT returns.
- Procedural formalities – the Value Added Tax Act 1994, and VAT Regulations 1995 apply conditions to the nature and content of any repayment claim for recovery of over-declared VAT.
- Customer arrangements – HMRC may seek to reject any claims where the economic burden of the VAT being reclaimed remains with the underlying consumer; referred to as the ‘unjust enrichment defence’. Customers may also be entitled to make contractual claims against the taxpayer in respect of historic overcharged VAT; repayment claims should mitigate the risk that the taxpayer is left out-of-pocket should those claims be successful. The extent to which overcharged VAT can or should be refunded under the terms of taxpayers’ customer arrangements should therefore be considered.
- Timings – in light of HMRC appealing the Tribunal’s decision, any repayment claim is likely to be stayed pending the outcome of the ongoing litigation.
There are also practical aspects to consider in light of the Tribunal’s decision. As the Tribunal held that the reduced 5% rate applied to supplies of electricity that did not exceed 1,000 kilowatt hours per customer, per EV charging point, it is important that systems are in place to record these metrics to demonstrate that those conditions are met. Similarly, as the taxpayer’s appeal was not upheld in connection with certain arrangements it had in place with third-party apps (where it was third parties who were considered to be making the supplies of electricity to consumers), it is important that any contractual terms agreed with third parties are reviewed to ensure that they reflect the economic and commercial reality of the relevant arrangements.
Given the potentially significant financial implications of this case, we may yet be some way from getting confirmation on the application of the relevant law. This case should be viewed in the context of the wider policy agenda of how the government determines it should tax EV vehicles (such as via the proposed Electric Vehicle Excise Duty) while simultaneously encouraging their uptake, as well as eliminating perceived unfairness in the tax system, given the current VAT treatment potentially penalises consumers that do not have access to off-road parking. With these wider policy aspects still in flux, we await the publishing of HM Treasury’s review into the cost of public EV charging, as well as the outcome of the parliamentary Transport Committee’s ‘supercharging the EV transition’ inquiry.